Delay Analysis in Construction Project Disputes

Senior Consultant, Ernst & Young
Accurate identification of the root causes of project delays and the allocation of responsibility among the parties involved, is crucial for effective project management. By adopting best practices and conducting detailed analyses, parties can ensure fair and equitable resolutions to disputes, ultimately fostering transparency and credibility in the construction industry.

Shubham Singh, Senior Consultant, Ernst & Young


The construction industry has seen a marked increase in disputes, largely due to delays in project completion. Recent reports indicate that nearly 50% of construction projects in India face delays, leading to disputes over Extensions of Time (EOT).

In any construction project, the central figures are the Employer, the Contractor, and possibly an Engineer appointed by the Employer. Contractual agreements between these parties establish specific obligations tied to a defined timeframe. The validity period of a contract, though agreed upon by the parties, must be clearly defined. Failure to meet these obligations within the stipulated time may result in damages as outlined in the contract conditions. To account for unforeseen delays that are not the Contractor's fault and could not have been foreseen at the contract's inception, EOT clauses are often incorporated. These clauses provide a critical safeguard for the Contractor, offering relief from Liquidated Damages (LD) and establishing a revised project completion timeline.

Accurate identification of the root causes of project delays and the allocation of responsibility among the parties involved, is crucial for effective project management. This determination is key in deciding whether to impose LDs for delayed project completion or grant an EOT. Furthermore, it enables the Contractor to substantiate associated costs through a Prolongation claim, particularly when the delays are deemed excusable and compensable.

The Indian Contract Act, 18721, serves as the foundation for contract law in India, providing general principles that shape contractual relationships. While the Act does not explicitly address time extensions or compensation in the context of construction contracts, certain sections are relevant in cases where parties seek redress for non-performance of obligations.

The construction industry has seen a marked increase in disputes

 

Legal Framework: Understanding the Indian Contract Act, 1872

Sections 51 to 54 of the Indian Contract Act address the principles of reciprocal promises, the order of performance, and the consequences of default in contracts involving such promises. These sections underscore the concept of the interdependence of obligations. In construction contracts, where promises made by both the Employer and the Contractor are closely linked, understanding this interdependence is critical. The Act stipulates that when the fulfilment of one promise is a precondition for another, the second party cannot perform its duty until the first obligation is fulfilled, which has significant implications in cases of delays.

Section 55 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, emphasizes the significance of time in contractual agreements, particularly when 'time is of the essence.' If the parties intend for time to be of the essence, and one party fails to fulfil obligations within the specified timeframe, the contract becomes voidable at the option of the promisee. In construction projects, where timely completion is crucial, Section 55 underscores the importance of meeting deadlines. However, when time is not of the essence, Section 55 offers a nuanced approach: while the contract doesn't become voidable due to missed deadlines, the promisee is entitled to compensation for losses incurred due to the delay.

An important aspect of Section 55 pertains to cases where the promisee accepts performance at a time other than originally agreed upon. If the promisee intends to claim compensation for losses due to delayed performance, they must notify the promisor of this intention at the time of acceptance. In the context of EOT proposals, including the intent to claim cost compensation (prolongation) and price escalation due to delays is essential, aligning with Section 55.

Case Law and the Importance of Thorough Analysis

Several notable cases underscore the importance of conducting thorough delay analyses. For example, in Ircon International Ltd. vs. C. R. Sons Builders & Development Pvt. Ltd.2, the Delhi High Court upheld an arbitrator's decision to apportion delays on a 50:50 basis, a decision influenced by the absence of a comprehensive delay analysis during the submission and approval of the EOT proposal. Similar outcomes were seen in Vascon Engineers Ltd. vs. Union of India and Union of India3 vs. C & C Construction Ltd.,4 where delays were apportioned without robust analysis, leading to arbitrary allocations.

These cases highlight that an EOT does not automatically entitle the Contractor to a prolongation claim, nor does delay project completion automatically entitle the Employer to impose damages. Identifying the causes of delays and determining their attribution to each party, especially when these delays impact the overall project timeline, is essential5.

Best Practices for Delay Analysis

When proposing or granting an EOT, it is crucial to explicitly reserve the right to claim compensation, damages, or escalation. This intent must be clearly expressed at the time of the EOT proposal. The case of Ircon International Ltd. vs. Delhi Metro Corporation6 illustrates this point well, where compensation was granted for only one of three EOTs because the party had explicitly reserved its rights. A similar principle was upheld in Mascon Multiservices & Consultants Pvt. Ltd. vs. Bharat Oman Refineries Ltd.7, where the Bombay High Court ruled that damages are payable only if notice to claim compensation is given at the time of accepting delayed performance.

To facilitate effective delay analysis, parties can refer to international best practices, such as those recommended by the Society of Construction Law (UK) Delay and Disruption Protocol (February 2017)8 and AACE International's Recommended Practice No. 29R-03 for Forensic Schedule Analysis9. These protocols outline methodologies for delay analysis, including Impacted As-Planned10 (IAP), As-Planned vs. As-Built (APAB), Time Impact Analysis (TIA), and Window Slice Analysis. The choice of methodology should be tailored to the specific project and stage of analysis, ensuring a comprehensive and accurate assessment of delays.

The Role of Delay Analysis in Construction Disputes

When an EOT is granted, it is crucial for the Employer to explicitly state their intent regarding the imposition of LDs and whether the extension is granted with or without compensation for delays attributed to their actions. This transparent communication aligns with the spirit of Section 55, providing clarity and promoting fairness in addressing delays.

It is common practice for some professionals to communicate delays generally and request EOTs without proper analysis. Due to the lack of comprehensive analysis, when disputes escalate to litigation, courts often struggle to comprehend the intricacies of the case. In Dispute Resolution Board (DRB)/Dispute Adjudication Board (DAB) or arbitration proceedings, technical experts are typically involved, offering a better understanding of complex cases. However, in litigation, where judges and lawyers lead, presenting a case with solid evidence, detailed analysis, and clarity is crucial for achieving a favourable outcome.

Final Recommendations

Performing thorough delay analysis is essential for both Contractors requesting an EOT and Employers seeking damages for delayed project completion. A detailed analysis helps substantiate which party is responsible for the delays and provides a solid foundation for claims or defences. The absence of such analysis can lead to inaccurate delay apportionments, resulting in significant losses for the affected party. By adopting best practices and conducting detailed analyses, parties can ensure fair and equitable resolutions to EOT disputes, ultimately fostering transparency and credibility in the construction industry.

  1. India Contract Act, 1872
  2. IRCON International Ltd. vs. C.R Sons Builders & Development Pvt. Ltd., (2020) DHC: 965
  3. Vascon Engineers Ltd. vs. Union of India, (2021) DHC:2828
  4. Union of India vs. C & C Construction Ltd., (2021) DHC: 3457
  5. Shubham Singh & Chitesh Thakre, Guidance on Extension of Time in Construction Contracts, 07 IJSREM (2023), doi: 10.55041/IJSREM19431
  6. Ircon International Ltd. vs. Delhi Metro Corporation, (2023) DHC: 7369
  7. Mascon Multiservices & Consultants Pvt. Ltd. vs. Bharat Oman Refineries Ltd., (2014) SCC Online Bom 4832
  8. See Society of Construction Law Delay and Disruption Protocol, Feb. 2017 Society of Construction Law – United Kingdom.
  9. AACE International, International Recommended Practice No. 29R-03 - Forensic Schedule Analysis - TCM Framework: 6.4 – Forensic Performance Assessment, (2011).
  10. Shubham Singh & Chitesh Thakre, 'Time in Focus: The Strategic Application of Impacted As-Planned Method of Delay Analysis in Construction Dispute Resolution', (2024), 90, Arbitration: The International Journal of Arbitration, Mediation and Dispute Management, Issue 2, pp. 180-196, https://kluwerlawonline.com/journalarticle/Arbitration:+The+International+Journal+of+Arbitration,+Mediation+and+Dispute+Management/90.2/AMDM2024020.

The author can be contacted at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

NBM&CW - OCTOBER 2024

2 comments

Leave your comment

In reply to Some User
×

Terms & Condition

By checking this, you agree with the following:
  1. To accept full responsibility for the comment that you submit.
  2. To use this function only for lawful purposes.
  3. Not to post defamatory, abusive, offensive, racist, sexist, threatening, vulgar, obscene, hateful or otherwise inappropriate comments, or to post comments which will constitute a criminal offense or give rise to civil liability.
  4. Not to post or make available any material which is protected by copyright, trade mark or other proprietary right without the express permission of the owner of the copyright, trade mark or any other proprietary right.
  5. To evaluate for yourself the accuracy of any opinion, advice or other content.
Due Diligence & Technical Audits: Save Billions in Construction

Due Diligence & Technical Audits: Save Billions in Construction

Construction, particularly of critical infrastructure projects like dams, barrages, and tunnels, require due diligence and technical audits for identifying risks, ensuring regulatory compliance, and optimizing project execution.

Read more ...

Vulnerability Atlas of India by BMTPC: Unique Tool For Disaster Management

Vulnerability Atlas of India by BMTPC: Unique Tool For Disaster Management

Brought out by BMTPC, the Vulnerability Atlas of India, is the only document to tabulate damage risk to housing stock across regions of India. It highlights areas prone to natural hazards like earthquakes, high winds, cyclones

Read more ...

Overcoming Delays in Large Infrastructure Construction Projects

Overcoming Delays in Large Infrastructure Construction Projects

The key to rapid construction project speed & overcoming delays lies in transitioning from project management to flow management for effective collaboration amongst all the stakeholders.

Read more ...

Life Cycle Assessment of Construction Projects to Enhance Sustainability

Life Cycle Assessment of Construction Projects to Enhance Sustainability

An evaluation of the environmental impacts associated with a project across its entire lifecycle - from raw material extraction and processing to construction, operation, and maintenance, enables stakeholders to identify opportunities

Read more ...

Integrated Automation Platforms in Project Management Improve Efficiency

Integrated Automation Platforms in Project Management Improve Efficiency

Automation creates efficiency by optimising and not replacing, human effort and should therefore be welcomed by organisations seeking to improve their project delivery record. Varghese Daniel, Co-Founder & CEO Wrench Solutions

Read more ...

Managing Cost and Time Overruns of Megaprojects

Managing Cost and Time Overruns of Megaprojects

Megaprojects are large-scale, complex ventures that take many years to develop and build, involve public and private stakeholders, and transform the area in which they are located. They have a higher value, a higher level of aspiration, longer lead

Read more ...

Effective Materials Management in Construction Projects

Effective Materials Management in Construction Projects

While materials count for a considerable amount of construction costs, the way materials are managed seems to be improvised rather than approached methodically. In the construction industry, one of the common challenges people face

Read more ...

Sustainable Operations Management of High-Rise Project

Sustainable Operations Management of High-Rise Project

With an ambition of providing housing for all citizens in India, the drive towards resource efficiency building operations is all-time high given the constraints in allocation of resources and their utilization, writes Mamta Rawat of Conserve

Read more ...

Benefits of Project Management in Developing India's Infrastructure

Benefits of Project Management in Developing India's Infrastructure

During the past couple of years, India has enjoyed the privilege of being amongst the most favored investment destinations of the world. With the sharp vision of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and compelling

Read more ...

Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Ordinance 2015 Provisions & Legal Issues

Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Ordinance 2015 Provisions & Legal Issues

In a significant development for Indian arbitration law, the President of India has formally adopted the Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Ordinance 2015 (the "Ordinance"), which will bring about major and long-awaited reforms to arbitration in India. The Ordinance amends Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996 and seeks in particular to eliminate

Read more ...

Raj Kalady

Redefining India – Accelerating Infrastructure Projects Through Project Management

In the last two decades, India has emerged as one of the fastest-growing economies in the world. According to a Citi group report, following the reforms undertaken by Government of India, the GDP is

Read more ...

A Study of Constructability Issues Related to Various Stages of Design and Construction Process

A Study of Constructability Issues Related to Various Stages of Design and Construction Process

The increasing levels of competition and the introduction of manufacturing concepts within the industry led to specialization. Such specialization led to the separation of design and construction facilities. The increasing complexity of many projects makes it more and more difficult for the designers to be fully aware of all the implications of their

Read more ...

Construction Claims

Model for Processing Construction Claims

With growing standards, advanced technologies, and owner-desired additions and changes, construction projects are becoming more and more complex, while the successful completion of projects has been thought to depend mainly

Read more ...

Obligations of Parties & Provisions of Claims in Modern Construction Contracts

Obligations of Parties & Provisions of Claims in Modern Construction Contracts

Construction contracts usually contain notice-of-claim provisions. The contractor must, within a stated period of time, notify the project owner in writing of any occurrence which may give rise to a claim for additional compensation under the contract. The policy behind these requirements is sound. Owners should have the opportunity to respond to

Read more ...

Termination of Contract

Termination of Contract Under Old FIDIC

Most commercial construction contracts include provisions allowing either party to terminate a contract for cause (also referred to as a termination for "default"). Unlike terminations for convenience,

Read more ...

Position of Engineer & Independent Engineer In Standard Forms of Contracts

Position of Engineer & Independent Engineer In Standard Forms of Contracts

The engineer is generally responsible for issuing the completion certificates and supervising any tests that have been contractually agreed as well as establishing that payments to the Contractor can be made, in funded

Read more ...

Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns - Expedite Infrastructure Projects

Study on Project Schedule and Cost Overruns - Expedite Infrastructure Projects

The KPMG in India – Project Management Institute (PMI) study was initiated on the request of MoSPI, which highlights the major reasons for schedule and cost overruns across major sector's infrastructure

Read more ...

PPP Audit of Infra Project - Importance and Implication

PPP Audit of Infra Project - Importance and Implication

Purnima Bajpai, Reliance Infrastructure, Pune. A contentious issue in the context of PPP arrangements and their audit relates to the scope of audit by Supreme Audit Institutions (SAI), in view of the

Read more ...

To get latest updates on whatsapp, Save +91 93545 87773 and send us a 'Saved' message
Click Here to Subscribe to Our eNewsletter.