Challenges to Elevatoring in India

TAK Mathews, Principal Consultant, TAK Consulting

TWIN elevators running at global tk headquarter in Essen Germany

The 146.6m high Pyramid of Khufu (also known as Pyramid of Giza) in Egypt, completed in 2570 BC, and the 122m high Jetavanaramaya in Sri Lanka on the Indian sub-continent completed in 301 AD (source: https://www.realmofhistory.com) stand testimony to man’s tall ambitions from prehistoric times. Closer home, we had the 73m Qutub Minar, a brick minaret of a comparatively newer 1220 AD vintage. Without exception, these were all structures principally driven by religious or political compulsions and not for human habitation.

The reference to a tall building for habitable purposes can be found in the bible “… And they said, let us build us a city and a tower, whose top may reach unto heaven; and let us make us a name……..”(source: Genesis 11: 4). Researchers like the late Professor J E Gordon have estimated that this building could probably have reached a height of 2 km. The biblical reference goes to elaborate that the building did not get completed as God intervened and confused the language so that people had no option but to abandon the project and disperse around the world. However, in all likelihood, the disruption would not have required God’s intervention.

In reality, till the middle of the 19th century, the tallest buildings for human habitation were limited to 6 floors as climbing so many stairs was just not practical (reference Wikipedia). Elisha Graves Otis’ “All Safe Gentlemen” demonstration of a safe elevator at the New York World's Fair at the New York Crystal Palace in 1853 changed all that. This one invention singlehandedly provided the impetus to realistic tall ambitions that continue to alter the skylines of the cities of the world.

After the structure, for which the know-how and material have existed from ancient days, what made a tall building a sustainable reality is the invention of the safe elevator. Today’s reality is that at many projects, landscaping and toilet fittings take priority over elevators through all stages of the project – design, procurement, execution and operation.

Challenges in Elevatoring
Low priority allotted to elevatoring

This is the challenge number 1, which in turn sets the base for the other challenges.

Low understanding of the science
The science of traffic analysis which forms the foundation of elevatoring design is complex. Unfortunately, not many in the field are well versed in this critical science. It is highly unlikely that the expert providing the elevatoring recommendation would have a copy of the elevatoring bibles like Gina Barney’s 400-page Elevator Traffic Handbook or George Strakosch’s 600-page Vertical Transportation Handbook, let alone have put in the effort to master this science.

Challenges to Vertical Transportation

With the availability of powerful software to carry out traffic analysis, many designers venture to provide design recommendations without the required mastery of the subject. As Richard Peters, the author of Elevate, while introducing his popular traffic analysis software warns, “Elevate is an extremely powerful traffic analysis tool. However, it will not make the user an elevator traffic analysis expert.”

The lack of understanding and appreciation also extends to how the recommendations are implemented. For instance, the placement and sizing of elevators tend to be dictated by the aesthetic requirements or FSI/FAR compulsions without recognising that the quality of service that can be provided by 8 elevators in a group is not the same as 2 groups of 4 elevators or 4 groups of 2 elevators.


NBM&CW November 2019

Click Here
To Know More / Contact The Manufacturer
Please provide your details we will contact you as soon as possible
Please let us know your name.
Invalid Input
Please let us know your Designation.
Invalid Input
Please let us know your City.
Please let us know your State.
Please let us know your Country.
Please let us know your Contact Number.
Please let us know your email address.
Please brief your query.

Elevatoring in Highrise Buildings Needs Specialized Approach

Amit Gossain, Managing Director, KONE India, Sebi Joseph, President, Otis India, Manish Mehan, CEO- thyssenkrupp Elevator (India), and Mr. Junichi Kyushima, Managing Director, Toshiba Johnson Elevators (India) Pvt. Ltd. share their views Read More ...

International Sourcing Exposition for Elevators & Escalators 2020

The first edition of the biannual International Sourcing Exposition for Elevators & Escalators 2020 (ISEE) is scheduled to be held from 5-7 November 2019 at Hall 4, at Bombay Exhibition Centre in Mumbai. The first edition of ISEE Read More ...

ATG: Innovation and performance

Alliance Tire Group (ATG) presented outstanding tire innovations for a wide range of machines from backhoes and skid steer loaders to excavators, heavy loaders and forklifts. Amongst other best-selling Alliance and Galaxy treads Read More ...

KONE: Making the Impossible, Possible at Beijing’s Tallest Building

The world’s cities are changing rapidly & skyscrapers are redefining our skylines. And at the heart of the Beijing city stands “China Zun” – A 528 (1,732 ft) meters high tower in Beijing comprising of 108 floors. The tower is a supertall skyscraper Read More ...

Elevators: Driving Urban Mobility

Elevator manufacturers are developing technologies that enable higher performance, greater safety and comfort, and higher energy efficiency in the design and development of their elevators. They are also catering to Read More ...

KONE India - launches new elevators for the mid-range segment with visuals inspired by the Navratna

Leading elevator and escalator manufacturing company KONE India has new elevator offerings: KONE U MONOSPACE® and KONE U MINISPACE™ for the mid-range segment, and launched Read More ...

Elevators & Escalators - Manufacturers focus on Expansion, Technology & Service

India's leading elevator manufacturers are undertaking massive capacity expansion and targeting 8-10% sales growth this year on the back of likely revival in the real estate market after the implementation of RERA and GST Read More ...

KONE N MiniSpace™ for Tall Buildings

As urban India continues to grow and bourgeon, the need to enhance people flow movement is constant and immediate. Kone incorporated valuable feedback received from customers and has relaunched Read More ...

Elevator- Vertical Mobility Gathers Momentum

Gilco Global Elevators
Elevator manufacturers are gearing up to bring forth technologically updated products and solutions that provide safe, reliable and superior mobility. The current focus on creating Smart infrastructure Read More ...

KONE introduces Elevators for low and mid-rise residential Buildings

KONE Elevators
Kone is one of the global leaders in the elevator and escalator industry. With an objective to offer the best People Flow® experience by developing and delivering solutions that ena‎ble people to move Read More ...

Kone’s Energy-efficient Solutions for Greener Buildings

KONE Energy Efficient Elevators
KONE today provides energy- efficient industry-leading elevators, escalators, automatic building doors, and integrated solutions that enhance the People Flow in and between buildings. KONE's services cover the entire Read More ...

Elevators - Vying on Smart Vertical Mobility

ThyssenKrupp Elevator Multicar Cityscape
Businesses and communities are working to find solutions that can be integrated flexibly, sustainably, and aesthetically into the modern urban setup to provide a better quality of life wherein smart vertical mobility is Read More ...

KONE InnoTrack™

Kone InnoTrack
Innovation is the ability to provide solutions that are not only new but also meet industry demands with the utmost efficiency, making life much easier. Moving large groups of people safely and smoothly, especially in big public transit centers Read More ...

ThyssenKrupp's Eco-friendly Mobility Solutions at Airports

ThyssenKrupp Eco Friendly Mobility Solutions at Airport
ThyssenKrupp Elevator specializes in providing advanced solutions for moving people from one place to the next; vertically, horizontally and diagonally. Its portfolio includes a wide range of passenger Read More ...

Otis Offers Eco-friendly Elevators and Escalators for Airports

Otis Eco Friendly Elevators
Just as elevators and escalators across residential and commercial applications are designed for their specific use, those installed in airports are designed and adapted for use in public spaces considering the Read More ...

Orona 3G Solutions Taking People's Mobility to Greater Heights

Ozona Elevators
Orona, a high-end solution provider for all kinds of urban mobility, is known worldwide for its sustainable products - elevators, escalators, and moving walkway. With commercial presence in over 100 countries and 2,50,000 Read More ...
NBM&CW

New Building Material & Construction World

New Building Material & Construction World
MGS Architecture

Modern Green Structures & Architecture

Modern Green Structures & Architecture
L&ST

Lifting & Specialized Transport

Lifting & Specialized Transport
II&TW

Indian Infrastructure & Tenders Week

Indian Infrastructure & Tenders Week