Some Critical Issues Pertaining to Road Construction Industry

Some Critical Issues Pertaining to Road Construction Industry

H. L. Chawla, Consultant, World Bank

During the course of inspections carried out by me as a part of various World Bank missions on the National Highways, State Highways and other road construction projects in the country, I have tried to find out the various constraints affecting the progress of the construction of the roads. Some of the critical issues pertaining to the Indian Road Construction Industry are as under:
  • Pre-construction issues
  • Land surveying, investigations and design issues
  • Construction and contract management issues

Pre-construction issues:

  • Delay in land acquisition
  • Resettlement of project affected persons
  • Tree cutting
  • Shifting of utilities
Since encumbrance free site is not made available to the contractors in the initial stages of the project, the contractors delay the mobilization and in most of the cases, the contractors use the mobilization advance elsewhere.

One more reason is that the extent of land to be acquired is not possible to be identified because of the outdated land records and poor quality of designs. Sometimes additional land requirements become necessary to take care of the designed right of way.

Another reason is that the trees to be cut are not properly demarcated on the design drawings. Moreover, the clearances and permissions from the Ministry of Environment and Forests is a pre-requisite and takes quite some time before the trees are cut and design right of way made available to the contractors.

Since no proper records exist of the under ground utilities like water supply, sewerage lines, electrical and telephone cables etc., these utilities get identified as encumbrance only during the implementation stage of the project. Similarly shifting of overhead electrical and telephone lines (which are visible including poles) takes a long time. This leads to delay as the shifting of these utilities brings in hardships to the general population and suitable alternate arrangements are required to be made.

Some Critical Issues Pertaining to Road Construction Industry
There are numerous government agencies involved from which clearances/approvals/permissions are required to be obtained before the utilities can be shifted or relocated. This takes a great deal of time. There are cumbersome procedures involved and sometimes the relevant laws and regulations are also not very clear.

The delay in the handing over of the encumbrance-free land to the contractor generally takes as much as about 30 months compared to about 20 months which should have been the ideal case. Even when the land was finally made available, there exist still some encumbrances which put a constraint on the contractor’s capacity to undertake construction work in an un-interrupted and continuous manner. Because of the above reasons, substantial extensions of time are required to be given to the contractors.

These time over runs lead to cost over runs. These also lead to claims by the contractors for idle resources and demand for compensation.

Land Surveying, Investigations, and Design Issues

The land acquisition for the highway projects is carried out in accordance with the principles laid out in the National Highways Act or the Land Acquisition Act. These two Acts govern the acquisition of land for defined public purposes and compensation in lieu thereof. If all due processes are followed, the land acquisition as per the NH act should normally take about 15 months and under the Land Acquisition around 24 to 30 moths.

Since such a long time is taken to acquire the land, the process should get started much earlier or may be at the same time as the project is at the design stage. But actually the land acquisition plans are prepared very late.

There are quite a few reasons for the delay and some of these are:
Some Critical Issues Pertaining to Road Construction Industry
    • Outdated revenue maps form the basis for preparation of land acquisition plans. The records are often not been updated for a long period of time.
    • The land acquisition plans are often not realistic as the design consultants lack expertise to prepare such plans. They also do not carry out the alignment and ground verification.
    • There are frequent changes in the designs and alignments during implementation stage. In some cases, there are discrepancies in the project coordinates and the reference frames resulting in mismatch thereby resulting in redesign of the alignment.
    • The project authorities have to depend on the human resources from the revenue authorities, who are already over stretched and cannot, provide the required assistance on time.
    • In the absence of clear guidelines on providing compensation in special cases (including land owners with unclear titles or more than one owner), the settlement process takes a much longer time.
    • In addition to the above, the reasons for delay in resettlement are as follows:
    • Delay in finalization of the alignment and corridor of impact during project preparation stage
    • Delay in identification and finalization of the list of displaced persons. The list of title holders gets finalized after the declaration of award by the competent authority.
    • The alternative land for relocation during preparation stage is not firmed up
    • Construction and contract management issues:
    • Very weak contract management & enforcement environment.
    • The role of the Independent Engineer is not clear. Many of the Employers staff and domestic supervision consultants do not have adequate knowledge/ to understand the FIDIC conditions of contract (being followed in most of the NH and state highways projects).
    • Lack of the understanding between the Employers and the contractors that speedy completion of the projects is to both parties’ interest.
    • Lack of understanding of the contract conditions both by the Employers and the contractors.
    • Since the Employer is usually lacking in fulfilling his obligations under the contract, such as timely delivery of encumbrance free land, timely decision making on the variations, making payments on time, early activation of dispute resolution mechanism, his leverage on the contract enforcement gets eroded.
    • There is a resistance to acceptance of the responsibility in taking decisions, even when the Employer’s staff is convinced. This is because of a “fear psychosis” and the staff tries to pass on the buck.
    • There is lack of training imparted to the Employer’s, CSC’s & contractor’s staff on the general terms and conditions of the contract and the division of the parties’ rights, duties and obligations as per the contract. This results in lack of motivation for treating the project as a common goal and working as a “team”and all the parties try to shift the blame to others and no one tries to take the responsibility.
    • Due to dearth of construction management skills in the country, the contractor’s performance gets affected. This includes the contractor’s work planning, resource and workflow management, cash flow management and his overall project management.
    • The contractors generally quote low to win the contract. They normally have their eyes on making money through raising claims at a subsequent date knowing fully well that the Employer will certainly provide them many avenues to do so, particularly because of delay in making land available and delay in decisions, payments etc.
    • Since the role of the Independent Engineer is not very clear so the Engineer takes no responsibility.
    • The Engineer is not accountable as after the project is completed, he is simply not there.
Some Critical Issues Pertaining to Road Construction Industry
  • The supervision consultancy contracts are generally time based. This creates a perverse incentive to delayed decision making resulting in extension of the civil works and consequently in the extension of the CSC contract.
  • The staff in the CSCs is also not fully conversant with the FIDIC conditions of contract and is also not up to date with latest quality management techniques and new technologies. They are thus handicapped in managing contracts effectively with timely and quality decision making.
The delay in the construction has led to a large gap between the budget allocation and actual expenditure on the road construction in the country in the past few years. This gap has been in the range of 15-20%. About 70% of the contracts have been delayed and about 50% of the contracts had cost over runs of more than 25%. The mean delay was about 73% of the original contract completion time.

The need of the hour is to find an early solution to ensure timely completion of the road construction projects.


The World Bank: Indian Road Construction Industry: Capacity issues, constraints & recommendations.

NBMCW September 2010

Ashoka Buildcon constructs Package 4 of landmark Eastern Peripheral Expressway project

Ashoka Buildcon, which was awarded package 4 of the EPE project, constructed 22km of the 135 km EPE, at a cost of ₹789 crores. It built three grade separators, one ROB, 12 VUPs, 22 PUPs, four minor bridges and 20 Read More ...

Wirtgen: Cold milling machines have a decisive impact on quality of road rehabilitation

Wirtgen offers the widest range of cold milling machines in the industry. Customers can choose from more than 30 different types of machines, with each also available with a variety of milling widths. The lower Read More ...

Smart Pavement Materials and Emerging Technologies

Smartness describes self-adaptability, self-sensing, and multiple functionalities of the materials. These characteristics provide numerous possible applications of such materials in manufacturing and civil Read More ...

Repair of Scaled Surface Areas of Newly Constructed Cement Concrete Pavement Slabs

After 2014, the speed of the construction of cement concrete road for national highways and expressways, in cities and even at village level has significantly increased due to the policy adopted by the Government of India Read More ...

ArcelorMittal Long Products - Benefits of steel solutions in bridge design

Today's modern bridge construction projects face totally new challenges. The public, the regulators and the authorities demand structures that are cost effective during their planning, execution, lifetime and dismantling. Read More ...

From Yarn to Bridges – Strata Takes Another Giant Leap in Technical Textiles

Strata Geosystems, a global leader in the soil reinforcement industry, has opened its new state-of-the-art manufacturing facility, which will meet the growing demand for geosynthetic products in India and around the Read More ...

Bogibeel Rail-cum-Road Bridge

There are a lot of legends and prophesies floating with the current of the mighty Brahmaputra River as it tracks its course from Tibet to Bangladesh, roaring down through narrow chasms and gobbling up land in its pursuit Read More ...

Advantages of Precast Concrete in Constructing Highways & Bridges

Prefabrication of any structure component off-site during highway construction (or reconstruction) offers major time and user cost savings in comparison with the traditional cast-in-place methods of construction. Read More ...

Long-life Pavements - European & American Perspectives

Long-life Pavements European & American Perspectives Road infrastructure investment has increased less in many countries than road traffic. If these trends continue, the outcome will be increasing intensity of Read More ...

Performance Management for Durable Pavements

Satisfactory pavement performance can be assured only with an appropriate design with a well-calibrated algorithm, material selection based on the appropriate mix design, proper processing of the materials for Read More ...

Experimental Study on Tunnel Excavation Muck for Road Construction

Substantial parts of India are covered by hills and Himalayas stand foremost among them. The border areas in the North and North-East of our country are mountainous with steep topography, difficult and hazardous Read More ...

Geocells For Pavement Reinforcement

Roads are essential for the economic growth of the country, and unlike the railway network, various classes of roads-from expressways to rural road, assure last mile connectivity. India’s growing economy requires Read More ...

Pervious Concrete Technology for Urban Roads and Pavements

Pervious Concrete Technology for Urban Roads and Pavements In recent years, the rise in employment and higher standard of living, amongst numerous other factors, has led to a gradual shift of people from rural to urban Read More ...

Durable and Economical Technology for Bituminous Surfacing of Rural Roads

The Pradhan Mantri Grameen Sadak Yojna (PMGSY) has been one of the most successful flagship programmes launched by former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee in 2000 for constructing a wide network of rural roads Read More ...

Precast Concrete - Smart Pavement - The future of road building

The term “information superhighway” was introduced in the 1990s. Back then, it was used to describe a worldwide communications network. Today, Kansas City, Mo.-based Integrated Roadways is putting a different Read More ...

Faster & Better Road Construction is Possible

Road Transport & Highways minister Nitin Gadkari has time and again been urging to use more of innovative techniques and materials for faster and better-quality construction of roads and highways. While launching Read More ...

New Building Material & Construction World

New Building Material & Construction World
MGS Architecture

Modern Green Structures & Architecture

Modern Green Structures & Architecture

Lifting & Specialized Transport

Lifting & Specialized Transport

Indian Infrastructure & Tenders Week

Indian Infrastructure & Tenders Week