Aerial Rope Transit - (Cable Car) for Public Transport

    Cable car

    Introduction Advanced transport technologies have improved mobility of men and materials in both normal and specific conditions. Numerous transit technologies have been developed for specific purposes to provide safe, quick and efficient mobility in particular geographical areas. Aerial Rope Transit (cable car/ropeway) is one such technology widely used in areas with topographical barriers, particularly in hilly and mountainous terrains. In Garhwal region of Uttarkhand, apart from ski resorts and tourist destinations, manual and hydraulic cable cars are operational in around 20 locations, and are a lifeline for local residents in a region where roads are sparse and air/train networks are not available (extracted from The Hindustan Times, dated June 27, 2017). Such a system may be promoted in other hilly regions.

    Pawan kumar
    Dr. Pawan Kumar, Town and Country Planning Organization, New Delhi
    Cable car transport is considered one of the safest based on the ratio of accidents to the number of people transported per km. The system offers plenty of secondary benefits, which make it the first option in urban transport. However, it is desirable to promote the cable car as a public transport.

    The Hon’ble Union Minister for Road Transport and Highways Shri Nitin Gadkari, for declogging traffic congestion on roads, has proposed cable cars or ropeway transport. The tender for the first project, between Dhaula Kuan (Delhi) to Manesar (Haryana), has already been cleared at an estimated cost of ₹50 crore, which may come down to ₹35 crore, once it becomes part of the ‘Made in India’ initiative.

    Similarly, Conveyor and Ropeway Services Private Limited (CRSPL) has proposed to introduce Curvo, the world’s first non-linear aerial ropeway for the most traffic congested areas of Kolkata. The ropeway is for second tier urban commutation in two sectors: Sealdah to BBD Bagh area and Howrah to the new State Secretariat at Nabanna.

    Meenal Jyotika
    Meenal Jyotika, Dual Degree M.Tech. (Mechanical) Student, Gautam Buddha University, Greater Noida.
    Another example is of Dombivli east railway station (Thane District, Maharashtra) to Shil Phata junction road or Manpda road, which has dense traffic and is narrow and congested. This major road is one of the oldest business market places and an important link to the newly developed job destination of Navi Mumbai. The annual average daily traffic on the project road is more than 15,000 PCUs and there is no space available for expansion. Even traffic flow cannot be disturbed for long. Therefore, selection for the most appropriate mode of transport was difficult in such a situation, where horizontal growth is not an option but only vertical growth, where LRT, Ropeway, and Metro-like transits with low right of way (RoW) are feasible. Ropeways are an ideal solution in situations like the Manpada road, and there are many more cable car proposals for different parts of the country.

    Aerial Rope Transit (Cable Car) System

    Aerial Ropeway Transit (ART) or Cable Car System (Ropeway) is known as aerial tram, sky tram, aerial tramway, etc. In India, it is also called Udan Khatola, Gagan Khatola, etc. The cable car is a type of aerial transit to transport passengers in a cabin which is suspended and pulled by cables. It consists of one or two fixed cables (i.e. track cable), one loop of cable (i.e. haulage rope), and passenger cabins. The track cables provide support for the cabins while the haulage rope driven by electric motor provides propulsion (push forward/drive forward).

    Similarly, cable car vehicles (i.e. cabins/aerial lifts / chairs cabin, gondolas, etc.) pulled by haulage rope and rotated by a motor off-board, are motor-less, engine-less, brakeless and have no control panels. The aerial cable car transport system moves back and forth on a fixed track with one or two vehicles, whereas, gondola cabins move along a unidirectional loop with declutching mechanism that has a device to allow the gondola to be uncoupled from the haul rope on arrival at the station, and to be attached again to the haul rope on exiting from the station. However, cable car vehicles have different carrying capacity. In a simple system, there may be only one cable car vehicle, whereas, in a complex system, several vehicles are placed at regular intervals along the line.

    The cable car is comparatively a safer mode of transport and provides direct connection between two points inspite of physical barriers and obstacles. It demands low space for towers and stations and is considered an environment-friendly and cost-effective mode of transport. It is being used in many cities such as Las Vegas, Oakland, Coblenz (Germany), Istanbul, Rio de Janeiro, Zurich, Singapore, Wellington (New Zealand), London, Mauritius, etc. The selection of such a transport system depends on criteria such as topography and terrains, length (horizontal & vertical), capacity (both cabin & whole system), line speed, operation system (uni-directional/bi-directional), purpose (passengers/tourists/materials), economic viability, operation & maintenance costs, safety of passengers, etc.

    Cable car
    Figure 1: Detachable Bi-cable Cable Car (Source: Hoffmann, K. (2009), oscillating effects of ropeways caused by cross wing and other influences, FME Transaction, No. 37, pp 175-184)

    Components of Aerial Rope Transit (Cable Car)

    The simplest system of cable car consists of cable(s), cable car vehicle(s), and supporting structure(s). Basically, it is an integrated mechanical system based on principles of mechanics to carry passengers from one elevation to another elevation, particularly in undulating terrains. Figure 1 illustrates running system of detachable bi-cable cable car.

    The whole system has two components, broadly: civil works (related to brick/RCC/steel structure, basic facilities for passengers, etc), and the second is installation of plants and machinery to provide mechanical and electrical support in running of cable car vehicles.

    Table 1 describes various components of cable car and their functions in mechanical shifting of passengers from one location to other location.

    Table 1: Components of Aerial Rope Transit (Cable Car)
    S.N. Components Description Function
    i. Cable car vehicle
    (cabin/gondolas)

    Consists of carriage / grip, hanger and passenger cabin.

    Vehicle may be fully enclosed carrier, semi-open, seating chair with standing space, etc.

    Vehicle has different capacity.

    Structural and mechanical assemblage in which passengers are shifted.
    ii. Terminal Stations Minimum two stations i.e. lower terminal station and upper terminal station are required. Stations need Drive Machines System which consists of motor and drive.
    (motor as mechanical device generates rotational/linear forces used to power a machine whereas drive as electronic device harnesses electrical energy sent to motor)
    iii. Intermediate Towers Intermediate structures to support both track cable (loads) and haulage rope (bundles) between terminals. For longer span, towers are required to provide support at various intermediate points.
    iv. Cables Cables i.e. ropes are a major component Cable pulls the cable car vehicles from one location to another for transporting passengers.
    v. Plants and Machinery Drive (main & auxiliary), gear box, tension / counter weight trolley, grip system, generator, emergency pulley, speed reducer, Diesel Generator (DG) set, etc. Provide movement by using electrical and mechanical support.
    Passenger Cabin
    Figure 2: Mechanical System and Passenger Cabin of Bhopal Ropeway at Manuabhan Tekri (photo by authors)

    Cable Car: An Integrated Public Transport

    The Cable Car as mass transit is used in developed countries which need specific technologies for performance in specific conditions such as geographical constraint areas to overcome natural barriers, weather/climatic conditions, hilly terrains, etc. In fact, such a system has both advantages and limitations but provides efficient mobility where conventional public transport may not be operated.

    The Metro-Cable Car System of Medellin (Colombia) is an example of integrated mass transit. The city of Medellin is located in a valley and is surrounded by hills. The settlements are neither connected by bus nor Metro services. Therefore, a Metro-Cable Car system has been developed to provide complementary mode of transport to the Medellin Metro.

    It is planned as a public transport having a ridership of 30,000 passengers per day and is properly integrated with Medellin’s mass transit system. The Metro-cable uses Mono-cable Detachable Gondola (MDG) technology. The first gondola line (Line K) was opened as a complementary mode of transport to Medellin Metro in 2006.

    In the Indian context, there is a lot of potential to explore use of the Cable Car as mass transit. The Government departments, transport agencies, cable car manufacturers, etc., should take initiatives to promote the system as an alternative mode of transport and integrate it with the existing mass transit, particularly in the hilly states.

    Safety and Security Issues

    Integrated System of Metro
    Figure 3: Integrated System of Metro and Metro-Cable, Medellin (Colombia)
    Accidents in the cable car transport system may be due to human error, failure of mechanical / electrical components, lack of maintenance of structural system, unsafe environment such as bad weather, volcanic eruption, etc. On June 25, 2017, four tourists and three local persons died when a cable car came crashing down from a height of about 30 meters in the tourist resort of Gulmarg. The tragedy was due to both bad weather conditions and mechanical failure. It was stated that sudden strong winds uprooted a pine tree that hit another large pine tree, whose branch fell on the cable, derailing it from the pulley. The system stopped operation and the cable derailed between the fifth and sixth towers, and the cabins started swinging dangerously, which caused shattering of glass and the passengers were thrown out of the cabin. (source: Indo Asian News Service, Srinagar dated June 26, 2017). Table 2 describes probable causes of accidents of cable cars and their frequency in percentage.

    Table 2 indicates that most accidents in cable cars are due to mechanical failure such as slip of cable, fall/malfunctioning of cabin, snapped rope wire, power system failure, collisions, etc., and therefore, complete technical and standard of procedures should be followed in their operation and maintenance.

    Table 2: Probable Percentage (Frequency) Causes of Accidents in Cable Cars
    S.N. Cause of Hazards Consequences Probable Percentage (Frequency)
    i. Cable slipped Passenger death 12.00
    ii. Cabin lost its hold capacity Passenger death 8.00
    iii. Hill collapsed Total system collapsed 8.00
    iv. Snapping of rope wire Passenger death 37.00
    v. Power system failure Delay in operation 12.00
    vi. Collision when entering station Minor injury 15.00
    vii. Loosening of holding capacity of soil/geology Tower collapse & passenger death 8.00
      Total   100.00
    Source: RITES Ltd. (2013), “EIA Study for Passenger Ropeway between Dhapper and Bhalaydhunga in South Sikkim District of Sikkim"

    Discussion and Concluding Remarks
    • The Cable Car transport system needs to ensure passenger safety as an important consideration. Mechanical failures and damages in bad weather put passenger safety at risk. Therefore, construction (RCC structures, steel structures, structural joints, etc.), operation and maintenance of the cable car should follow all the safety provisions and parameters as per the Indian Standard Codes to resist seismic and wind forces.
    • There is need to maintain “service level benchmarks” for cable car operations in terms of service frequency, speed, capacity, accessibility, and availability. Operations can get interrupted due to bad weather, particularly, high winds. Generally, the maximum acceptable wind speed varies from 70-110 km./hr. depending on the technology used.
    • There should be a strict schedule for maintenance of cable car vehicles on a daily basis. It is important to conduct pre-operative checks on machinery and post-operative checks for maintenance, repairs of plants and machinery.
    • A plan should be put in place for evacuation procedures during breakdown and evacuation in an emergency or critical situation.
    • To improve mechanical performance, there is need to conduct “magneto-inductive test” (i.e. measurement of magneto-inductive flux leakage to check working conditions of strands and to check rope core) and radiographic test (in which gamma rays are passed through the steel wire ropes for getting images of the flaws to be rectified). Further, visual inspection of cables supplemented with additional measurements on a daily basis is necessary.
    • Emergency stop buttons must be provided at convenient points to stop the cable car vehicles in the event of an emergency. Further, an alternative mechanism is required to run cable car vehicles at slow speed to rescue passengers from the main line in case of failure of cable car main drive motor. Arrangement of self-driven rescue carriage and cabin is desirable at both lower and upper terminal stations to evacuate stranded passengers on line.

    Figure 3 illustrates integrated system of Metro, Metro-Cable Line K, J, & L and their integration. The other details are as follows:

    Mode : Mass Transit Service
    Metro Line : Line A
     

    : Line B

    Metro-Cable Line Length  
    Line K

    :2789 mt

    Line  J

    :2072 mt

    Line L :4595 mt
    Line Speed :18-22 km/hr
    Cabin capacity :10
    Headway :12-60 seconds
    PPDPH :550-3000

    The existing cable car network in Indian cities may be stretched by creating new transport infrastructure. Similarly, the purpose of recreational/tourism may be extended to the mass transit purpose. Therefore, a scientific study is required for proper selection of suitable aerial rope transit with economic viability and geographical feasibility.

    References
    1. A Report on Kotappakonda Aerial Ropeway Project, Department of Tourism, Govt. of Andhra Pradesh, 2015.
    2. Hoffmann, K. (2009), Oscillating effects of Ropeways caused by Cross wing and other influences, FME Transaction, No. 37, pp 175-184).
    3. Kumar, Pawan (2016), Cable Car (Ropeway): An Alternate Mode of Transport, Indian Journal for Transport Management, Volume 40, Number-3, pp 203-211.
    4. Kuehner, K. and Wehking,K. (2018), Assessment of Damage Behavior of twisted Ropeway Ropes in Operation, Logistic Journal (DOI: 10.2195/lj_NotRev_kuehner_en_201803_01).
    5. RITES Ltd. (2013), EIA Study for Passenger Ropeway between Dhapper and Bhalaydhunga in South Sikkim District of Sikkim, New Delhi.
    6. Tezak, S. et al (2016), Increasing the Capacities of Cable Cars for Use in Public Transport, Journal of Public Transportation, Vol. 19, No. 1, pp 1-16.

    NBM&CW August 2018

    CURRENTLY ONLINE
    We have 610 guests and no members online

    NBM&CW

    New Building Material & Construction World

    New Building Material & Construction World
    MGS Architecture

    Modern Green Structures & Architecture

    Modern Green Structures & Architecture
    L&ST

    Lifting & Specialized Transport

    Lifting & Specialized Transport
    II&TW

    Indian Infrastructure & Tenders Week

    Indian Infrastructure & Tenders Week