Rapid Transit System in India Making inroads

Rapid Transit System

Urban Transportation and Sustainable Growth

To quote Mark Walport, “Industrialisation, Mass Transit, and the Internet are technological revolutions that have reshaped lives, nations, and the planet.”

The Indian economy is poised to grow at over 7% in the coming years, placing it amongst the world’s fastest growing economies – and with the concomitant demand for constant improvement in infrastructure - connectivity as well as capacity development. At the same time, a balance needs to be maintained for inclusive and environmentally sustainable growth to ensure a better livelihood and right to life, which is one of the fundamentals right enshrined in the Constitution of India

Development of transport infrastructure is sine-qua-non for every economy in its transition for development, as it functions as a catalyst of growth for other sectors and furthers the socio-economic development of a nation. Indeed, transportation has long (and correctly) been viewed as a means of energising and sustaining economic growth, generating employment, and fostering holistic development. Unlike other sectors, the demand-supply gap cannot be bridged by increasing imports, but only through capacity-building. It is this unique feature which makes transportation the backbone of a nation’s development and improved quality of life. However, with the ever-increasing population and growing urbanization, the stress on transportation is increasing, which is adversely affecting the environment, seamless travel of people, and asset life deterioration.

The Ministry of Urban Development (MoUD) issued the National Urban Transport Policy (NUTP) in 2006, followed by NUTP in 2014, to bring about comprehensive improvements in urban transport services and infrastructure. Special emphasis was laid on to mass rapid transit (MRT), both rail and road based, including bus system as these are the only modes that carry high numbers of people using least space. Since its introduction in India, the Rapid Transportation System (RTS) has come up in a big way and is considered imperative for inclusive and environmentally sustainable growth.

RTS boosts economic growth of a region by not only providing seamless connectivity within the cities but also providing periphery regional connectivity, thereby, increasing the influence zone. Though, congestion due to sectoral urbanization is an issue which the Government has been trying to address, with the Regional Rapid Transit System (RRTS) being implemented, there will be some respite for city travellers and the overburdened infrastructure.

However, the Mass Rapid Transit System (MRTS) has faced various issues over the years with slow rolling out of projects, delay in relation to ROW, and financing issues, which delay asset availability to the public and lead to huge economic and social costs to the country. With the development of new technology initiatives in the MRT/RRT systems, it is the opportune time for the industry to revive investment confidence and develop new models inclined towards PPP and less dependent on budgetary support.

Existing Technology and Metamorphosing of New Technology in Rapid Transit

At present, the MRTS can broadly be divided into the following:
  • Rail based MRTS - Metro Rail, Light Rail Transit, Regional Rail, Tramways
  • Road based MRTS – Bus Rapid Transit Systems (BRTS)
The selection of the type of MRTS is mainly governed by the MoUD’s guidelines based on the capacity requirements, the influenced zone, and the distance requirements. However, we are crossing through a time where technological innovations are leading not only our imagination but also the ground reality. The advent of new technology initiatives is driving cleaner environment, faster travel and better transportation promises. In recent years, we have witnessed, enough buzz being created on the skyway, pods (PRTS), hyperloop, and now, flying taxis. Hyperloop is being considered as an option for MRTS by various states in India, though it is at a very nascent stage and will require a robust legal and institutional framework since the present legislations may not be able to address the nuances of the technology, such as safety certification, liability, insurance and fare fixation issues. It may be a challenge for the government to classify the regulatory framework for introduction of the hyperloop technology as MRTS. Also considering there are only few developers of the technology in India, it will create a selection challenge even while following the Swiss model. But the competitiveness and cost effectiveness while choosing the technology have to be the guiding principles.

SkyWay STransport System

Investment scenarios in Mass Rapid Transit - Metro Rail

The present investment in the Metro Rail is mainly driven by the government funding (state and central government) where the executing agency is a Special Purpose Vehicle with equal equity partnerships by the central and concerned State Governments, as followed by the Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC), Chennai Metro Rail Corporation (CMRC), Bangalore Metro Rail Corporation (BMRC) Nagpur Metro, Lucknow Metro, Kochi Metro and Ahmedabad Metro. The Public Private Partnership (PPP) model was only considered for Mumbai Metro Line- 1, Hyderabad Metro and Pune Metro Lime-III, which are being developed with Viability Gap Funding (VGF) from the Government of India.

However, due to the sheer size of the projects and the capital requirements, the benefits are not reflected in financial returns of the developer. Over and above the capital requirements, these projects are highly regulated. Though with the introduction of the Metro Rail Policy 2017, the non-fare box revenue is also provided to the private developers as part of the concession, but the ridership risk is still to be assumed by the private developers. Further, the VGF support being limited to 40% (20% by state government and 20% by central government) is also seen as a deterrent by the private developers. Nevertheless, the Government has to consider these as public utility services as well and guided by economic rate of return, rather than financial rate of return as it has a multiplying effect on overall development.

Delhi Meerut rrtc

Reintroduction of Public-Private Partnerships in Rapid Transportation

In its 2015 report on ‘Revisiting and Revitalising Public Private Partnership Model of Infrastructure’, the Vijay Kelkar Committee observed that PPPs “have the potential to execute infrastructure projects faster and better … There is immense urgency in raising the quality and quantum of PPPs in India’s infrastructure portfolio as part of its overall efforts to reduce its infrastructure deficit.”

However, for PPPs to be successful in MRTS, it is imperative that the government defines a vision for driving the transportation sector forward in a manner that adequately balances the interests of the investors, government, consumers and developers. Added to this is the need to develop a shelf of bankable projects that can be rolled out – experience has shown that investors are wary of wading into projects that appear financially unviable, for example, certain BRTS projects. Additionally, based on experience from the past decade of PPPs, the following are also important to ensure success of a PPP:
  • Ensuring timely grant of approvals and clearances to avoid unnecessary and costly delays in implementation. In this regard, it may be considered to ensure that right of way is given upfront as such access is often a prerequisite for obtaining approval – many projects, public and private alike, continue to face challenges owing to delays in land availability.
  • Permit participation of diverse bidding entities to include foreign funds and investment fund to provide the required investments.
  • Allowing for smooth and timely divestment by investors (i.e., by removing onerous lock-in restrictions, especially post-commissioning), more so when the nature of private investors is also diversifying.
  • Allocating risks over the project lifecycle to the party best equipped to handle the same (rather than unduly burdening any one party with the risks).
  • Building adequate safeguards and mechanisms for renegotiating costs/tariffs owing to unforeseen events.
  • Commercial exploitation of property to minimise the viability gap and relooking at the VGF limits.
  • Facilitating timely and efficacious resolution of disputes, with in-built timeframes for various stages in the proceedings.

The Rail Ahead

ultra pod 660
In spite of the challenges of capital requirement, lack of financing, right of way issues and fare fixations issues, the MRTS, being led by Metro Rail, has braced the currents and has shown phenomenal growth, with a modest beginning with 8 km in 2002 to 585 km in 2019 and about 600 km of sanctioned metro lines under construction, which will be operational in the next five years.

It is a known fact that MRTS/RRTS are one of the ways by which the sustainable economic development can take place wherein the requirement of urban mobility and environmental concerns can be addressed together. However, for MRTS/RRTS to be successfully rolled out to the public, their feasibility should be kept in mind, which, amongst others, is dependent upon the full corridor being made available for development from the start with availability of land. DRP should be made available and binding on the project proponent, realistic forecast of ridership should be provided, and KPI’s should be established, based on which the project should be evaluated at regular intervals.

While the existing MRTS/RRTS technology is being further developed, the next decade will in most likelihood, witness the reality of what is being called the Next-Gen Transportation – PRTS, Hyperloop, Skytrans and ET3, which will reinvent passenger, fright and cargo mobility.

Vishnu Sudarsan & Ashish Suman, Partners, J Sagar Associates

NBM&CW August 2019

Click Here
To Know More / Contact The Manufacturer
Please provide your details we will contact you as soon as possible
Please let us know your name.
Invalid Input
Please let us know your Designation.
Invalid Input
Please let us know your City.
Please let us know your State.
Please let us know your Country.
Please let us know your Contact Number.
Please let us know your email address.
Please brief your query.

Infra Development: The Way Forward

Although the Indian economy has been facing macro-economic ups and down due to global economic gloom, it has managed to remain stable, recording moderate growth rate consistently. Braving all the problems beyond its control, it has improved Read More ...

“Nal Se Jal” - SPML Infra Playing Key Role in Developing Water Infrastructure in India

SPML Infra Limited, India’s leading water management company will play a key role in the development of sustainable water infrastructure to realize the vision of “Nal Se Jal”. This ambitious scheme announced by the Finance Minister during Read More ...

Indian Aviation on a Growth Path

The Aviation Industry in India has emerged as one of the fastest growing industries in the country, especially so during the last three years. Introduction of low-cost carriers, FDI in domestic airlines, advanced information technologies Read More ...

Redefining Urbanity with international transport system

Creative Group presents a new vision for Chandni Chowk (a very congested area in Old Delhi) with re-planned interconnectivity, intermodality, and green spaces, that release the current stress above the ground and create opportunities to restore Read More ...

Attracting Private Investments to Boost Highway Growth in India

Ever since India set out on a path of economic liberalization in 1991, the policymakers for almost three decades remained focused on developing infrastructure to commensurate with the economic growth of the nation. But the task was humongous Read More ...

Transport Infrastructure in Focus

Transport Infrastructure to continue as a key focus area for new Government with massive capital outlay of up to ₹30 trillion expected over next five years. Construction companies are likely to be the major beneficiaries and will witness Read More ...

Real Estate Market Outlook 2019

India continues to retain its position as the world's fastest growing major economy on the back of improved investor confidence and better policy reforms. The IMF's database also suggested that India's contribution to world growth Read More ...

Infra Construction - Positives Outweigh Negatives

For a large part of the current up-cycle which started in CY2016, road work has largely been the biggest demand driver, followed by railways/metro.Notwithstanding the general slowdown in public/private infrastructure work Read More ...

ICRA - Strong demand growth for Mining & Construction Equipment Industry

The Indian Mining & Construction Equipment (MCE) industry is likely to see a moderation in demand growth, which is expected to fall to 4-6% in the medium term, more particularly during CY2019. The basic reason are the policy Read More ...


Israel's Ilan and Asaf Ramon International Airport will service the Red Sea resort city of Eilat and surrounding region. Commissioned by the Israel Airport Authority (IAA), the project was handled from A to Z by design Read More ...

Real Estate

Staving off the triple impact of Real Estate Regulation and Development Act (RERA), Goods and Services Tax (GST) and Demonetization (which had brought the sector to a grinding halt), India's Real Estate is back on Read More ...

Construction Dust Causes, Effects and Remedies

Construction dust can seriously damage the health of construction workers and if exposed for longer times can eventually even kill them. About 22,000 to 52,000 persons per year are dying due to inhaling polluted air in USA alone Read More ...

3-D Printing in Construction: A Review

Three dimensional printing has made its advent in construction in the recent past. With recent advancements in technologies, materials and further inclusion of building information modelling into the construction process, 3D printing is Read More ...

Reforms leading to higher expectations

The RRE has witnessed a prolonged downcycle owing to high inventory, muted demand, weak affordability, and declining investor interest. However structural changes over the last two years in the form of Real Estate Read More ...

Real Estate Industry in 2019

Post the revival of the Indian real estate sector through a series of initiatives by the government, the confidence of the homebuyers has increased with a clear understanding of the market. The developers have also witnessed Read More ...

Technology Transforming Indian Real Estate

One of the most potent and radical ground-breaking technologies set to transform property markets in current times is artificial intelligence (AI), which along with machine learning are reforming technology all Read More ...

New Building Material & Construction World

New Building Material & Construction World
MGS Architecture

Modern Green Structures & Architecture

Modern Green Structures & Architecture

Lifting & Specialized Transport

Lifting & Specialized Transport

Indian Infrastructure & Tenders Week

Indian Infrastructure & Tenders Week