Poor demand to keep private power producers under stress in medium term

Nuclear power plant

Rahul Prithiani, Director, CRISIL Research
Rahul Prithiani, Director, CRISIL Research
Given little scope for fresh PPAs being signed by discoms

The irony couldn’t be starker: for a country where significant stretches remain untouched by electricity, leave alone enjoy uninterrupted power. Power producers are battling a glut.

Recent years have seen aggressive capacity additions, led by the private sector. Between fiscal years 2013 and 2017, installed capacity saw a compound annual growth rate of 10%, with a whopping 130 GW (including renewables capacity) added.

However, power demand grew at a tepid 4% a year, given weak financial health of distribution companies (discoms) which restricted their power off-take ability, sluggish industrial growth, and rising energy efficiency measures taken by the government.

Not surprisingly, the average plant load factor (PLF) for thermal plants fell to 60% last fiscal from 70% in 2013. It was even lower for the private sector – for these producers, PLFs were at 56% last fiscal.

This has put the generation companies in a fix. The duress is more in the private sector, which added 87 GW of capacity between 2009 and 2017, a chunk of it without adequate offtake and fuel arrangements.

Sans off-take duress continues for private producers

The power procurement structure is also undergoing a shift. Given their weak financial position and uncertain sales growth projections, as well as low electricity prices in short term market (owing to oversupply situation), discoms are preferring short / medium term procurement instead of long-term PPAs. The increasing share of intermittent renewable energy and rise in industrial open access consumption only bolster that decision. Hence, there are very few long term PPAs.

Power sector
This heaps financial stress on power producers with untied capacities. Today, as much as 16 GW of existing capacities do not have any long-term PPAs. Yet, fresh PPAs by discoms for commercial power have tapered and are unlikely to regain thrust before 2022.

The power producers’ options become limited sans PPAs. Sale through the merchant route is not sustainable as short-term power prices, which declined to Rs.3 per kwh last fiscal (weighted average of power transacted on exchanges and bilateral through traders), are expected to remain low at about Rs.3.3-3.5 per unit even in 2022. On the exchanges, tariffs are quoting even lower, ~Rs. 2.4 per kwh, which barely covers the fuel and transmission cost.

Consequently, in the absence of assured off-take and low merchant tariffs, consolidation in the sector is expected to be slow. Further, takeover of stressed assets to be limited to the capacities with firm off-take agreement as witnessed in recent past.

But T&D poised for robust growth

India’s inter-regional power transmission capacity has increased from 17 GW in fiscal 2007 to 63 GW as on March 2017 and is expected to increase further to 118 GW by 2022. Planned strengthening of inter-state transmission system and associated transmission systems within states as well as ultra-high capacity green energy corridors with expected investments worth Rs.430 billion would drive the transmission segment growth.

On the distribution front too, there has been reasonable traction, with all major states (except West Bengal) signing memoranda of understanding under the Ujwal Discom Assurance Yojana (UDAY), which will gradually improve the respective discom’s financial position. With Rs.2.3 trillion of bonds being issued (86% of target) as of March 2017, debt and interest burden on discoms has been reduced, resulting in higher liquidity and therefore higher investments to improve operational efficiencies.

Implementation of Integrated Power Development Scheme and Deen Dayal Upadhyaya Gram Jyoti Yojana with cumulative investments worth Rs.72 Bn in 13th five year plan, coupled with Investments in forecasting and scheduling mechanism, grid monitoring and balancing requirement on account of rising share of intermittent renewable energy, as well as demand side management, smart metering, etc, are expected to result in robust growth of the distribution segment.

However, regular tariff revisions and large-scale investments in distribution infrastructure for operational efficiency are critical to improve the financial health of state discoms. In 2016-17, while states like Karnataka, MP, AP, Telangana, Chhattisgarh and Rajasthan hiked industrial tariffs, many states kept tariffs unchanged for non-industrial consumers.

Indian Power sector Huge opportunity

Government measures initiated to alleviate stress; timely and effective implementation critical

The government has initiated several measures to alleviate stress in the generation segment, the most recent being the Scheme to Harness and Allocate Koyla – or SHAKTI – policy, which aims at removing fuel supply bottlenecks by providing coal linkages to plants having Letter of Assurance. This would keep the generation costs low and ensure increased plant availability with assured fuel supply. However, availability of fresh PPAs by discoms and discounting to be provided on existing PPA tariffs could impact economics of projects adversely.

The flexible coal utilisation policy for state and central generation plants, aimed to reduce fuel costs was also notified earlier in May 2016. This, in fact, has already augured well as the average generation cost of NTPC plants reduced to Rs.1.94 per kwh last fiscal compared with Rs.2.01 per kwh in 2015-16, owing to improved coal quality and supply.

The government has also given more powers to the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) for dealing with stressed assets. The Strategic Debt Restructuring, or SDR, scheme, the Scheme for Sustainable Structuring of Stressed Assets, or S4A, and flexible structuring of long-term project loans under the 5:25 scheme introduced by the RBI are all aimed at relieving the stress to an extent. However, given lack of power off-take till now, the impact of the same cashflows has been limited.

Way forward

Of the total Industrial deployment of gross bank credit worth Rs.26.8 trillion (as of March 2017), the largest single sector exposure (Rs.5.3 trillion or 20%) is to Power sector. Despite government’s efforts towards resolving fuel issues and introduction of various RBI schemes, the debt woes of the private sector generators still exist.

Power sector
The government is now considering to set up a holding company (termed the National Asset Management Company) for identified stressed assets. This would involve the public sector entities NTPC, Power Finance Corporation and Rural Electrification Corporation, besides banks, which will auction stressed plants or lease them on contract basis after the lenders take management control. However, the lenders and promoters would take significant haircut through debt-equity swap due to weak cash flows.

The revenue generation for stressed assets can materialize only when the power demand starts picking up. For sustainable demand growth, ensuring industrial segments pick up through the ‘Make in India’, is necessary. Also, improvement in the last mile connectivity to realise the latent power demand and intensive rural electrification is required.

Apart from impetus to demand growth, efficient and cost reflective tariffs would also be essential for reducing discom losses- which in turn can make timely payment to generators and also increase power off-take.

Augmentation of T&D infrastructure, improvisations for improving discom’s financial health through adequate tariff revisions and favourable regulatory provisions for merchant power market development are key monitorables.

With per capita consumption of power at 1075 kwh in 2015-16, or about a third of the world average, India’s power sector has significant headroom for growth. However, issues arising out of demand-supply mismatch and regulatory constraints would have to be handled efficiently and effectively in order to realise this potential.

NBM&CW October 2017

Real Estate Industry in 2019

Post the revival of the Indian real estate sector through a series of initiatives by the government, the confidence of the homebuyers has increased with a clear understanding of the market. The developers have also witnessed Read More ...

Technology Transforming Indian Real Estate

One of the most potent and radical ground-breaking technologies set to transform property markets in current times is artificial intelligence (AI), which along with machine learning are reforming technology all Read More ...

Indian Construction Equipment Sector - Seeing Unprecedented Growth & Intelligentization

The Indian equipment sector is undergoing sweeping changes not just in terms of higher demand amid the government’s resolve to build world-class infrastructure, but also due to the digitalization and intelligentization Read More ...

Indian Real Estate Sector 2018 - New policies for Growth, Development & Transparency

India's Real Estate Sector is seeing a resurrection with the several structural changes initiated by the government in 2017. The Government has put housing on a high growth trajectory by offering tax and fiscal incentives to Read More ...

India's Booming Aviation Sector - Will Boost CE Industry

India has witnessed a six-fold increase in passengers over the past decade due to better connectivity and cheaper fares. Global consultancy and research firm Centre for Asia Pacific Aviation (CAPA) revealed in its recent report Read More ...

Diversifying for Growth

A trend that is being noticed in the last one year, is that of companies diversifying from their core business to the Infrastructure Sector, where they are seeing a good potential for expanding their business footprint. Prospective Read More ...

Infrastructure Creation in India – The Next Generation of Reforms

Infrastructure is the centre piece of India’s growth-story. The total outlay for infrastructure in the FY 2018-19 stands at ₹5.97 lakh crore, as compared to the ₹4.94 lakh crore for FY 2017-18, thereby making an increase of more Read More ...

Bharatmala to Boost Real Estate Activity

The government’s ₹7 lakh crore Bharatmala highway-building programme is expected to give a big boost to the Real Estate sector, besides raising demand for steel and cement and creating large-scale blue-collar Read More ...

RERA: Law of the Land?

It is nearly a year since the Indian realty entered a new paradigm with the on-set of nationwide implementation of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (RERA). As the first anniversary of RERA draws Read More ...

2017: The Year of RERA – What is the current scenario?

The Real Estate Regulatory Act (RERA) which came into effect from 1st May 2017, was aimed at ensuring accountability, infusing transparency and bringing uniformity in practices in the real estate sector Read More ...

Real Estate 2018 Era of RERA, GST and REIT

The year 2017 has been the most eventful period for the Indian Real Estate sector with new regulations and policy changes, following demonetization, roll out of RERA, Benami Transaction Prohibition Read More ...

Miles and miles to go...For Indian cities to be truly smart!

The last few years have witnessed pragmatic policies to bring about an urban renaissance in the country through innovative initiatives in urban development. On the top of such initiatives is the government Read More ...

The big bang Highways construction plan

In a master stroke to bridge the physical infrastructure deficit in the road and highway sector, the government has unveiled its biggest ever plan involving Rs.6.92 lakh-crore to construct 83,877 km of roads Read More ...

New Age Technologies for Construction Industry

The construction industry is changing rapidly, and new materials and technologies are being introduced on a regular basis. Execution of construction projects and their timely delivery Read More ...

New age airports must be agile, smart, and sustainable, as well as revenue efficient

In September 2014, the Airports Authority of India (AAI) had announced that it would be building 50 low-cost, no-frills airports all over the country. This is in tandem with its Policy on Airports that clearly Read More ...

India’s Mega Infra Projects on World Map

India’s infrastructure sector, a key driver of the country’s development and economic growth, remains the focus of the Government’s policies, initiatives and investment plans. The sector has seen many changes Read More ...

New Building Material & Construction World

New Building Material & Construction World
MGS Architecture

Modern Green Structures & Architecture

Modern Green Structures & Architecture

Lifting & Specialized Transport

Lifting & Specialized Transport

Indian Infrastructure & Tenders Week

Indian Infrastructure & Tenders Week