Forward Analysis for a Cable Stayed Bridge

Vinayagamoorthy Marriap Sr. Technical Support Engineer, MIDAS R&D Centre, Mumbai

Overview

In general, to design a cable-stayed bridge, a final system (completed system) analysis and a construction stage analysis are required. From the final system (completed system) analysis, dimensions of a structure, cross section of cables and cable forces are determined.

Depending on the erection method, the structural system of a cable-stayed bridge can be changed greatly. And the change of structural system can cause an unstable state during construction. In this regard, construction stages should be composed in a way that the construction stages, which affect the structural system, are included and should be used to check the structural safety. When the analysis is performed following the erection sequence to fulfil this purpose, it is called Forward Analysis. Through the forward analysis, stresses in construction stages, construction sequence and possibility of construction can be checked and an optimal construction method can be selected.

The reason for being difficult to apply forward analysis to a cable-stayed bridge is that the cable forces to be introduced at each construction stage are hard to know. In Korea, most of cable-stayed bridges have been designed by using backward analysis followed by forward analysis. From the backward analysis cable forces were determined, and afterwards using these cable forces the forward analysis was carried out.

Forward Analysis for a Cable Stayed Bridge
In this case, the structural systems between backward analysis and forward analysis are different and therefore, key segment closure is different between the two analyses. This leads to the fact that the final member forces at the final stage from the forward analysis are different from the member forces from the initial equilibrium state analysis (at the final system (completed system)). In the initial equilibrium state analysis for the final system (completed system), after the self-weight of the structure, cable forces and superimposed dead loads are applied to the key segment, the member forces at the key segment are calculated. However, in the forward analysis, the girder is deflected by its self-weight and cable pretension at the stage immediately before the key segment closure. When the key segment is closed, it is not affected by the self-weight of other structural elements except for the key segment itself and cable pretension. These differences from different structural systems lead to the differences in analysis results.

This problem is caused by not understanding the cable theory or by no existence of software taking care of this problem except for the software dealing with large displacement.

But the above mentioned is unreasonable according to the following reasons:
  1. Within elastic range, forward analysis result is the same as the backward analysis result. (e.g., not considering time-dependent effects).
  2. If the key segment closure force is calculated, both forward and backward analyses will have the same result as that from initial equilibrium state analysis.
According to the cable theory, unstressed length of cable is calculated by the initial equilibrium state analysis, and in backward analysis the cable length changes as the structural system changes and accordingly cable force changes with cable length. Therefore, if the planned construction stages are applicable to the design, it is also possible to achieve the aforementioned with forward analysis. First, unstressed cable length is calculated based on the cable force from the final system (completed system) and cable forces for each stage can calculated by considering the cable length changes with construction stages. However, until now this theory has been feasible only with large displacement analysis. It is because when the cable is installed by the cantilever method the cable length should be a real displacement. In a large displacement analysis, a newly created member can be installed tangentially to the existing member. Tangent displacement is referred to as a virtual displacement. But in a small displacement analysis, it is difficult to calculate the cable force considering the virtual displacement. However, in midas Civil software, even in a small displacement analysis, a virtual displacement can be considered. Therefore, if the unstressed length is computed and thereafter the forward analysis is carried out, it is possible to perform construction stage analysis with forward analysis alone. 'Lack-of-Fit Force' function converts the relationship between the unstressed length and the cable length into pretension loads so as to calculate the cable forces for each construction stage. As long as 'Lack-of-Fit Force' function is used, it is possible to analyze staged construction with forward analysis alone without backward analysis.

'Lack-of-Fit Force'(LFF) signifies 'Additional Pretension', which is introduced during the cable installation where the change of structural behavior and structural system are considered, or 'Pre-applied Force', which is pre-applied to the key segment so that the key segment can be located at the same position as the completed system when the key segment is to be closed. During the forward analysis, if the program calculates the 'Lack-of-Fit Forces' for the cable and key segment elements and these 'Lack-of-Fit Forces' are reflected in the installation of cable and key segment, the final stage result from the forward analysis will coincide with the result from the initial equilibrium state analysis.

Test Model (3 span cable stayed bridge)

Forward Analysis for a Cable Stayed Bridge
For a real design of a cable stayed bridge, connection of key segment and generation of side span supports, temporary bents, temporary rigid link between tower and girder and elastic link between tower and girder, which are the factors affecting the structural behavior, should be included. The forward analysis using Lack of Fit Force should be evaluated on various structural cases in order to be used for a real bridge. Therefore, before we apply forward analysis using LFF to a real bridge, we will verify the applicability of LFF function by performing the forward construction stage analysis for a simplified bridge, which includes key segment closure, boundary condition change during construction stages and installation and removal of temporary bents.

Test Model is a 2D 3-span continuous symmetrical cable stayed bridge. The total bridge length is 170m (40+90+40). The 8 cables are supporting the bridge.

Forward Analysis for a Cable Stayed Bridge
The "Backward Forward" results were obtained like this; first, cable force for each stage was obtained from backward analysis and the cable pretension was introduced as External Type Pretension for forward analysis. To consider the effect of key segment, LFF was applied to the key segment (beam) element.

As seen in the results, when the forward analysis without considering LFF is used (and the cable force for each stage is calculated by backward analysis), less cable pretension than it should be introduced, so the displacement at the final stage is greater than the displacement from the initial equilibrium state analysis and the cable force is smaller as a whole. Likewise, girder has the greater positive and negative moments than those from the initial equilibrium state analysis. On the other hand, when the forward analysis using LFF is used (and the cable force is calculated from the initial equilibrium state analysis), the displacements at tower and girder, the girder moment and the cable force are the same as those from the initial equilibrium state analysis.

Forward Analysis for a Cable Stayed Bridge
When LFF is considered for Truss only, both ends of the key segment are deflected upward at the stage immediately before the key segment closure. Since the key segment is closed from the position, large upward deflection results in at the final stage.

Conclusion

Forward analysis is carried out following the construction sequence and backward analysis is performed by removing structural members step by step from the completed system. Up to now, after initial equilibrium state analysis (at completed system) has been performed, backward analysis has been performed to find the cable forces for each stage and then based on these cable forces forward analysis has been performed. However, backward analysis is inconvenient compared to forward analysis and time dependent effects cannot be reflected in the backward analysis. According to the cable theory, forward analysis and backward analysis give the same result within elastic range as long as the unstressed cable length are obtained from the initial equilibrium state analysis (at completed system). In this test model case, we have seen that it is possible to analyze a cable stayed bridge, using Lack of Fit Force function, by forward analysis alone without backward analysis.
Cusmat: Offering Immersive Learning Techniques
Cusmat’s Metaverse-based training and upskilling tools for technicians and operators in Mining, Logistics & Manufacturing industries are making training and recruitment more efficient, faster, and cost-effective. Cusmat is providing virtual reality or augmented

Read more ...

Driving Efficiency & Productivity with Smart Construction
As construction projects become more complex, construction companies must infuse agility into their operations to avert time and cost overruns by tapping into the benefits of advanced technology solutions like Building Information Modeling

Read more ...

Technology Boosting Jobsite Connectivity
While jobsite connectivity is making sure that information is transferring to the right individuals at the right moment so that they can do their jobs more effectively, however, executing jobsite connectivity is a completely different matter as every

Read more ...

Robots in Construction
Adopting Robots in construction can help maintain productivity at a time when fewer people are pursuing a career in the industry: GlobalData. The construction industry’s lack of digitalization and new technologies mean that companies will struggle to

Read more ...

Predictive Analytics is at the heart of Digital Transformation in the Energy Industry
Senthilkumar Pandi, a Digital Data Management expert, explains how Predictive Analytics enable the Energy Industry to prevent costly and unexpected downtimes, and suggests how to choose the right solution.Though digitalization has been

Read more ...

Continental presents IoT suite for pits, mines, and construction sites
Continental’s IoT solution SightIQ will set new standards for the productivity management of quarries, mines, and construction sites. SightIQ can integrate virtually all data available to a manager from mobile machines, vehicles and

Read more ...

How Technology Fast Tracks Delivery of Unique Construction Projects in India
Technology companies have developed hardware and software solutions to help manage every aspect of a construction project, no matter how complex or massive the project may be. Harsh Pareek, Regional Sales Director, India and SAARC, Trimble Solutions

Read more ...

Delhi Metro Rail Corporation Finalizes Alignment Design for Phase IV Expansion Project with the help of Bentley’s Rail Design Application
The Delhi Metro Rail Corporation is working on its Phase IV expansion to improve rail connectivity between Delhi and the further regions of the National Capital Region. The project includes constructing a 104-km metro railway line that connects the Majlis Park metro station

Read more ...

Contribution of Technology & Digital Transformation to Net Zero Future
Senthilkumar Pandi, Head of Project Execution Systems – CAD/EDMS, highlights the relevance of technology in facilitating sustainable development. Digital Transformation, which was just a buzz a few years ago, is now inevitable for any business to sustain

Read more ...

Technological Improvements in Construction
Pre-Engineered & PPVC Building Technologies are bridging the gap in construction with faster, more cost-effective, high quality and sustainable structures. H. L. Chawla, Former Consultant, The World Bank & ILO

Read more ...

Digital Twin: The Age of Aquarius in Construction and Real Estate
In line with the fourth industrial revolution, investing in technological automation has evolved from speculative to mission critical. The digital twin is at the forefront of this movement. First movers in healthcare, energy and

Read more ...

Intelliwave SiteSense®  Materials Management
SiteSense helps Material Managers digitize materials management processes by helping them to effectively and accurately communicate material location and status with the construction teams

Read more ...

Buildsys Construction productivity app paves way for digital revolution in the industry
The construction industry has been held back from achieving its full potential by processes that are outdated, inefficient and time-consuming. Scattered information sources make locating critical data difficult, and poor coordination between disciplines leads to errors in construction

Read more ...

Trimble Introduces Tekla 2020 Structural BIM Software Solutions
Trimble has introduced the latest versions of its Tekla software solutions for advanced Building Information Modeling (BIM), structural engineering and steel fabrication management—Tekla Structures 2020, Tekla Structural Designer

Read more ...

Constructible BIM: Empowering civil engineers - to build with confidence
India is among the fastest urbanizing societies in the world today, and the country’s urban population is projected to eclipse its rural population by 2050. This rapid demographic transformation requires an unprecedented growth in

Read more ...

Moving is Always Stressful - 3D software helps engineers prove their clients' new 'home' is ready for work
Whether it's moving across town or across the country, there are always boxes to pack and trucks to fill. But what if the core of your business IS trucks and you didn't have a choice about moving? That's exactly

Read more ...

Quest Informatics offers advantages of BOT engagement
Quest Informatics’ BOT engagement model brings twin advantages of integrated offerings and change management to clients. BOT engagement covers the entire range of before-market

Read more ...

Tata Technologies to work on turnkey projects in Off-highway CE business
Tata Technologies, a fast-growing engineering services and manufacturing enterprise IT, plans to leverage its business presence in the growing off-highway construction equipment business through

Read more ...

ARI offers scalable simulation solutions
ARI designs and develops high-specification complex simulation systems used in training, screening, feasibility analysis and process development. ARI offers scalable simulation solutions

Read more ...

Fully Stressed Design of Pratt and Howe Trusses
In this study, fully stressed design of steel Pratt and Howe trusses have been carried out. Total 24 cases for each truss were analyzed using STAAD.Pro software and optimal cross sectional areas of all members of both trusses calculated using fully stressed design concept. A comparison is made between Pratt and Howe Truss on basis of optimal mass

Read more ...