Shriram Bapat, Retd.Chief Engineer Civil, NPCIL, Mumbai

Prestressed concrete slab (PT slab) construction has gained wide importance as a state of art technology, due to a number of engineering solutions and economy that it provides. Conventional usage of bright metal sheets as duct material have explicit problems of corrosion, duct opening leading to slurry intrusion and higher short-term losses due to the large values of friction and wobble coefficients. Further, one-end stressing operation may lead in to inefficiency of the prestressing system. The use of HDPE material, as prestressing duct, can eliminate the inherent problems associated with the metal ducts and reduce the prestress losses. Both end stressing using HDPE sheathing is the best combination for PT slabs.

Introduction

Prestressed concrete slabs (PT slabs) are the state of art construction technology and are provided these days for almost all commercial complexes. This concept is also being adopted for some large scale residential complexes. As the concrete quantities as well as reinforcement steel quantities get reduced when this concept is adopted, it is getting popular. Additionally, one gets clear headroom, as the floor beams are eliminated. This paper highlights the cost effectiveness of use of HDPE sheathing compared to bright metal sheathing which is conventionally used in the industry.

Sheathing Material

Three different types of sheathing materials are available in the market and are in general being used for housing the prestressing tendons.
  • Bright Metal Sheathing
  • Lead Coated Metal Sheathing
  • Galvanized Metal Sheathing
All the above sheathings are manufactured as round sheathing and then pressed to get a flat sheath, suitable for PT Slab. In the process of converting round sheath to flat sheath, there are chances of getting non-uniform profile of the flat duct as well as there are chances of opening of joints, which further leads to chances entry of slurry into the sheath while concreting. The flat HDPE duct is ideal in this situation, as the shape will be uniform and absolutely no possibility of leakage of slurry into the duct, while concreting.

Table-1: Comparison of Wobble and Friction Coefficient Values
Type of sheath Wobble coefficient Friction coefficient
Bright Metal 0.0046 0.25
Galvanized  Metal 0.0030 0.20
Lead coated Metal 0.0030 0.18
H.D.P.E. 0.0020 0.17

In addition to the advantages of the HDPE duct as mentioned above, HDPE ducts have lower values for co-efficient of friction and wobble co-efficient, leading to reduced short-term prestress losses during pre-stressing operation. Table-1 gives values of friction and wobble co-efficients for different types of sheathing ducts.

HDPE flat duct was not being manufactured in India till recently. Now, one manufacturer has successfully developed and came forward to manufacture and supply of HDPE flat duct.

Present Study

In view of lower value of friction and wobble coefficients for HDPE duct, when compared with those values for Bright Metal duct, which is commonly used in PT industry, a study was undertaken to work out economy in using HDPE duct. Different column grids, corresponding column sizes, slab thickness and drop slab thickness were considered. Table-2 gives the considered combinations.

Table-2: Combination Considered for the Case Study
Sr No. Grid Size(m) Column Size(mm) Slab Thickness(mm) Drop Size(mm)
1 8 x 8 700 X 700 200 3000 X 3000 X 375
2 9 x 9 700 X 700 200 3000 X 3000 X 375
3 10 x 10 800 X 800 225 3500 X 3500 X 400
4 11 X 11 900 X 900 250 4000 X 4000 X 450
5 12 X 12 900 X 900 265 4000 X 4000 X 475

Five panels have been considered in X-direction and three panels have been considered in Y-direction. Stressing has been done from alternate end in both the direction as one case and in other case, stressing is considered from alternate end in Y-direction and from both ends in X-direction. ADAPT FLOOR PRO 3D (Builder) software of Dr. ALAMI has been used for analytical work.

Table-3: Comparison of H.T. strand requirements using Bright Metal Duct and HDPE Duct
Column Slab Drop Panel COLUMN Both End Stressing Alternate End Stressing
BM HDPE BM HDPE
HTS HTS HTS HTS
Grid Thk. Size Size (Kg/sq.m.) (Kg/sq.m.) (Kg/sq.m.) (Kg/sq.m.)
8X8 200 3X3X0.375 700X700 3.4 3 3.4 3.1
9 200 3X3X0.375 700X700 4 3.64 4 3.81
10 225 3.5X3.5X0.400 800X800 4.4 3.9 4.5 4
11 250 4X4X0.450 900X900 4.6 4.24 4.7 4.3
12 250 4X4X.500 900X900 5.4 5.0 5.6 5.35

Results

On the basis of analytical results, the requirement of H.T. strand per square meter of slab has been worked out. Table-3 gives comparison of H.T. strand requirement using Bright Metal and HDPE flat duct and Table-4 gives percentage saving of H.T. strand when HDPE flat duct is used, in place of Bright Metal Duct.

Table-4: Percentage Saving in H.T. Strand
Column Grid % SAVING
Size Both End Stressing Alternate End Stressing
8X8 11.7 08.0
9X9 09.0 04.8
10X10 11.4 11.0
11X11 07.8 08.5
12X12 07.40 04.50

Conclusion

It can be seen from the Table-4 that there is substantial saving in requirement of H.T. strands when HDPE duct is used, in place of conventionally used Bright Metal duct. The range of saving is 4.50% to 8.5% when conventional alternate end stressing is resorted to. The saving goes up in the range of 7.4% to 11.7%, when both end stressing is resorted to. Additionally, there is marginal saving in requirement of duct length and number of anchorages.

When conventionally used Bright Metal Ducts are provided in PT Slab construction, they get corroded during construction stage itself (particularly in and around Mumbai coastal region). This increases friction and thus the frictional losses also go up. Use of HDPE flat duct will eliminate this problem.

On the basis of study following is recommended:
  • HDPE flat duct shall be used in PT Slab construction.
  • Both end stressing shall be resorted to, in place of conventional method of alternate end stressing.
  • 8 m x 8 m column grid seems to be most economical choice in selecting column grid at planning stage.

Acknowledgment

The author acknowledges the analytical help provided by Shri Umesh Bhujbalrao of M/s.VSIL, Bhopal. Preparation of this paper was possible due to constant pursuance by Shri C.B.Dandekar of M/s.REX Polyextrusion Ltd, Sangli, manufacturers of HDPE flat duct.
Finnish company Betolar expands to Indian concrete markets with a cement-free concrete solution
Betolar, a Finnish start-up, and innovator of geopolymer concrete solution Geoprime®, has expanded its operations to Europe and Asian markets including India, Vietnam and Indonesia. Betolar’s innovation Geoprime® is the next-generation, low carbon

Read more ...

Why Fly Ash Bricks Are Better Than Clay/Red Bricks
It is estimated that in India each million clay bricks consume about 200 tons of coal and emit around 270 tons of CO2; on the other hand, with fly ash bricks production in an energy-free route, there are no emissions. Dr. N. Subramanian, Consulting

Read more ...

Low Fines, Low Viscosity, Self-Consolidating Concrete for Better Impact on CO2 Emissions
Production of low fines SCC with increased robustness in a highly flowable, less viscous condition meeting true SCC specifications is now a reality to help realise the architect’s and engineer’s dream of various complex profiles and shapes in

Read more ...

Methods & Factors for Design of Slabs-on-Grade
Sunitha K Nayar, gives the grouping of slabs-on-grade based on the design philosophies and a brief overview of the different design methods, the commonalities between design strategies in terms of the input parameters, assumed and estimated parameters, and the

Read more ...

FIBERCRETE®: Synthetic Fibers for Concrete Reinforcement
Kalyani Polymers is offering world-class made-in-India Synthetic Micro & Macro Concrete Fiber Products for the Construction Industry under the brand name FIBERCRETE®. Concrete is an integral part of any construction project, it can be roads, tall structures

Read more ...

Climate Control Concrete
Leading cement and concrete maker ACC has unveiled a revolutionary thermal insulating climate control concrete system in India. Sridhar Balakrishnan, MD & CEO, ACC Limited, discusses its attributes, applications, and benefits for home builders, architects

Read more ...

Innovations in Crack Bridging with Self-Healing Bacteria in Concrete
Dr. Manjunatha L R, Vice President - Direct Sales & Sustainability Initiatives, and Raghavendra, Senior officer, JSW Cement Limited, discuss bacterial concrete that can meet the requirements for strength, durability, and self-healing of cracks.

Read more ...

Sustainable Development Through Use of Self-Curing Concrete
Dada S. Patil, Assistant Professor, Civil Engineering Department, AIKTC, Panvel, Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra; Dr. S. B. Anadinni, Professor & Associate Dean (Core Branches), School of Engineering, Presidency University, Bengaluru; and Dr. A. V. Shivapur, Professor

Read more ...

Developing a Corrosion Resistant RCC Structure
Samir Surlaker, Director, Assess Build Chem Private Limited, emphasizes the importance of a clear cover for a concrete structure since concrete as a porous material needs protection of its reinforcement. Along with the thickness (quantity) of cover, the porosity of

Read more ...

Quest for Higher Strength Concrete From HSC to UHPC
Concrete technology has come a long way since the Romans discovered the material, with a number of ingredients, which include a host of mineral and chemical admixtures, besides of course, the Portland cement, aggregates (coarse and fine), and water. These ingredients

Read more ...

Modelling Methods for Protection of RCC Structures
Anil Kumar Pillai, GM, Ramco Cements, discusses two major softwares (Life 365 and DuraCrete), used in the industry for protection of RCC structures. The common design approach is faulty because we consider only the loading aspect, whereas the environmental aspect is equally

Read more ...

Bajaj Reinforcements LLP - Introduces Fibre Tuff heavy-duty synthetic fibres that offer a range of benefits to concrete
Fibre Tuff, macro synthetic polypropylene fibres, are heavy-duty synthetic fibres that are specially engineered for use as secondary reinforcements, providing excellent resistance to the post cracking capacity of concrete. They are replacing steel fibres in a range

Read more ...

Use of Headed Bars in Reinforced Concrete Design
Reinforced concrete design and construction practice has historically focused on the use of bonded straight or bend rebar as a method for rebar anchorage. This relies on bond integrity between the rebar and the concrete so that sufficient anchorage

Read more ...

Innovation easy, effective and economical tool for asset creation
Innovation and entrepreneurship are essential ingredients in building a successful commercial venture. The ways in which these two concepts fuel enterprise are something entrepreneur's never stop exploring. There is no doubt that innovation were

Read more ...

Reactivity of Alite and Belite towards Sustainability of Concrete
Alite and belite are the predominant phases of Portland cement formulation. Alite is impure tricalcium silicate (C3S) and belite is impure dicalcium silicate (C2S). The impurities are an integral part as cement is manufactured

Read more ...

Innovative, Economic, Durable and Sustainable Concrete to last for +100 years of service life
Concrete is a versatile construction material and day by day its consumption is increasing globally. It is second only to water in the global consumption. No civil engineering structure is feasible without using concrete

Read more ...

Nanospan India Pvt Ltd
The use of Graphene with concrete has been talked about and researched ever since Graphene was invented in 2010 which grabbed its inventors a Nobel prize. Nanospan is the first company in the world to break technological and commercial

Read more ...

Fosroc: Building, Cementing & Supporting
Fosroc is the foundation of the JMH Group. It employs over 1700 employees in 17 operating companies based in Europe, the Gulf & Middle East, India, South Asia, and China. Through FGT, its trading company, it services another 50 countries

Read more ...

Dextra Group
Established in 1983 by French expatriate entrepreneurs, the Dextra Group has a long history of growth and development, driven by strong entrepreneurship and innovation. It has diversified into three main activities: manufacturing, trading and freight forwarding

Read more ...

Ferrochrome Ash Based Geopolymer Concrete
Jyotirmoy Mishra, Ph.D. Scholar, Department of Civil Engineering, Veer Surendra Sai University of Technology, Burla, Odisha, presents his research on the feasibility and compressive strength performance of geopolymer concrete

Read more ...

×
Sign-up for Free Subscription
'India Construction Week'
Weekly e-Newsletter on Construction Industry
Get the latest news, product launches, projects announced / awarded, government policies, investments, and expert views.
Click here to subscribe.
×