Self Compacting Cocrete

Dr. S.C. Maiti, Ex–Joint Director, National Council for Cement & Building Materials, New Delhi. Raj K Agarwal, Managing Director, Marketing & Transit (India) Pvt. Ltd, New Delhi.

Introduction

Concrete mixtures having high workability and high cohesiveness will be self–compacting concrete. The self–compacting concrete (SCC) is defined as a flowing concrete that can be transported without any segregation and placed without the use of vibrators to construct concrete structures free of honeycombs. Initially such concrete was developed by Japanese researchers. For such concrete which is specially required for heavily reinforced sections, a viscosity modifying agent (VMA) is required along with a polycarboxylic ether (PCE) based superplastisizer. Because of high fluidity, SCC requires higher fines content, in order to resist bleeding and segregation. Natural fine aggregate together with manufactured sand and mineral admixture {flyash or ground granulated blast furnace slag (ggbs) or silica fume} provide higher fines contents in the concrete mix. A cohesive SCC is thus produced in order to flow steadily in the heavily reinforced concrete sections, without any segregation & bleeding.

Materials and Mix Proportions

Besides cement, water and aggregates, the necessary ingredients for producing SCC are superplasticizers (PCE based), viscosity–modifying agents and mineral admixtures e.g. flyash, ground granulated blast furnace slag & silica fume. The proportion of fine aggregates required is higher, may be around 55% and the corresponding proportion of coarse aggregate (generally of smaller size, say 10 or 12 mm maximum size) will be around 45%. The mineral admixtures and fine sand (manufactured sand) are required to make the highworkability concrete mix cohesive.

Typical concrete mix proportions for high strength (74.5 MPa at 28 days) SCC used by Gettu & others (from Spain) (1) are as follows:
  • Cement (OPC-53 grade) = 428 Kg/ m3
  • Water = 188 l/ m3
  • Flyash (2935 cm2 / gm) = 257 Kg / m3
  • Superplasticizer (vinyl copolymer) = 7.9 Kg / m3
  • Sand (crushed limestone ) (0-5mm) = 788 Kg / m3
  • Coarse aggregate (gravel) (5-12mm) = 736 Kg / m3
The water / binder ratio of the concrete mix is 0.27. A look at the materials & mix proportions indicate use of smaller size coarse aggregate (12mm maximum size) & the shape is rounded, being gravel aggregate. In fact, crushed gravel will be a better option in order to obtain high- workability and highstrength SCC.

The workability measured for the above mix is “ slump flow” of 48cm. In our country, still we are carrying out the usual slump test even for high–workability concrete mix. The “flow test” as specified in IS 9103 (2) can be conducted for testing such high–workability concrete mix, but the “slump flow test” will be better than the “flow test,” as no lifting (15 times in 15 seconds) of concrete is necessary, as the SCC is a flowing concrete mixture.

Vachhani and others (3) used SCC in the prestigious Delhi Metro construction. Concrete mix proportions for M-35 grade of SCC are as follows :
  • Cement = 330 Kg / m3
  • Water = 163 l / m3
  • Flyash = 150 Kg / m3
  • Superplasticizer = 3.12 l / m3
  • VMA ( glenium stream 2 ) = 1.3 l / m3
  • Retarder ( Pozzolith 300 R) = 0.99 l / m3
  • Sand = 917 Kg / m3
  • Coarse aggregate:
  • 20mm maximum size = 455 Kg / m3
  • 10 mm maximum size = 309 Kg / m3
Vachhani and others (3) highlighted the mechanism of self compaction, which is based on :
  1. Large quantity of “fines” (500 to 650 Kg / m3),
  2. Use of high –range water – reducing superplasticizers (with water- reduction of 25%), and
  3. The use of Viscosity Modifying Admixtures.
“Fines” includes cement, flyash and the part of sand of size less than 0.125 mm. This together with water & chemical admixtures constitute the paste in the concrete mix. The paste makes the concrete mix cohesive and controls the segregation–resistance of the mix. The polycarboxylic ether–based superplasticizer ( presently being imported) generally provides water–reduction of the order of 30-40 % in the concrete mix. The VMA improves the segregation–resistance of the mix without changing the fluidity or workability. The retarder in the concrete mix controls the workability–retention, which is specially important in hot climate.

Fresh Self–Compacting Concrete

The characteristics of fresh SCC are fully described by the following properties :
  1. Filling ability–ability to completely fill all the spaces in the formwork,
  2. Passing ability–ability to flow around reinforcement, and
  3. Segregation resistance–ability to resist segregation of materials during transportation and placing.
Consequently new test methods have been developed to test SCC in the fresh state. The “filling ability” is tested by “ slump flow” and “ V funnel,“ the “passing ability” is tested by “L- Box“ and“ U–Box“ and the segregation–resistance is tested by “ V- funnel”

Hardened Self–Compacting Concrete

The properties and characteristics of hardened SCC do not greatly differ from those of normal concrete, except that SCC can not be used in mass concrete construction using bigger size aggregates, say 75mm or 150mm sizes. Because such concrete always needs to be compacted with needle vibrators, in order to compact thoroughly in the forms.

Any required compressive strength of SCC can be achieved. Vachhani & others (3) obtained 28- day compressive strength of 44-49 MPa in the above–mentioned concrete mix proportions for M-35 grade concrete, for the Delhi Metro construction.

The high – strength SCC can be called “ High–performance concrete,” as such concrete has denser microstructure with lower inherent “porosity” and “permeability,” because of lower water- cementitious materials ratios and use of mineral admixtures in concrete.

Concrete Mix Proportioning Approach

The Self–Compacting Concrete, because of its high–workability and cohesiveness, generally needs higher fines content and lower size (10 or 12 mm maximum size) of coarse aggregate. Smoother and rounded or semi- rounded (may be crushed gravel) coarse aggregate will develop cohesiveness in the concrete mix. Bapat’s (4) suggestion is good. Flakiness & elongation indices of coarse aggregate should be less than 15% each. Large quantity of fines is also required–500 to 650 Kg/m3 of concrete, & therefore crushed stone fine aggregate is also required along with natural fine aggregate. Flyash has also been used as an essential ingredient of SCC. In India, 30 to 50% flyash has been used in SCC. Originally Japanese people (5) suggested water–powder ratio between 0.90 & 1.1 (by volume). But it is the paste that controls the segregation of the concrete mix. The powder & the paste includes finer ( less than 0.125mm) part of the fine aggregate. Vachhani (3) & Bapat (4) used about 35 to 36% paste to produce self compacting concrete. The viscosity modifying agent also controls the segregation– resistance of the concrete mix.They are generally starch, cellulose & gum–based. Preferable & satisfactory VMA is “Welan Gum.” The quantity of such VMA required in SCC is very less, about 0.1% by weight of cementitious materials.

Prof P.K. Mehta (6) included “Welangum,” silica fumes & ultrafine colloidal silica under the list of VMA. Gum or cellulose– based material is capable of modifying the viscosity of SCC, but the silica fume may not be able to modify the viscosity of concrete. Subramanian and Chattopadhyay (7) observed that micro silica at an appropriate dosage may be beneficial in reducing the dosage of “Welan gum.”

The following mix proportioning steps for SCC can be followed.
  • The target 28-day compressive strength of concrete can be calculated first based on standard deviation value used for the specified grade of concrete.
  • The water–cementitious materials ratio can be decided based on the target 28–day compressive strength of concrete. This can be in the range of 0.30 – 0.50, 0.30 for a 28 day compressive strength of about 90 MPa, while 0.50 for a 28 day compressive strength of about 30 MPa .
  • For the high – workability concrete mix, the water content of concrete will be in the range of 180 – 190 l/m3 of concrete.
  • The maximum size of aggregate for SCC is more or less fixed at 10 or 12 or 16 mm.
  • The sand (natural + manufactured) content can be kept at about 55% & the coarse aggregate content can be about 45%, by weight of total aggregate.
  • The superplasticizer required is PCE–based and about 1% by weight of total cementitious material. The cementitious material includes ordinary Portland cement, flyash /ggbs & silica fume (in case of high strength concrete). For normal strength concrete (say from M-25 to M-50), no silica fume will be required, but about 20 to 30 % good quality flyash will be required. If ggbs is used in place of flyash, its percentage can be 40 to 50 %, by weight of total cementitious material. For high strength concrete of M-60 to M-80, about 10% silica fume will be required instead of flyash or ggbs. The dosage of super plsticizer & the viscosity modifying agent can be fixed based on one or two trial mixes in a laboratory.
  • With the above details in hand, concrete mix proportions for any grade of SCC can be arrived at.

Conclusions

The self compacting concrete, a high workability cohesive concrete mix needs polycarboxylic ether–based superplasticizer and a viscosity modifying agent.

The proportion of fine materials in the concrete mix is also higher than that of normal concrete mixes. Therefore, in addition to natural fine aggregate, manufactured sand and mineral admixture eg flyash, ggbs or silica fume is also to be used.The percentage of fine aggregate is around 55%, while that of coarse aggregate is around 45%, by weight of total aggregate. Smaller size of coarse aggregate (10,12 or 16mm maximum size) having soother surface texture (rounded or crushed gravel) is required for concrete to flow smoothly in the formwork. For normal “standard” concrete grades of M-25 to M-50, about 20 to 30 % flyash or 40 to 50 % ggbs can be used, whereas for high strength self – compacting concrete of grades M-60 to M-80, 10 % silica fume will be required.

References

  • Gettu,R, Izquierdo, J, Gomes, P.C.C & Josa, A. Development of high – strength self- compacting concrete with flyash: a four – step experimental methodology. 27th conference on OUR WORLD IN CONCRETE & STRUCTURES : 29 – 30 August 2002, Singapore, pp.217 – 224.
  • IS 9103. Specification for concrete admixtures. Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi.
  • Vachhani, S.R, Chaudary, R & Jha, S.M. Innovative use of self compacting concrete in Metro construction. I.C I Journal, Vol. 5, No 3, Oct – Dec 2004, pp.27 -32.
  • Bapat, S.G, Kulkarni, S.B & Bandekar, K.S. Self- compacting concrete in nuclear power plant construction. I.C.I Journal, Vol-6, No 3, Oct- Dec 2005, pp- 37- 40.
  • Okamura,H, Ozawa,K & Ouchi,M. Selfcompacting concrete. Structural Concrete, Vol-1, No1, March 2000.
  • Mehta,P.K & Monteiro,P.J.M. Concrete-Microstructure, Properties & Materials. Third edition, 2006, Tata McGraw –Hill Publishing Co Ltd, New Delhi, p.478.
  • Subramanian, S & Chattopadhyay, D. Experiments for mix proportioning of Self – compacting concrete. The Indian Concrete Journal, Jan 2002, pp. 13 – 20.
Concrete Rheology - Unveiling the Secrets of Concrete
Concrete is a heterogeneous composite complex material, and its hardened property is influenced by its fresh property. Concrete today has transformed into an advanced type with new and innovative ingredients added - either singly or in

Read more ...

ICRETE: Making Concrete Economical
ICRETE offers many benefits apart from reducing cement content and giving high grades saving to ready-mix concrete companies; it helps reduce shrinkage and permeability in concrete slabs, increases the durability of concrete, and also works

Read more ...

UltraTech Cement to implement Coolbrook’s RotoDynamic HeaterTM revolutionary technology for industrial electrification
UltraTech Cement Limited, India’s largest cement and ready-mix concrete (RMC) company, and Coolbrook, a transformational technology and engineering company, will jointly develop a project to implement Coolbrook’s RotoDynamic HeaterTM (RDH)

Read more ...

Plastic Shrinkage and Cracks in Concrete
Plastic shrinkage cracking occurs when fresh concrete is subjected to a very rapid loss of moisture. It is caused by a combination of factors such as air and concrete temperature, relative humidity, and wind velocity at the surface of concrete. These can cause

Read more ...

Mechanised way of plastering with spray Plaster Machine
This paper covers the research work carried out on cement plastering process for internal and external building wall by using spray plastering machine. Objective of study is to experiment and compare the plastering activity by conventional way and

Read more ...

Construction Defects Investigation & Remedies
In recent years, the speed of construction has increased very fast; buildings which used to take 3-5 years are now getting completed in 1-2 years. There is a race to complete projects faster, but due to this speedy construction, the quality of construction is often

Read more ...

Challenges in usage of Hydrogen in Cement Industry
With its zero-emission characteristics, hydrogen has become a promising decarbonization path for the cement industry. While there are several issues that need to be resolved in the use of hydrogen, there are also many advantages, so much so that the growth

Read more ...

Enhancing Corrosion Resistance of Steel Bars in Reinforced Concrete Structures
Reinforced concrete is a composite material which is made using concrete and steel bars. Concrete takes the compressive forces and steel bar takes tensile forces. Concrete around the steel bar protects it from corrosion by providing an alkaline environment

Read more ...

Moving toward workability retention to rheology retention with low viscosity concrete technology
Amol Patil, Sr. Specialist - General Manager (Admixture and Specialty Products), Master Builders Solutions (India), and Nilotpol KAR, Managing Director, Master Builders Solutions (South Asia), present a paper on the concept of low viscosity concrete in

Read more ...

Cement industry innovating eco-friendly packaging
Cement companies are constantly innovating to meet global sustainability standards and improve logistics, shelf life, and utility of cement, while reducing wastage. Thei aim is to reduce their environmental impact without compromising their product

Read more ...

IIT Madras uses Solar Thermal Energy to Recycle Waste concrete
Researchers at the Indian Institute of Technology Madras have developed a treatment process using solar thermal energy to recycle construction and demolition debris. Waste concrete from demolition was heated using solar radiation to produce recycled concrete

Read more ...

Textile Reinforced Concrete - A Novel Construction Material of the Future
As a new-age innovative building material, TRC is especially suited for maintenance of existing structures, for manufacturing new lightweight precast members, or as a secondary building material to aid the main building material. Textile Reinforced Concrete

Read more ...

Technological Innovation for Use of Bottom Ash by-product of Thermal Power Plants in the Production of Concrete
The day is not far for the adoption of this innovative, eco-friendly, and cost-effective bottom ash – concrete process technology by construction agencies undertaking road/infrastructure project works, real estate developers, ready mix concrete (RMC) operators

Read more ...

Headed Bars in Concrete Construction
Using headed bars instead of hooked bars offer several advantages like requirement of reduced development length, less congestion, ease of transport and fixing at site, better concrete consolidation, and better performance under seismic loads.

Read more ...

Sustainability of Cement Concrete - Research Experience at CRRI on Sustainability of Concrete from Materials Perspective
It can be said that ever since the publication of the document of World Commission on Environment and Development [1], the focus of the world has diverted towards sustainability. Gro Harlem Bruntland [1] defined sustainable development as “development

Read more ...

Shrinkage, Creep, Crack-Width, Deflection in Concrete
The effects of shrinkage, creep, crack-width, and deflection in concrete are often ignored by designers while designing structural members. These effects, if not considered in some special cases such as long span slabs or long cantilevers, may become very

Read more ...

Concrete Relief Shelve Walls - An Innovative Method of Earth Retention
Relief shelve walls are a unique concept that use only conventional construction materials like PCC / RCC / steel reinforcements, and work on a completely different fundamental to resist the lateral load caused due to soil. Information on the various dimensions

Read more ...

Carbon Neutrality in Cement Industry A Global Perspective
Increasing energy costs, overcapacity, and environmental pollution are the top concerns of the cement industry, which is one of the major contributors to CO2 emissions. Dr S B Hegde, Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Jain College of Engineering

Read more ...

Finnish company Betolar expands to Indian concrete markets with a cement-free concrete solution
Betolar, a Finnish start-up, and innovator of geopolymer concrete solution Geoprime®, has expanded its operations to Europe and Asian markets including India, Vietnam and Indonesia. Betolar’s innovation Geoprime® is the next-generation, low carbon

Read more ...

Why Fly Ash Bricks Are Better Than Clay/Red Bricks
It is estimated that in India each million clay bricks consume about 200 tons of coal and emit around 270 tons of CO2; on the other hand, with fly ash bricks production in an energy-free route, there are no emissions. Dr. N. Subramanian, Consulting

Read more ...