Importance of Realistic Cable Models in the Design of Prestressed Concrete Structures

Importance of Realistic Cable Models in the Design of Prestressed Concrete Structures

Saleem Akhtar, Dr.K.K.Pathak, Dr. S.S.Bhadauria, Dept. Civil Engg., UIT, RGTU Bhopal CSD Group, AMPRI (CSIR) Bhopal.

Concrete is perhaps the most important construction material due to its various added advantages. The major problem with concrete is that it is very weak in tension. To strengthen the concrete to withstand tensile stresses, reinforced and prestressed concrete have been developed. In prestressed concrete, cable layout plays vital role in reducing tension from the concrete. Due to curvature cable exerts forces on the concrete to counterbalance the forces causing tension. Cables are laid as a continuous curve but for analysis purpose, they are modeled by some mathematical curve. The most important of them is the discrete parabolic modeling in different spans. Parabolic modeling simplifies the analysis to large extent but in this process cable geometry at the intermediate supports becomes discontinuous. To have more realistic models, we have used reverse parabolas and B-spline curves for cable modeling. These curves not only ensure the smooth profile but also provide realistic stress value. In this study, on comparing the results of these three different models, it is found that there is significant variation in stress values at intermediate supports, which clearly indicates the importance of realistic cable modeling.


Spline curve
While analysing prestressed concrete beams in the text books 1-4, the prestressing cable is assumed to traverse parabolic profile. The reason being, for parabolic profile, curvature becomes constant and cable force can berepresented as an equivalent uniformly distributed load acting in the opposite direction to the working loads. Although, parabolic assumption simplifies analysis, thecable profile becomes discont–inuous at intermediate supports. Actual cable profile is like a smooth spline. In this study, prestressed concrete beams are analysed for parabolic, reverse parabolas and B-spline profiles (Figure 1). Using these methodologies, two prestressed concrete beams have been analyzed. Results are compared in terms of stresses and deflections at various sections of the beam. It is observed that cable profile plays vital role on the stresses and deflections hence it should be properly accounted for analysis and design purposes.

Cable Models

In this study, following three different types of cable modeling i.e. parabolic, reverse parabolas, and B-spline are considered.

(a) Parabolic Modeling

A general parabola may be defined as y = ax2 . . . . (1)

The approximate constant curvature of this curve may be defined as- K » d2y/dx2 = 2a . . . . (2)

In continuous prestressed concrete structures where cable profile changes its curvature several times, each time a new parabola has to be defined. This is accounted through load balancing approach, analytically and STADD software, numerically.

(b) Reverse Parabolic Modeling

This method was proposed by Lin and Burn4. In this reverse parabolas are used at the support to maintain smooth– ness of the cable. Due to fitting of multi parabolas and mathematical complexities in maintaining the continuity at the juncture of two parabolas, this approach is quite involved. Since this models the true profile, results are quite close to the exact ones.

(c) B-Spline Modeling

A B-spline is a typical curve of the CAD philosophy5-6. It models a smooth curve between the given ordinates. Braibant and Fleury7, Pourazady et al8, Ghoddosian9 etc., have used this curve in shape optimization problems. When a B-spline curve is used the geometrical regularities are automatically taken care of. Following are few important properties of B-spline curve.

(1) The curve exhibits the variation diminishing properties. Thus the curve does not oscillate about any straight line more often than its defining polygon.

(2) The curve generally follows the shape of the defining polygon.

(3) The curve is transformed by transforming the defining polygonal vertices.

(4). The curve lies between the convex hull of its defining polygon (Figure 2).

(5). The order of the resulting curve can be changed without changing the number of defining polygon vertices (Figure 3).

The curvature of B spline curve, K, in a finite element is calculated using vector calculus as described in next section.

Finite Element Formulation

In this study, linear elastic analysis of prestressed concrete structures is carried out. Nine node Lagrangean element and three node curved bar element have been used to model the concrete and the cable. Cable is assumed to be embedded in the concrete. The radius of curvature R in the element is given by- R = 1/K . . . . (3)

Forces transferred by the cable to concrete element is shown in Figure 4. Assume curvature between 1&2 and 2&3 as equal to the curvature at two Gauss points. Let the length of the cable between 1-2 and 2-3 be approximated as-

Importance of Realistic Cable Models in the Design of Prestressed Concrete Structures

. . . . (4)

where (x1 ,y1), (x2 ,y2) and (x3 ,y3) are the co-ordinates of 1,2 and 3.

The tension variation in the bar element can be expressed by isoparametric interpolation as-

Tn=å3i=1Ti Nci . . . . . (5)

Nci’s are shape functions of the cable element.

Using the formulae of vector calculus, normal and tangential forces Pn and Pt are calculated in the following manner.

where Tn is the tension in the cable, T is the tangent vector, r is the local co-ordinate and R is the radius of curvature.

The resultant of these forces is given by-

Importance of Realistic Cable Models in the Design of Prestressed Concrete Structures

. . . . . (8)

Their equivalent finite element nodal forces are worked out using virtual work theorem. Perfect bond between cable and the concrete has been assumed. The detailed formulation of this can be found in Ref.10. Using these formulations, a FE software PRES2D has been developed in FORTRAN program–ming language.

Numerical Examples

Spline curve
To compare the effects of parabolic, reverse parabolas and B-spline modeling of the prestressing cable, two PC beams are analysed using PRES2D software. Following data are used for the analysis purpose:
  1. Wobble coefficient = 1x10-5
  2. Young’s modulus (concrete) = 2x104 N/mm2
  3. Young’s modulus (steel) = 2x105 N/mm2
  4. Density (concrete) = 2500 Kg/m3
  5. Poisson’s ratio = 0.15
  6. Cross sectional area of cable = 1600 mm2 Negligible friction is considered in this study.

(a) Two Span Beam with Uniformly Distributed Loading

A two span beam of 30 m length and 300mm x 750mm cross section with 23 KN/m uniformly distributed load (including self– weight) and prestressing force of 938 KN has been analyzed by load balancing method with idealized parabolic profile, Lin’s method [Lin and Burns (1995)] with actual cable profile considering two parabolic segments at midspan and two reversed parabolic segments at the support and proposed B-spline model. The idealized parabolic model and realistic model is shown in Figure 5(a) & (b). Parabolic model is accounted through load balancing approach analytically and through STADD software numerically. For FE analysis using B-spline model, the beam is discretised into 20 plane stress nine noded elements making total of 123 nodes as shown in Figure 5(c). Stresses at various locations due to different approaches are given in Table 1. Negative sign indicates compressive stresses. Deflections at middle of span are given in Table 2. It can be seen that conventional parabola approach results are in close match with STAAD results while the results of Lin’s approach are in good match with B-spline approach; particularly at the supports. It can also be observed that the top fibre stresses are compressive while the bottom stresses are more compressive in case of Lin’s method when compared to conventional parabolic layout, which is also observed from B-spline results. Deflection at mid span is less in case of Lin’s cable layout as well as B-spline cable profile compared to conventional approach (Table 2). It should be noted that design based on parabolic model would be erroneous as it results in lesser tensile stresses than the actual ones. The analysis considering two parabolic segments at mid span and two reversed parabolic segments at support, is very complex. The proposed approach using B-spline model of the cable overcomes these difficulties.

(b) Two Span Beam with Concentrated Loading

Spline curve
A two span beam of 24 m length and cross section of 300mm x 600mm with centrally applied concentrated loads of 150 KN and prestressing force of 1200 KN is taken up for comparision (Figure 6a). The beam is analyzed using load balancing method with two parabolas, Lin’s approach using 6 parabolic segments, STAAD software and by our approach using PRES2D software. For FE analysis the beam is divided into 20 nine nodded plane stress elements making a total of 123 nodes as shown in Figure 6b. Stresses and deflections due to different approaches are given in Table 3 and Table 4. It can be observed that stresses obtained om parabolic modeling and STAAD Pro software are close because both use same formulation. Realistic cable modeling by B-spline gives stresses comparable to Lin’s approach. But stress analysis by 6 parabolic segments model is very complex as the very modeling of these parabolas istedious. Designbased on B-spline model will be more accurate. It can be observed that tensile stresses due to Lin’s approach are on higher side. Hence design based on it will be conservative. Deflections at arious sections due to different approaches come out to be approximately the same.


In this study, a novel approach to analyse prestressed concrete beams is presented. Cables are modeled as B-spline. To make it user–friendly, this approach is coded in a 2D FE software where concrete is modeled by 9 node Lagrangian and cable by 3 node curved bar elements. Using this software two representative problems are analysed and results obtained from various methods are compared. It is observed that realistic cable modeling should be carried out to obtain true stresses and deflections for design considerations. Stresses are found to be more sensitive to the cable model than the deflections.


  • Hurst MK. Prestressed Concrete Design, First Edition,Chapman and Hall, London (1988).
  • Gilbert RI. Time Effects in Concrete Structures. Elsevier New York (1988).
  • Jain AK. Reinforced Concrete- Limit State Design. Nem Chand & Bros. Roorkee, (1989).
  • Lin TY, Burns NH. Design ofprestressed concrete structures, Third Edition, John Wiley and Sons. Inc.,New York (1982)
  • Qing SB, Liu Ding Yuan. Computational Geometry-Curve and Surface Modeling. Academic Press London (1989).
  • Rogers DF, Adams JA. Mathematical Elements for Computers Graphics. Second Edition McGraw Hill New York (1990).
  • Braibant V, Fleury C. Shape optimal design using B-splines. Comp. Meth. Appl. Meth. and Engg, 44,247-267, (1984).
  • Pourazady M, Fu Z. An integrated approach to structural shape optimization. Computers & Structures, 60(2), 274-289, (1996).
  • Ghoddosian A. Improved Zero Order Techniques for Structural Shape Optimization Using FEM. Ph.D Dissertation Applied Mechanics Dept. IIT Delhi (1998).
  • Pathak, K.K., Gradientless shape optimization of concrete structures using artificial neural networks, Ph.D Thesis, Deptt. of Applied Mechanics, IIT Delhi, March 2001.
Click Here
To Know More or to Contact the Manufacturer
Please let us know your name.
Invalid Input
Please let us know your Designation.
Please let us know your Contact Number.
Please let us know your email address.
Please brief your query.
Our other Value-Added Services:

To receive updates through e-mail on Products, New Technologies & Equipment, please select the Product Category(s) you are interested in and click 'Submit'. This will help you save time plus you will get the best price quotations from many manufacturers, which you can then evaluate and negotiate.

Invalid Input
Invalid Input
Invalid Input
The demand for structural strengthening of ageing structures is growing rapidly in buildings, industrial structures, infrastructure projects like bridges, dams, etc. Structural Strengthening also

Read more ...

Durability and strength are two most important criteria and requirements for the long-term performance of concrete structures against weathering action, chemical attack and abrasion. Any deficiency

Read more ...

Cement is a key binder component of concrete production in the building industry. It is a complex hydraulic binder, made up of four main clinker components; alite (Ca3SiO5), belite (Ca2SiO4)

Read more ...

FAIRMATE manufactures a complete range of construction chemicals and provides cost-effective solutions and world-class services to the Speciality Construction Chemicals Industry in alliance with leading

Read more ...

Corrosion of concrete is a major issue and many concrete structures on adverse environment have experienced unacceptable losses in terms of serviceability, ultimately requiring replacement

Read more ...

Cement is the most used industrial commodity required for development, but it is also responsible for high GHG emissions; so there is a need to create a balance between the nation’s growth and environment sustainability

Read more ...

Cement concrete is the most consumed materials on the earth next only to water. The ingredients used in preparing concrete are not sustainable. The ingredients are responsible for causing global warming. The most

Read more ...

India’s ready-mix concrete (RMC) market is projected to witness a 7-9% CAGR in the next five years. This growth is predominantly driven by the increased investments in the development of infrastructure throughout

Read more ...

Concrete, being a physical mixture of cement, aggregate (sand and crushed rocks), and water, is the key construction material across the world. There is now a huge demand for infrastructure which has increased concrete

Read more ...

There is a need for technologically advanced concrete admixtures for the ready-mix industry that meet industry codes and meet or exceed the demands of challenging construction applications and adverse placement conditions

Read more ...

High Performance Concrete (HPC) is seeing major applications in the field of civil engineering constructions such as long-span bridges, tunnels, high-rise buildings, huge complexes, highway pavements, and more, since

Read more ...

Concrete being the second largest consumed material after water needs attention towards sustainable construction with an increase in infrastructure. The world is moving towards innovative techniques and methodologies

Read more ...

Co-processing of waste in the cement industry is an advanced and innovative recovery process whereby energy is recovered, and the non-combustible part of the waste is reused as raw material.

Read more ...

Traditional masonry units are not sustainable and eco friendly due to consumption of fuel or cement. It is essential to find sustainable alternatives. This paper reports about preparation of geopolymer bricks, masonry

Read more ...

Geo-polymer mortar (GPM) is proven for its strength, durability and sustainability [2 & 3]; strength of GPM is a function of alkaline to binder ratio, and has an adverse effect on consistence properties of mortar

Read more ...

Comparison of Reinforced and Pre-Stressed Concrete Building Frames This article discusses pre-stressing of concrete to get lighter and slender beam sections for six different four storied concrete building frames of different spans/lengths by the application of post-tensioning

Read more ...

Ready mix concrete (RMC) is the first choice for projects requiring concrete. The term ‘ready mix’ is used to describe a process where concrete is pre-made at a plant and delivered in batches to job sites. It is a convenient

Read more ...

When we talk of Primers that are applied before the paint work, what comes to mind are the Acrylic Primers. However, since the last few years, White Cement-based Primers are gaining popularity amongst the construction

Read more ...

Chemistry is truly relevant for concrete because chemistry controls the life/durability of concrete. It explains why cement hardens and the interaction between cement and its environment. Dr. S.B.Hegde at Udaipur Cement Works

Read more ...

Concrete is considered the world’s most versatile, durable and reliable construction material, next only to water. It is the most consumed material requiring large quantity of cement, fine aggregates, course aggregates

Read more ...

Sign-up for Free Subscription
'India Construction Week'
Weekly e-Newsletter on Construction Industry
Get the latest news, product launches, projects announced / awarded, government policies, investments, and expert views.