Conventional Vis–a–Vis Mineral Admixed Concrete for Cement Concrete Pavements Construction

Conventional Vis–a–Vis Mineral Admixed Concrete

Dr Rakesh Kumar, Scientist and Dr Renu Mathur, Scientist & HoD, Rigid Pavements Division, Central Road Research Institute (CRRI) New Delhi.

This article presents a comparison between conventional concrete and mineral admixed concrete to be used in the construction of cement concrete pavements. Mineral admixtures such as flyash, rice-husk ash and silica fume were used in this study. These admixtures were selected to arrive at an economical way for enhancing flexural strength of concrete without significantly affecting compressive strength. Ten concrete mixes were used in this investigation. The performance of concrete mixes was evaluated at fresh state as well as hardened state. Hardened state concrete properties such as compressive strength and flexural strength were evaluated. The study suggests that mineral admixed concrete shows higher flexural strength in comparison with conventional concrete. It also reveals that flexural strength can be drastically enhanced by using 5 to 10 percent of flyash, rice husk ash and silica fume as partial replacement of cement. However, from economical point of view replacement of 10 per– cent cement by mass with flyash is a better option for enhancing flexural strength of control concrete to be used in the construction of cement concrete pavements.

Introduction

The design of concrete pavements (also known as rigid pavements) is based on the flexural tensile strength of concrete as these pavements fail due to bending stresses. The flexural strength (sometimes called the modulus of rupture) of concrete is determined by use of beam specimens under either three-point or center-point loading following any standard test procedure.

Physical & mechanical properties of cement

The third-point loading is preferred because in the middle third of the span, the specimen is subjected to pure moment which is not possible in the center-point loading device. Hence, the center-point loading test gives results about 15 percent higher in comparison to three-point loading test. Depending on axle load, present traffic, design life, fatigue consumption etc., the average 28-day flexural strength of at least 3.5 MPa is commonly encountered in practice. This range of flexural strength can be achieved by using concrete of M 35 and above grade depending on its constituent ingredients. In recent past, a lot of research was carried out throughout globe for improving the performance of concrete in terms of its rheology, strength and durability qualities1,2. Consequently, several new constituents such as mineral and chemical admixture of concrete were used to meet the specific need of strength and durability of concrete. The use of mineral admixture in combination with chemical admixture has allowed the concrete technologists to tailor the concrete for many specific requirements. Among the several types of mineral admixture available, the most common are industrial by-products, such as silica fume, fly– ash, blast furnace slag, limestone powder and rice-husk ash etc. Use of these mineral admixtures improve the particle packing density, rheological properties in fresh state and mechanical properties including flexural strength and durability of cementitious system3-9. Amongst the mineral admixtures, silica fume seems to be the most useful for the development of very high strength concretes and/or high performance concrete. Various advantages of using silica fume, flyash and rice husk ash in concrete need not to be overemphasized. Therefore, in this study the relative performance with respect to compressive and flexural strength development of conventional vis-à-vis mineral admixed concretes containing ASTM Class F flyash, Silica fume, and rice-husk ash, for the construction of cement concrete pavements has been reported.

Physical & mechanical properties of Flyash

Experimental Study Materials

Properties of silica fume
Ordinary Portland cement with properties as given in Table 1 was used throughout this experimental investigation. The cement met the requirements of the Indian Standard specification IS: 8112-198910.

The flyash (FA) used in this study was obtained from a thermal power plant near Delhi and was evaluated as per ASTM C 618 requirements.11 Table2 shows some of the important physical and chemical properties of the flyash.
Properties of rice husk ash

Grading of sand
This flyash met the ASTM C 618 requirements. It is therefore, concluded that the flyash may perform satisfactorily in cement concrete.

Silica fume (SF) used in the experimental work had specific gravity of 2.18 and Blaine specific surface was around 450 m2/kg. Some important properties of silica fume used are presented in Table 3.

The rice husk ash (RHA) used was obtained from a commercial plant located at Tharsguda, Orissa, India. Its specific gravity and bulk density were 2.06 and 718 kg/m3respectively. The particles of rice husk ash were finer than 45mm. The various properties of rice husk ash are given in Table 4.

Throughout the study, the same land-quarried local sand was used. The specific gravity of the sand was 2.62 and its water absorption was 0.73%. The bulk density of the fine aggregate was 1615 kg/m3. The fineness modulus of the sand was 2.4. The sand was evaluated for the water absorption, specific gravityand grading as per the procedure given in IS: 383-197012. The data on grading of sand is reported in Table5. 20 mm (maximum nominal size) graded crushed stone was used as the coarse aggregate for this study. The specific gravity of he coarse aggregate was 2.62. Its water absorption was 0.27%.
Grading data of coarse aggregates
The bulk density of the coarse aggregate was 1610 kg/m3. The sieve analysis data on the coarse aggregate both for d" 20 mm and d" 12.5 mm are given in Table 6.

A new generation carboxylic ether polymer based super plasticizer was used as a high-range water reducing agent for this study.

Mix Proportions

Ten concrete mixes were used for this study whose mix proportions are summarized in Table 7. This includes one controlled conventional concrete i.e. a mix without mineral admixture and nine minerals admixed concrete mixes. The mineral admixtures used were Class F flyash, silica fume and rice husk ash. Three concrete mixes using each of the mineral admixtures were manufactured. Admixed concrete mixes were made with 5%, 8%, and 10% replacement of cement in conventional concrete with these mineral admixtures.
Properties of rice husk ash
The replacement level was limited to 10% with a notion to achieve 28-day compressive strength similar to conventional concrete and flexural strength at least about 4.0 MPa. The water-to-cementitious material ratio was kept around 0.42 and dosages of superplasticizer were varied in range of 0.2% to 0.4% of binder's mass to achieve a slump value of 75±5 mm. It is worth to mention hat the slump specifications are different for the cement concrete road construction for fixed form paving and slipform paving. Hence, the range of slump value is so selected to fit the requirements of both forms of the paving. The mixing procedure adopted was as described below. All the ingredients except superplasticizer were mixed in dry state for few seconds in a tilted drum type concrete mixer, then ¾ of total required water was added and the mix was further mixed for a couple of minutes. The superplasticer was mixed in remaining 1/4th water and added to the mix in the final stage of mixing. The mixture was mixed for another two to three minutes before evaluating its properties at fresh state.

Sample Preparation

For compression testing, 150 × 150 × 150-mm3 cubes and for flexural tensile strength prism specimens with dimensions 100 × 100 × 500-mm3 were prepared from all concrete mixes. All the specimens were demoulded after 24 hours of casting and curing in the steel mould. Thereafter, the demoulded specimens were marked for identifications and kept submerged in a curing tank till the age of testing.

Mix proportions of concrete

Fresh properties of concrete mixes

Flexural strength of concrete mixes

Results and Discussion Properties of Fresh Concrete

The results obtained on the fresh state properties i.e. slump, concrete temperature and concrete unit weight are presented in Table 8. The targeted slump was 75 ± 5 mm for all the concrete mixes. Additions of silica fume as well as rice husk ash slightly decreased the slump value in comparison of control concrete. Therefore, the same was brought within the range required by increasing the amount of more water reducing agent (Table 7). This indicates that addition of silica fume and rice husk ash decreases the slump of the concrete. However, in the case of FA concrete the slump value increased marginally. Based, on the results given on the slump values in Table 8 and the amount of super plasticizer required to maintain those value Table 7, it is obvious that replacement of cement by SF and RHA reduces the slump of the fresh concrete which is mainly due to increased fineness of the SF and RHA particles in comparison of cement particles.
Three-point loading
The data on concrete temperature presented in Table 8 indicates that the replacement of cement by RH & silica fume is similar. In general, an insignificant effect on concrete temperature can be noticed. A close look, of the Table 8 indicates that the mineral admixed concrete shows higher unit weight than the controlled one, which is due to micro filling effect of the mineral admixture. However, it can be noticed that the increase in replacement levels have insignificant effect on unit weight of concrete containing mineral admixture, which may be due to the fact of close range of replacement, levels.

Mechanical Properties

Conventional Vis–a–Vis Mineral Admixed Concrete
The most important mechanical properties of concrete for the use in pavement construction is flexural strength. In addition to it, the compressive strength of concretes was determined for their comparison. The results have been discussed in the following sections.

Compressive Strength

The compressive strength of concrete mixes was determined as per the standard procedure described IS: 51613 at 7 and 28 days. Average result obtained on triplicate specimens was used for the reporting. Figures 2-4 illustrate the development of compressive strength of concrete mixes containing 5%, 8% and 10% of mineral admixtures i.e. silica fume (SF), rice husk ash (RHA) and Class F flyash in comparison of controlled one, respectively. It is obvious from the Figure 2 that the concrete containing silica fume, out performs other concrete mixes including control one in term of compressive strength development. Similar trends for strength development can be observed in the cases of replacement levels of cement with mineral admixtures under nvestigation i.e. 8% and 10% (Figures 3-4). It can further be seen that concrete containing fly– ash (FA) develops least compressive strength. However, in the replacement levels used in the study, it shows strength nearly at par with control concrete. The insignificant reduction in strength of concrete containing flyash in comparison with control one may be due to the lower level of replacement of cement with flyash.

Strength development of concrete mixes
Strength development of concrete mixes
Figure 2: Strength development of concrete mixes containing 5% of mineral admixture
Figure 3: Strength development of concrete mixes containing 8% of mineral admixture

Further, the effect of levels of replacement of cement with the mineral admixture on strength development is shown in Figures 5-7. Figure 5, 6, and 7 show the development of strength of concrete containing silica fume, rice husk ash and flyash, respectively along with control concrete. From Figure 5, it can be observed that the increase in the level of replacement of cement by silica fume increases the compressive strength of concrete; however, the increase in replacement level from 8% to 10% is not much significant. Therefore, optimum level of silica fume seems to be 8% in concrete. In the case of concrete containing rice husk ash (Figure 6) the replacement level has not much significant effect on the strength gain. But, in the case of flyash concrete (Figure 7) no significant reduction in strength in comparison with control concrete can be seen with increase of replacement levels from 5% to 10%.

Strength development of concrete mixes
Strength development of concrete mixes
Figure 4: Strength development of concrete mixes containing 10% of mineral admixture
Figure 5: Effect of replacement levels of SF on strength of concrete mixes


Strength development of concrete mixes
Strength development of concrete mixes
Figure 6: Effect of replacement levels of RHA on strength of concrete mixes
Figure 7: Effect of replacement levels of FA on strength of concrete mixes

Flexural Strength

The determination of flexural tensile strength or modulus of rupture is essential to estimate the stress at which the concrete member may crack. Its knowledge is useful in the design of pavement slabs and airfield runway as flexural tension is critical in these cases. For this, specimens of standard dimension of 100 mm × 100 mm × 500 mm were used. The specimen was placed in the Universal testing machine such that the load was applied to the upper most surface as cast in the mould. The test was conducted at the age of 28 days as per the standard procedure described in IS: 51613. The average result obtained on three specimens was taken as the representative flexural strength of the concrete. Table 9 presents the flexural strength of concrete. It is obvious from the Table 9 that concrete mix containing SF outperform all other concretes including controlled concrete in flexural strengths development at all the levels of replacement. Concrete mix containing RHA performs next to concrete mix containing SF. Concrete mix containing FA also shows improvement over flexural strength in comparison of control concrete mix. The increase in flexural strength of concrete containing admixtures is mainly due to the densification of transition zone of concrete and overall improvement in the homogeneity of concrete in comparison with controlled concrete. Therefore, the easiest economical way for enhancing flexural strength of conventional concrete up to 20 percent of 28-day value is incorporation of good quality of flyash in it.

Conclusion

Conventional Vis–a–Vis Mineral Admixed Concrete
The following important conclusions can be drawn from this experimental study:
  • Replacement of cement by SF and RHA reduces the slump of the fresh concrete in comparison of control concrete.
  • The increase of replacement levels of silica fume from 8% to 10% has not much significant effect on the development of compressive strength.
  • The replacement levels of rice husk ash have no significant effect on strength development and perform at par with control concrete.
  • The replacement levels of flyash have no significant effect on strength development and it performs nearly at par with control concrete.
  • Concrete mix containing mineral admixture such as flyash, silica fume and rice husk ash develops higher flexural strength than the conventional concrete without compromising compressive strength.
  • The most economicalconcrete mix with improved flexural strength for the construction of rigid pavements be produced by using 370 kg/m3 of cement and 40 kg/m3of flyash.

Acknowledgments

The kind permission of the Director, Central Road Research Institute, Mathura Road, New Delhi – India to publish this research work is highly acknowledged.

References

  • Nehdi M, Mindess S & Aitcin PC, Rheology of high-performance concrete: effect of ultrafine particles, Cement and Concrete Research, 28 (1988) 687.
  • Feng N, Shi Y & Hao T, Influence of ultrafine powder on the fluidity and strength of cement paste, Advances in Cement Research, 12 (2002) 89.
  • Mehta PK, Advancement in concrete technology, ACI Concrete International, 21 (1999) 69.
  • Aitcin PC & Neville A, High performance concrete demystified, ACI Concrete International, 15 (1993) 21.
  • Aitcin PC, Influence of condensed silica fume on the properties of fresh and hardned concrete; Condensed Silica Fume, Edited by PC Aitcin (Les Presses Del University de Sherbrooke, Quesec), 1983, 25.
  • Buil M, Paillere AM & Roussell B, High strength mortars containing condensed silica fume, Cement and Concrete Research, 14 (1984) 693.
  • Mehta PK, Condensed silica fume, Concrete Technology & Design, Vol.3, Cement Replacement Materials (Ed. R. N. Swamy) Surrey University press, 2000.
  • Obla KH, Hill R, Thomas MDA & Hooton RD, Properties of concrete containing ultrafine flyash, Proceedings of Fifth CANMET/ACI International Conference on Durability of Concrete, supplementary volume, Chairperson: Mohan Malhotra, Barcelona, Spain, Farmington Hill, MI 2001, 141.
  • Mehta PK & Pirtz D, Use of rice husk ash to reduce temperature in high-strength mass concrete, Journal of American Concrete Institute.75 (1978) 60.
  • Indian Standard Method of Physical Tests for Hydraulic Cement, IS:4031, 1988, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi.
  • Annual Book of ASTM Standards, Concrete and Aggregates, Vol. 04.02, ASTM, Philadelphia, PA, 1999.
  • Indian standard specifications for coarse and fine aggregates from natural sources for concrete, IS: 383-1970, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi.
  • Indian standard code of methods of tests for strength of concrete, IS:516-1959, Bureau of Indian Standards, New Delhi.
Click Here
To Know More or to Contact the Manufacturer
Please let us know your name.
Invalid Input
Please let us know your Designation.
Please let us know your Contact Number.
Please let us know your email address.
Please brief your query.
Our other Value-Added Services:

To receive updates through e-mail on Products, New Technologies & Equipment, please select the Product Category(s) you are interested in and click 'Submit'. This will help you save time plus you will get the best price quotations from many manufacturers, which you can then evaluate and negotiate.

Invalid Input
Invalid Input
Invalid Input
Innovation and entrepreneurship are essential ingredients in building a successful commercial venture. The ways in which these two concepts fuel enterprise are something entrepreneur's never stop exploring. There is no doubt that innovation were

Read more ...

Alite and belite are the predominant phases of Portland cement formulation. Alite is impure tricalcium silicate (C3S) and belite is impure dicalcium silicate (C2S). The impurities are an integral part as cement is manufactured

Read more ...

Concrete is a versatile construction material and day by day its consumption is increasing globally. It is second only to water in the global consumption. No civil engineering structure is feasible without using concrete

Read more ...

The use of Graphene with concrete has been talked about and researched ever since Graphene was invented in 2010 which grabbed its inventors a Nobel prize. Nanospan is the first company in the world to break technological and commercial

Read more ...

Fosroc is the foundation of the JMH Group. It employs over 1700 employees in 17 operating companies based in Europe, the Gulf & Middle East, India, South Asia, and China. Through FGT, its trading company, it services another 50 countries

Read more ...

Established in 1983 by French expatriate entrepreneurs, the Dextra Group has a long history of growth and development, driven by strong entrepreneurship and innovation. It has diversified into three main activities: manufacturing, trading and freight forwarding

Read more ...

Jyotirmoy Mishra, Ph.D. Scholar, Department of Civil Engineering, Veer Surendra Sai University of Technology, Burla, Odisha, presents his research on the feasibility and compressive strength performance of geopolymer concrete

Read more ...

As every one ton of Cement (OPC) produced, emits 0.96 tons of CO2, there is an urgent need to promote blending materials (ex. GGBS &PSC) and screened slag, to achieve lower CO2 emissions, reduce greenhouse gas effect, reduce exploitation

Read more ...

In most of the developing countries, demand for steel for use as a reinforcing material is increasing day by day. However, when steel is in short supply, one can consider bamboo as an alternative material for reinforcement

Read more ...

There is high demand for white cement in countries with hot climates, as more heat is reflected from white concrete surfaces as compared to standard grey concrete. As a value-added product, white cement is becoming

Read more ...

Garry Martin, Director - Major Projects, Low & Bonar Construction Fibres, presents a new examination of the benefits of micro fibres in both the plastic and hardened state of concrete and their contribution to increased sustainability.

Read more ...

An integrated material and structural design strategy of strength through durability is the need of the hour since structures are designed for ductility and structural integrity. Dr. S. B. Hegde, President – Manufacturing

Read more ...

The demand for structural strengthening of ageing structures is growing rapidly in buildings, industrial structures, infrastructure projects like bridges, dams, etc. Structural Strengthening also

Read more ...

Durability and strength are two most important criteria and requirements for the long-term performance of concrete structures against weathering action, chemical attack and abrasion. Any deficiency

Read more ...

Cement is a key binder component of concrete production in the building industry. It is a complex hydraulic binder, made up of four main clinker components; alite (Ca3SiO5), belite (Ca2SiO4)

Read more ...

FAIRMATE manufactures a complete range of construction chemicals and provides cost-effective solutions and world-class services to the Speciality Construction Chemicals Industry in alliance with leading

Read more ...

Corrosion of concrete is a major issue and many concrete structures on adverse environment have experienced unacceptable losses in terms of serviceability, ultimately requiring replacement

Read more ...

Cement is the most used industrial commodity required for development, but it is also responsible for high GHG emissions; so there is a need to create a balance between the nation’s growth and environment sustainability

Read more ...

Cement concrete is the most consumed materials on the earth next only to water. The ingredients used in preparing concrete are not sustainable. The ingredients are responsible for causing global warming. The most

Read more ...

India’s ready-mix concrete (RMC) market is projected to witness a 7-9% CAGR in the next five years. This growth is predominantly driven by the increased investments in the development of infrastructure throughout

Read more ...

×
Sign-up for Free Subscription
'India Construction Week'
Weekly e-Newsletter on Construction Industry
Get the latest news, product launches, projects announced / awarded, government policies, investments, and expert views.