Carbonation A Durability Threat for Concrete

Jayobroto Burman Roy, General Manager, ATS Infrastructure Ltd. Noida

Introduction

The term “Carbonation” of concrete means the chemical reaction between carbon dioxide in the air and hydration products of the cement. The process includes:
  1. Diffusion of CO2 in the gaseous phase into the concrete pores,
  2. Its dissolution in the aqueous film of these pores,
  3. The dissolution of solid Ca(OH)2in the water of the pores,
  4. The diffusion of dissolved Ca(OH)2in pore water and its reaction with the dissolved CO2,
Final result of several steps through which the calcium carbonate is formed may simply be described by the following reaction which is assumed to be irreversible.

Ca2+(aq) + 2(OH¯)(aq) + CO2(aq) CaCO3(s) + H2O (Eq.1.1)

Effect of Carbonation

When Ca(OH)2is removed from the paste, hydrated CSH, C3S and C2S will also carbonate.

3CaO·SiO2·3H2O+3CO2 3CaCO3+2SiO2+3H2O (Eq. 1.2)

Factors affecting Concrete Carbonation

The rate of carbonation depends on porosity (for CO2to Diffuse) & moisture content of the concrete (for dissolution of solid Ca(OH)2). The diffusivity of CO2 depends upon the pore system of hardened concrete and the exposure condition. The pore system of concrete depends upon the type and the content of binder, water/binder ratio, and the degree of hydration. Thus, the main factors affecting concrete carbonation are:
  1. Pore system of Hardened Concrete which in turn depends upon w/c ratio, type of binder, and degree of hydration,
  2. Relative humidity (for dissolution of Ca(OH)2),
  3. The concentration of CO2.

    Optimal conditions for carbonation occur at a RH of 50% (range 40–90%).
    • If RH <40%, CO2 cannot dissolve,
    • If RH >90%, diffusion of carbon dioxide will be inhibited by the water that has filled the pores and hence CO2 cannot enter the concrete.
    • The most dangerous range of relative humidity for carbonation is 40% to 80%, since the carbonation reaction calls for the presence of water, while under higher atmospheric humidity the diffusion of carbon dioxide will be inhibited by the water that has filled the pores.

Carbonation and Concrete Durability

Understanding Corrosion

Corrosion is an electrochemical process involving the flow of charges (electrons and ions). At active sites on the bar, called anodes, iron atoms lose electrons and move into the surrounding concrete as ferrous ions. This process is called a half-cell oxidation reaction, or the anodic reaction, and is represented as: (Figure 1.2).

Schematic Diagram of Corrosion
2Fe’ -> 2Fe2++ 4e- (Eq. 1.3)

2H2O + O2 + 4e-’ -> 4OH- (Eq. 1.4)

2Fe2++ 4OH-’ -> 2Fe(OH)2 (Eq. 3.5)

This initial precipitated hydroxide tends to react further with oxygen to form higher oxides. The increases in volume as the reaction products react further with dissolved oxygen leads to internal stress within the concrete that may be sufficient to cause cracking and swelling of the concrete cover.

Consequence of Carbonation

  • Carbonation results in a decrease of the porosity making the carbonated paste stronger. Carbonation is therefore an advantage in non-reinforced concrete.
  • However, main consequence of carbonation is the drop in the pH of the pore solution in the concrete from the standard values between 12.5 and 13.5, to a value below 9 in the fully carbonated zones, so that the passive layer that usually covers and protects the reinforcing steel from corrosion becomes unstable.
Carbonation A Durability Threat for Concrete

Once this layer is destroyed rusting of iron bars and subsequent expansion of the concrete takes place and durability of concrete decreases. Hence Carbonation is harmful for reinforced concrete.

Methods to Measure Carbonation

Extent of Carbonation is measured in two ways:
  • First way is to measure the concentration of CO2 absorbed by the concrete specimen.
  • Second way is to carbonate the specimen in (a) natural or (b) laboratory environment conditions and then break it and spray a pH indicator to know the extent of Carbonation.
Both methods are described in detail on next page.

IR Spectrum Analysis

Schematic Diagram of pH
The carbonation set-up consists of a close loop in which a mixture of air and carbon-dioxide could be introduced at a certain RH. Due to the carbonation reaction, an amount of CO2 molecules will be immobilized reducing the concentration of carbon dioxide in the circulating gas mixture. The CO2 concentration in the gas is measured using an IR absorption device. A pump is used to circulate the gas while also temperature and RH are measured.

Using pH Indicators

Carbonation Depth vs. Compressive strength
In this method, first concrete specimen is kept in an open environment for a number of years or in Carbonation Chamber for a number of months. Generally, conditions of 70% CO2, 50% Relative Humidity, and 20-22ºC is maintained in a carbonation chamber, fig. 1.4(a). Then sample is broken and is sprayed with a pH indicator. Popularly a standard solution of 1% phenolphthalein in 70% ethyl alcohol is used. In the noncarbonated region with pH values above 9.2, the phenolphthalein indicator turns purple-red; and in the carbonated portion with pH less than 9.2, the solution remained colorless. Figure 1.4(a), (b).

Literature Review

Figure 1.6 shows a compilation of carbonation depth by various researchers. It was found that most of the researches were confined to a particular zone of compressive strength. Very less data is found concrete above 60 MPa concrete strength.

Figure 1.5 shows the collection of various carbonation depth verses strength. It is noted that most of the research is done on concrete with strength below 60 MPa. The value and variation of data after this is negligible. Figure 1.6 shows the results of rapid carbonation. It shows slightly higher depth but follows similar trend. Figure 1.7 shows a critical analysis of Figure 1.5. Table 1.1 shows a few sets of distinct data derived from Figure. 1.5

Classification of the Data

Following conclusions can be arrived:
  1. Carbonation Depth shows a good variation and possibly a good method to judge durability upto 60 MPa.
  2. After 60 Mpa Compressive Strength, the values of normal carbonation depth are insignificant and it is difficult to access the durability of concrete.
  3. Based on the table no 1.1, following bound distribution can be made:
    Carbonation Depth vs. Compressive strength
    1. Normal concrete is distributed over whole bound,
    2. Concrete with one pozollonic material is lying in middle and lower bound,
    3. Concrete with mixed pozollonic materials is lying in lowerbound.
  4. The plot shows that concretes with mixed pozollonic materials (till 30%) are more reliable w.r.t. carbonation depth as compared to normal concrete or concretes with only one pozollonic material.
Results of Carbonation Depths

Numerical Prediction Method

Jiang et. al. presented a good numerical modeling as presented below for normal and high volume flyash:

The model for predicting HVFA concrete carbonation is in good agreement with the test results obtained in an accelerated carbonation apparatus. It can be used to predict the evolution of carbonation depth with time. However, more tests are required to confirm these preliminary observations. From this study, it can also be seen that at a given binder content, the carbonation depth of HVFA concrete is greater than OPC concrete. The increase of curing period can improve the carbonation behavior of HVFA concrete. The carbonation depth of HVFA concrete of appropriate mix proportion can approach that of OPC concrete, and meet the requirements of structural concrete.

Experiments

Carbonation Depth Results Analysis of Carbonation Results

Carbonation Depth

Carbonation Depth vs. Compressive strength
Relationshp between carbonated depth vs. Strength are plotted here.

The values of carbonation depth have been plotted against design strength in Figure 1.13. It has been divided into 6 parts. Each part is the line representing for a fixed replacement level of fly ash and silica fume. It is a comprehensive graph and it can be seen very clearly that as strength increases the carbonation depth values are decreasing.

If we assume that carbonation depth are directly related to durability of concrete, i.e. higher the carbonation depth lower will be durability, following conclusion can be given.
  1. The effect of 15% replacement by Fly Ash is not clear. Carbonation depth has increased for M25, M30, and M40 but decreased for M20 and M35. In Figure 4.8 if we delete point ‘X’ then we may conclude that 15% Flyash replacement increases carbonation depth and will therefore decreases durability. In this experiment samples were water-cured for 28 days only. What would have happened if samples were water-cured for 56 days? Will it result in better durability of concrete with 15% replacement by Flyash?
  2. 6% replacement by Silica Fume showed significant decrease in Carbonation Depth, hence is more durable.
  3. 15% Flyash and 6% silica Fume replacement shows further fall in carbonation depth values, hence it is even more durable.
  4. Due to less available data not much can be said about concrete with 30%FA and 6%SF replacement or 40%FA and 6% FA replacements, but it is clear that concrete made by double replacement of cement generally shows better durability property as compared to single replacement or no replacement.
  5. Double replacement of 40% fly– ash and 6% silica fume shows least carbonation. However, exact replacement levels which would give maximum durability without going for a higher strength concrete is cannot be predicted.
  6. The argument that “pozzolana decreases conc. of Ca(OH)2 and CO2 has to react with less Ca(OH)2 and hence carbonated front should move faster inside concrete” seems void. Except for 15% Flyash replacement, all other pozzolana/flyash concretes have shown lower carbonation.
  7. Variation of the graph is very-very similar to as predicted after Literature Review (see Figure1.5-8)

Conclusion

Comparision of Carbonation
In this discussion, the mechanism of carbonation along with the adapted experimental methods are presented. Phenolphthalein method of detecting depth of carbonation is found to be the most popular method. A lot of experimental and imperical model to estimate carbonation (Jiang et al.) have been reported in literature.

Carbonation data from various literature have been plotted for comparative study and excellent co-relation where noticed. Indeed Jiang et al. model must have simulated all these results. It was noticed that a lot of data exists under 60 MPa concrete. Very less data exist for concrete above 60 MPa. This is because above 60 MPa, the depth of carbonatin is insignificant.
Click Here
To Know More or to Contact the Manufacturer
Please let us know your name.
Invalid Input
Please let us know your Designation.
Please let us know your Contact Number.
Please let us know your email address.
Please brief your query.
Our other Value-Added Services:

To receive updates through e-mail on Products, New Technologies & Equipment, please select the Product Category(s) you are interested in and click 'Submit'. This will help you save time plus you will get the best price quotations from many manufacturers, which you can then evaluate and negotiate.

Invalid Input
Invalid Input
Invalid Input
Innovation and entrepreneurship are essential ingredients in building a successful commercial venture. The ways in which these two concepts fuel enterprise are something entrepreneur's never stop exploring. There is no doubt that innovation were

Read more ...

Alite and belite are the predominant phases of Portland cement formulation. Alite is impure tricalcium silicate (C3S) and belite is impure dicalcium silicate (C2S). The impurities are an integral part as cement is manufactured

Read more ...

Concrete is a versatile construction material and day by day its consumption is increasing globally. It is second only to water in the global consumption. No civil engineering structure is feasible without using concrete

Read more ...

The use of Graphene with concrete has been talked about and researched ever since Graphene was invented in 2010 which grabbed its inventors a Nobel prize. Nanospan is the first company in the world to break technological and commercial

Read more ...

Fosroc is the foundation of the JMH Group. It employs over 1700 employees in 17 operating companies based in Europe, the Gulf & Middle East, India, South Asia, and China. Through FGT, its trading company, it services another 50 countries

Read more ...

Established in 1983 by French expatriate entrepreneurs, the Dextra Group has a long history of growth and development, driven by strong entrepreneurship and innovation. It has diversified into three main activities: manufacturing, trading and freight forwarding

Read more ...

Jyotirmoy Mishra, Ph.D. Scholar, Department of Civil Engineering, Veer Surendra Sai University of Technology, Burla, Odisha, presents his research on the feasibility and compressive strength performance of geopolymer concrete

Read more ...

As every one ton of Cement (OPC) produced, emits 0.96 tons of CO2, there is an urgent need to promote blending materials (ex. GGBS &PSC) and screened slag, to achieve lower CO2 emissions, reduce greenhouse gas effect, reduce exploitation

Read more ...

In most of the developing countries, demand for steel for use as a reinforcing material is increasing day by day. However, when steel is in short supply, one can consider bamboo as an alternative material for reinforcement

Read more ...

There is high demand for white cement in countries with hot climates, as more heat is reflected from white concrete surfaces as compared to standard grey concrete. As a value-added product, white cement is becoming

Read more ...

Garry Martin, Director - Major Projects, Low & Bonar Construction Fibres, presents a new examination of the benefits of micro fibres in both the plastic and hardened state of concrete and their contribution to increased sustainability.

Read more ...

An integrated material and structural design strategy of strength through durability is the need of the hour since structures are designed for ductility and structural integrity. Dr. S. B. Hegde, President – Manufacturing

Read more ...

The demand for structural strengthening of ageing structures is growing rapidly in buildings, industrial structures, infrastructure projects like bridges, dams, etc. Structural Strengthening also

Read more ...

Durability and strength are two most important criteria and requirements for the long-term performance of concrete structures against weathering action, chemical attack and abrasion. Any deficiency

Read more ...

Cement is a key binder component of concrete production in the building industry. It is a complex hydraulic binder, made up of four main clinker components; alite (Ca3SiO5), belite (Ca2SiO4)

Read more ...

FAIRMATE manufactures a complete range of construction chemicals and provides cost-effective solutions and world-class services to the Speciality Construction Chemicals Industry in alliance with leading

Read more ...

Corrosion of concrete is a major issue and many concrete structures on adverse environment have experienced unacceptable losses in terms of serviceability, ultimately requiring replacement

Read more ...

Cement is the most used industrial commodity required for development, but it is also responsible for high GHG emissions; so there is a need to create a balance between the nation’s growth and environment sustainability

Read more ...

Cement concrete is the most consumed materials on the earth next only to water. The ingredients used in preparing concrete are not sustainable. The ingredients are responsible for causing global warming. The most

Read more ...

India’s ready-mix concrete (RMC) market is projected to witness a 7-9% CAGR in the next five years. This growth is predominantly driven by the increased investments in the development of infrastructure throughout

Read more ...

×
Sign-up for Free Subscription
'India Construction Week'
Weekly e-Newsletter on Construction Industry
Get the latest news, product launches, projects announced / awarded, government policies, investments, and expert views.