Analysis of Trough Shaped Ferrocement Roofing Elements Using ANSYS

Ferrocement Roofing Elements Using Ansys

L.Andal, Assistant Professor, Civil Engg. Department, Velammal College of Engineering and Technology, Madurai, M.S.Palanichamy, Vice Chancellor, Tamil Nadu Open University, M.Sekar, Dean, College of Engineering Guindy, Chennai, V.Vanitha, Lecturer, Civil Engg. Department, Mepco Schlenk Engineering College, Sivakasi

Ferrocement is a composite material made up of cement matrix and reinforcement in the form of multiple layers of mesh. Ferrocement structures are flexible and strong, due to the fact that they are thin and the steel reinforcement is distributed widely throughout the mortar. Though the raw materials required for Ferrocement construction is easily available, it is not widely used in our country due to the non-availability of proper design guidelines/code books. This paper aims at the study on the behavior of Ferrocement beams using ANSYS, finite element software. Finite Element Models have been developed for the trough shaped ferrocement roofing unit. The results obtained using the finite element software is compared with the analytical results computed from the formulae available in the literature and also with the experimental results. Design charts are developed for ferrocement trough unit to serve as an aid for a prospective designer to arrive at a section to suit their requirements.

Introduction

Housing shortage is a well recognized problem in this world. As result of uncontrolled population growth, migration to urban centers and the decay of existing low cost housing units, the cumulative needs of housing of many countries are already beyond easy corrective measures. Development of new materials of construction, low cost housing and accelerated construction methods are some of the different measures that research workers and engineers have been attempting towards meeting this challenge. Studies on building costs show that roofs/floors account for as high as 20-25% of the total building cost and saving in these items will go a long way in reducing the overall cost of a building. Traditionally, either ferrocement or corrugated galvanized iron sheets or asbestos cement sheets are being used for low cost roofing. Ferrocement as a roofing component was conceived in this context. As a composite material made of wire mesh, cement and sand, ferrocement posses unique qualities of strength and serviceability. If a roof/floor system in ferrocement is evolved and adopted on a large scale, it will prove a fitting contribution to housing the millions of homeless in the country.

The following are the analytical and experimental works related to ferrocement. Andal et.al (studied the flexural strength of modified ferrocement with polymer mortar. 45 specimens were tested and the load deflection curves, first crack loads and ultimate loads were analysed to obtain the optimum percentage of polymer to be used in modified ferrocement. Expressions were derived for the plastic moment and First Cracking Moment. Ramesht, M.H.(2) compared various analytical procedures which have been developed to predict the ultimate moment of Ferrocement under flexure. Balaji Rao,(3)proposed two methods to predict the first crack and ultimate moments of Ferrocement elements and concluded that both the methods are found to give satisfactory agreement with test data. Mathews,et.al.(4) studied the analytical and experimental investigations of cracking load, ultimate load, deflection, crack spacing and crack width of hollow ferrocement roofing system. Ramachandra Murthy, D.S(6)studied the applications of Ferrocement as housing units, water tanks, grain silos, roofing components, irrigation channels, boats and marine structures. Damodar Maity, et.al (9)studied the deflection and stress behavior of nine different types of ferrocement roofing elements. From the parametric study, it was found that deflection is less in double T-type of element and more in case of trough shaped element. Principal stresses are less in the segmental shell element and more in case of inverted V–shaped element. On the basis of cost analysis it was found that the shell element is the most economical shape as a roofing element.

Moreover, the theoretical analysis of ferrocement trough shaped elements are very tedious and time consuming. So this paper deals with the analysis of ferrocement elements using ANSYS software.

Objective

The main objective of this work is to develop design charts for the Ferrocement trough units. Design aids are essential and will be of immense help to the majority of the users of ferrocement. Moreover, they will increase consideration of ferrocement as an alternative construction material in various applications. In view of this, design charts are developed using the results obtained from ANSYS for ferrocement trough shaped roof/floor system.

ANSYS (Version 8.0)

ANSYS is a general purpose Finite Element analysis software package. The software implements equations that governs the behavior of these elements and solves them all creating a comprehensive explanation of how the system acts as a whole. This type of analysis is used for solving problems which are too complex to analyze manually.

Details of Trough Element

Trough shaped section with lips as shown in Figure 1 is selected for the roofing element. The cross sectional details are given below.
Ferrocement Roofing Elements Using Ansys
  • Span =3.0m
  • Thickness of section, t =20mm
  • Depth of the section, H = 100mm
  • Angle of web with vertical = 59Ú
  • Angle of web with horizontal = 31Ú
  • Characteristic compressive
  • Strength of mortar = 40 N/mm2
  • Moment of inertia, Ig (mm4) = 5956199.0
  • Neutral axis depth Yb =47.5mm
  • Section modulus Z (mm3) = 125393.66

Analysis Using ANSYS

The following steps are involved in analyzing the trough element using the finite element software package ANSYS
  • Element selection
  • Defining material properties
  • Model creation
  • Meshing
  • Applying boundary conditions and loading
  • Analysis
  • Viewing results
The accuracy of the results depends upon the type of element used and the way in which the model is meshed. Among these steps the element selection and meshing are very important.

Elements Used

Ferrocement Roofing Elements Using Ansys
In modeling the trough unit the elements chosen were:
  • SOLID 65 for modeling the mortar layers and
  • SHELL 181 for modeling the chicken mesh and weld mesh layers.
The trough element modeled using ANSYS is shown in Figure 2

Calculation of Cracking Moment

  • Method I: (Ref 3)
    where,
    fr - modulus of rupture of cement mortar
  • Ig – Gross moment of Inertia
  • Yb – Neutral axis depth

  • Method II: (Ref 3)

    Ferrocement Roofing Elements Using Ansys

    where,
    frm - modulus of rupture ofmesh-mortar combination

    Ig – Gross moment of Inertia

    Yb – Neutral axis depth

  • Method III :( Ref 4)

    Ferrocement Roofing Elements Using Ansys

    where,
    fcr - modulus of rupture of cement mortar

    Ig – Gross moment of Inertia

    Yb – Neutral axis depth

  • Method IV :( Ref 1)

    Ferrocement Roofing Elements Using Ansys

    Mcr = a x fcu xZ

    where,

    α - Cracking Moment constant Characteristic compressive strength of mortar

    Z - Section modulus

    S = Percentage of reinforcement

    F = Percentage of flyash
Ferrocement Roofing Elements Using Ansys

Cracking Moment from ANSYS

The stress value from ANSYS is given below from which the Cracking Moment is calculated.

Stress at first visible crack = 14.740 N/mm2

Cracking Moment Mcr= 14.740 x (5956199.0 / 47.5)

= 1.857 KNm

Experimentally the Cracking Moment obtained at the first visible crack (Ref 8) was 1.075 KNm.

The comparison of Cracking Moment for 20 mm thick Ferrocement trough element by various methods with ANSYS results are given in Tables 1 to 4.

Ferrocement Roofing Elements Using Ansys

Development of Design Charts

Design charts are developed for ferrocement trough unit by varying the following parameters
  1. Thickness of the section,t: 20, 25, 30 &35 mm
  2. Characteristic compressive
    Strength of mortar, fcu : 35, 40, 45&50 N/mm2
  3. Mesh mortar parameter, x : 0.2 (4 layers of chicken mesh &1 layer of weld mesh), 0.25 (6 layers of chicken mesh &1 layer of weld mesh) & 0.30 (8 layers of chicken mesh &1 layer of weld mesh).
The calculation of mesh-mortar parameter "x" for the Ferrocement Trough Element with 4 Layers of Chicken Mesh and One Layer Weld Mesh is given below.

Ferrocement Roofing Elements Using Ansys

= 0.059 + 0.116
= 0.175
H" 0.200.

Design charts developed for ferrocement trough for various thicknesses of the specimen and the mortar strengths are given in Figures 3 to 8.

Ferrocement Roofing Elements Using Ansys
Ferrocement Roofing Elements Using Ansys
Ferrocement Roofing Elements Using Ansys

Conclusion

Based on the detailed analysis of Ferrocement trough units using ANSYS the following conclusions have been drawn:
  • The cracking moment by method 4 is found to be in good agreement with both the ANSYS and Experimental results.
  • The methods 1, 2, and 3 underestimated the cracking moment for the Ferrocement trough units.
  • From the results obtained from ANSYS design charts are developed for the ferrocement trough unit. The design charts developed in this paper will serve as an aid for the designer to arrive at a suitable section.

References

  • Andal, L. Palanichamy, M.s. Ponraj Shankar And Vaidyanathan, R.(2005) 'Behaviour of Ferrocement Flexural Member with Polymer Modified Mortar,' Proceedings of International Conference on Advances in Concrete Composite and Structures (ICACS-2005) Jan 6-8.
  • Ramesht, M.H. And Vickridge, I.g.(1996) 'Faoferrs- A Computer Program for the Analysis of Ferrocement in Flexure,' Journal of Ferrocement Vol.26, No.1, pp.21 -31.
  • Balaji Rao, K.(2002)'Estimation of Cracking and Ultimate moments and load-deflection behavior of Ferrocement Elements', National seminar of Ferrocement 18-20 Feb' 2002 @ Anna University, Chennai. pp.G1– G10.
  • Mathews, M.S. Sheela, S. Seetharaman, P.R. And Sudhakumar, J.(1991) 'Analytical and Experimental Investigations of Hollow Ferrocement Roofing Units'.Journal of ferrocement. , Vol.27; NO.1, pp.1 -14.
  • Perumal, P. And Vidhyanathan, R.(1987) 'Strength and Corrosion Resistance of Ferrocement slabs', Proceedings of National Seminar on Modern trends in building materials, Design & Construction, Institution of Engineers (India) Allahabad, Nov.13-15.
  • Dr. Ramachandra Murthy, D.S. (2002) 'Low cost Housing in Ferrocement Technology,' National seminar of Ferrocement 18-20 Feb' 2002 @ Anna University, Chennai, pp. j1 – j8.
  • Rao, P.K. (1992) 'Stress-strain Behavior of Ferrocement Elements under Compression,' Journal of Ferrocement Vol.22, No. 4, pp.343 – 352.
  • Sujatha, T. (2005) 'Flyash based Ferrocement trough shaped roofing/ flooring element for low cost housing,' M.E. Thesis.
  • Damodar Maity, Kalita, U.C. And Nazrul Imam (2002) 'An Investigation On the Shape of Ferrocement Roofing Elements,' Journal of Ferrocement Vol.32, No. 4, pp. 271-284.
  • Naaman, A.E.'Ferrocement and Laminated Cementitious Composites,' Techno Press 3000, USA, pp.1471, 143 &145.
  • ACI Committee Report No. 549 'State–of–the–Art Report on Ferrocement,' ACI-549 -97, American Concrete Institute, Detroit, Part 5, pp. 549.R-2.
  • ANSYS Help Manual (Version 8.0).

From the Editor

Structural Engineering Research centre at Roorkee/Ghaziabad carried out R&D work on ferrocement under the able guidance of its director Prof. G.S. Ramaswamy from 1968 onwards and a very large number of applications were developed and technology released for commercial use through NRDC. The Centre supported the activities of international ferrocement information centre A.I.T. Bangkok by deputing its experts for conducting Try Programme and preparation of do-it-yourselfManuals on tanks, Bins, Roofs, Boats, Bio Gas Plants etc. Large number of papers and manual were produced and the pre–patents were file. The technologies developed are in use by leading engineering department, pre–cast component Producers.
Finnish company Betolar expands to Indian concrete markets with a cement-free concrete solution
Betolar, a Finnish start-up, and innovator of geopolymer concrete solution Geoprime®, has expanded its operations to Europe and Asian markets including India, Vietnam and Indonesia. Betolar’s innovation Geoprime® is the next-generation, low carbon

Read more ...

Why Fly Ash Bricks Are Better Than Clay/Red Bricks
It is estimated that in India each million clay bricks consume about 200 tons of coal and emit around 270 tons of CO2; on the other hand, with fly ash bricks production in an energy-free route, there are no emissions. Dr. N. Subramanian, Consulting

Read more ...

Low Fines, Low Viscosity, Self-Consolidating Concrete for Better Impact on CO2 Emissions
Production of low fines SCC with increased robustness in a highly flowable, less viscous condition meeting true SCC specifications is now a reality to help realise the architect’s and engineer’s dream of various complex profiles and shapes in

Read more ...

Methods & Factors for Design of Slabs-on-Grade
Sunitha K Nayar, gives the grouping of slabs-on-grade based on the design philosophies and a brief overview of the different design methods, the commonalities between design strategies in terms of the input parameters, assumed and estimated parameters, and the

Read more ...

FIBERCRETE®: Synthetic Fibers for Concrete Reinforcement
Kalyani Polymers is offering world-class made-in-India Synthetic Micro & Macro Concrete Fiber Products for the Construction Industry under the brand name FIBERCRETE®. Concrete is an integral part of any construction project, it can be roads, tall structures

Read more ...

Climate Control Concrete
Leading cement and concrete maker ACC has unveiled a revolutionary thermal insulating climate control concrete system in India. Sridhar Balakrishnan, MD & CEO, ACC Limited, discusses its attributes, applications, and benefits for home builders, architects

Read more ...

Innovations in Crack Bridging with Self-Healing Bacteria in Concrete
Dr. Manjunatha L R, Vice President - Direct Sales & Sustainability Initiatives, and Raghavendra, Senior officer, JSW Cement Limited, discuss bacterial concrete that can meet the requirements for strength, durability, and self-healing of cracks.

Read more ...

Sustainable Development Through Use of Self-Curing Concrete
Dada S. Patil, Assistant Professor, Civil Engineering Department, AIKTC, Panvel, Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra; Dr. S. B. Anadinni, Professor & Associate Dean (Core Branches), School of Engineering, Presidency University, Bengaluru; and Dr. A. V. Shivapur, Professor

Read more ...

Developing a Corrosion Resistant RCC Structure
Samir Surlaker, Director, Assess Build Chem Private Limited, emphasizes the importance of a clear cover for a concrete structure since concrete as a porous material needs protection of its reinforcement. Along with the thickness (quantity) of cover, the porosity of

Read more ...

Quest for Higher Strength Concrete From HSC to UHPC
Concrete technology has come a long way since the Romans discovered the material, with a number of ingredients, which include a host of mineral and chemical admixtures, besides of course, the Portland cement, aggregates (coarse and fine), and water. These ingredients

Read more ...

Modelling Methods for Protection of RCC Structures
Anil Kumar Pillai, GM, Ramco Cements, discusses two major softwares (Life 365 and DuraCrete), used in the industry for protection of RCC structures. The common design approach is faulty because we consider only the loading aspect, whereas the environmental aspect is equally

Read more ...

Bajaj Reinforcements LLP - Introduces Fibre Tuff heavy-duty synthetic fibres that offer a range of benefits to concrete
Fibre Tuff, macro synthetic polypropylene fibres, are heavy-duty synthetic fibres that are specially engineered for use as secondary reinforcements, providing excellent resistance to the post cracking capacity of concrete. They are replacing steel fibres in a range

Read more ...

Use of Headed Bars in Reinforced Concrete Design
Reinforced concrete design and construction practice has historically focused on the use of bonded straight or bend rebar as a method for rebar anchorage. This relies on bond integrity between the rebar and the concrete so that sufficient anchorage

Read more ...

Innovation easy, effective and economical tool for asset creation
Innovation and entrepreneurship are essential ingredients in building a successful commercial venture. The ways in which these two concepts fuel enterprise are something entrepreneur's never stop exploring. There is no doubt that innovation were

Read more ...

Reactivity of Alite and Belite towards Sustainability of Concrete
Alite and belite are the predominant phases of Portland cement formulation. Alite is impure tricalcium silicate (C3S) and belite is impure dicalcium silicate (C2S). The impurities are an integral part as cement is manufactured

Read more ...

Innovative, Economic, Durable and Sustainable Concrete to last for +100 years of service life
Concrete is a versatile construction material and day by day its consumption is increasing globally. It is second only to water in the global consumption. No civil engineering structure is feasible without using concrete

Read more ...

Nanospan India Pvt Ltd
The use of Graphene with concrete has been talked about and researched ever since Graphene was invented in 2010 which grabbed its inventors a Nobel prize. Nanospan is the first company in the world to break technological and commercial

Read more ...

Fosroc: Building, Cementing & Supporting
Fosroc is the foundation of the JMH Group. It employs over 1700 employees in 17 operating companies based in Europe, the Gulf & Middle East, India, South Asia, and China. Through FGT, its trading company, it services another 50 countries

Read more ...

Dextra Group
Established in 1983 by French expatriate entrepreneurs, the Dextra Group has a long history of growth and development, driven by strong entrepreneurship and innovation. It has diversified into three main activities: manufacturing, trading and freight forwarding

Read more ...

Ferrochrome Ash Based Geopolymer Concrete
Jyotirmoy Mishra, Ph.D. Scholar, Department of Civil Engineering, Veer Surendra Sai University of Technology, Burla, Odisha, presents his research on the feasibility and compressive strength performance of geopolymer concrete

Read more ...

×
Sign-up for Free Subscription
'India Construction Week'
Weekly e-Newsletter on Construction Industry
Get the latest news, product launches, projects announced / awarded, government policies, investments, and expert views.
Click here to subscribe.
×