ICRA: Success of TOT model critical for funding Bharatmala programme

ICRA:  Success of TOT model critical for funding Bharatmala programme
While the NHAI borrowing programme is on track, the budgetary allocation in the last two budgets was lower than required thereby necessitating dependence on other funding avenues

The timely monetisation of mature road assets will be a critical determining factor in plugging the shortfall in budgetary allocations and fetch requisite funding to support ambitious execution targets set for the Bharatmala programme; failing which the shortfall will have to be met through additional borrowings, thereby further increasing the debt with the NHAI. In this context, success of the toll-operate-transfer (TOT) will be very significant. The overall funding requirement for the new highway development programme is estimated at Rs.6,92,324 crore, which is proposed to be funded through budgetary allocations1 of Rs.3,43,045 crore over FY2019-FY2022, market borrowings of Rs.2,09,279 crore, Rs. 34,000 crore through proceeds of monetisation through the toll-operate-transfer (TOT)2 route and the remaining Rs.1,06,000 crore through private sector participation.

Elaborating on the same, Mr. Rajeshwar Burla, AVP & Associate Head, Corporate Ratings, ICRA said, “A majority of the Bharatmala programme is expected to be undertaken through the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI). While the NHAI borrowing programme is on track, the budgetary allocation in the last two budgets was lower than required (Rs. 72,010 crore for FY2020 around 21%3 lower than what is required), thereby necessitating dependence on other funding avenues.”

It may be recalled that the Cabinet had approved the Bharatmala Pariyojana Phase-I along with other programmes in October, 2017 involving around 83,000 km (including Bharatmala Pariyojana Phase-I of 24,800 km) of national highway development by FY2022.

As per ICRA note, the first bundle under the TOT, which was awarded to Macquarie had a total of nine projects involving 681 km. As against the NHAI’s expectation – initial estimated concession value (IECV) of Rs.6258 crore, the winning bid of Macquarie stood at Rs.9682 crore. Considering that the H1 was higher than the NHAI’s estimate by 55%; the first TOT bid was a resounding success for the NHAI.

Comparison between first and second TOT bundles
 Parameter First bundle Second bundle
Number of stretches 9 8
Golden Quadrilateral stretches 6 0
Location 6 in AP; 3 in Gujarat 3 in West Bengal, 2 each in Gujarat and Rajasthan and 1 in Bihar
Median toll collection track record 10.89 years 6.65 years
Toll collections in FY2018 as per NHAI Rs. 513.38 crore Rs. 299.12 crore#
Total length 681 587
IECV* 6258^ (winning bid of Rs.9681.5 crore) 5362
IECV/Toll collection in FY2018 12.2 (18.9 times on winning bid) 17.9
Initial capex 814 929
1Including gross budgetary support (GBS), central road fund (CRF) and toll-permanent bridge fee fund (PBFF)
2 TOT is the model through which public funded national highway projects are monetised; these are operational projects with at least two years of toll collection track record. The concession period for TOT is 30 years with upfront concession fee payment to NHAI.
3The budgetary allocations to the ambitious new highway development programme is estimated at Rs. 3,43,045 crore over FY2019-FY2022 implying average allocation of around Rs. 86,000 crore per annum. Of this the REFY2019 allocation stood at Rs. 68,557 crore. Therefore, the remaining Rs. 2,74,488 crore is required to be allocated over FY2020-FY2022 averaging at Rs.91,496 crore per annum.
#Some of them were OMT contracts for which full revenues were not reported in FY2018;
*IECV: Initial Estimated Concession Value of Authority;
^Macquarie secured first bundle for Rs.9681.5 crore (55% higher than IECV, H1-H2 of 29%)
The bids for the second bundle of TOT were invited by the NHAI in August 2018. Following tepid response, the bid deadline for second bundle was deferred multiple times and finally concluded in December 2018. The second bundle witnessed three bidders. As against IECV of Rs.5362 crore, the H1 bid stood at Rs.4612 crore (from Cube Highways) – 14% lower than IECV. The H2 bid (Adani Group) stood at Rs. 3675 crore – 31% discount to IECV. Unlike the first bundle, there are no stretches along high density golden quadrilateral corridors for second bundle and many of these stretches are located in states with relatively lower economic activity and consequently the toll collection potential has been lower for the second bundle when compared to the first bundle. Therefore, it failed to elicit favourable response in line with the first bundle.

TOT bundle bids
(Source: NHAI, ICRA research; figures in Rs. crore)

“The fact that the first TOT bundle was awarded for a much higher price than the NHAI’s estimate by 55% has raised the expectations for second bundle. This is evident from the IECV (base price) to the annual toll collection (FY2018) ratio, which was 12.2 times for first bundle and 17.9 times for second bundle. The IECV multiple for second bundle is possibly aligned with the multiple for the winning bid for first bundle of 18.9,” Mr. Burla added.

To make the second bundle more attractive, the NHAI may add a couple of attractive stretches with more traffic density or replace some of the stretches with weak traffic density with that of higher traffic density. The NHAI also has the option to reduce the IECV but that would set a wrong precedent. Therefore, downward revision of IECV is unlikely. Under phase-I of TOT, seventy-five operational national highway projects totaling 4,376 km have been preliminarily identified for monetisation. Overall, the government expects to mop up about Rs. 34,000 crore from phase-I of TOT.

Karnataka clears ₹423-cr bridge venture

The Karnataka government has cleared a bridge project between Amabaragodlu and Kalasavalli villages in the Shravasti backwater region of Sagara taluka to be built at an investment of ₹423 crore. Once commissioned Read More ...

MMRDA speeds up ₹203-cr flyover project

Construction of the flyover connecting Eastern Express Highway with BKC is cruising ahead with MMRDA launching girders above the tracks near Sion and Chunabhatti stations. The nodal agency has got the approval to block Read More ...

Shristi Infra launches realty project in Bengal

West Bengal-based Shristi Infrastructure Development Corporation (SIDCL) has launched phase III of the lifestyle condominium at Krishnagar Sentrum in the state. The residential tower comprises premium 2-bhk and 3-bhk Read More ...

NHSRCL floats bids for ₹20,000-cr bullet train project

The National High Speed Rail Corporation (NHSRCL) has invited bids for 237-kms of the 508-km Ahmedabad-Mumbai bullet train project - the biggest ever contract for civil construction in India. Official sources informed Read More ...

L&T wins ₹2,236-cr BMRCL underground metro contract

L&T has bagged the tender for two underground packages of the Bangalore metro project on the Gottigere-Nagawara corridor. The company has received bids for the underground section from Vellara Junction to Shivajinagar Read More ...

Railway hastens ₹5,000-cr Khalilabad-Bahraich rail line

The Indian Railways recently launched a 240 km-long Khalilabad-Bahraich railway line involving an investment of ₹5,000 crore in Uttar Pradesh. Official sources informed that the railway track will be constructed to connect Read More ...

Expressway worth ₹90,000-cr off to a flying start

NHAI has launched construction work of the 1,320-km long Delhi-Vadodara-Mumbai Expressway involving an estimated cost worth ₹90,000 crore. The work of the mega project is being taken up in three phases at a cost of Read More ...

Cabinet clears ₹12,114-cr Surat metro rail project

In a major boost to public transport in the Diamond City, the Union cabinet has approved the Surat Metro Rail project entailing an investment of ₹12,114 crore. The city will also in the near future see pre- Read More ...

NHAI unveils ₹5,010-cr highway project in TN

NHAI has launched construction work on the ₹5,010-crore highway projects in Kanchipuram in Tamil Nadu. State government sources said that the PM has already laid the foundation stones for the mega road projects, which Read More ...

MoRTH launches ₹1,588-cr inter-modal hub in Nagpur

The Union transport minister has launched construction of an inter-modal station (IMS) hub involving an investment of ₹1,588.81 crore, in Nagpur. IMS is a passenger terminal integrating various transportation Read More ...

CCEA approves ₹1,866-cr for rail line in Odisha

The Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs has cleared construction of a third railway line between Narayangarh in West Bengal and Bhadrak in Odisha. Finance minister Arun Jaitley said that the new 155-km railway line, which Read More ...

KEC International rakes up ₹1,323-cr contracts

EPC company KEC International, has bagged multiple orders worth ₹1,323 crore in railways, civil, smart city infrastructure, cable laying, power transmission and distribution (T&D) segments. Its T&D business has secured Read More ...

SECR clears ₹922-cr gauge conversion of rail line

The ministry of railways has sanctioned ₹922 crore gauge conversion projects between Nagpur and Nagbhid with a length of 106-km and civil and construction work on long-pending gauge conversion project being taken up Read More ...

S Pallonji launches premium realty project in Thane

The renowned real estate builder of national repute, Shapoorji Pallonji, has recently announced its entry into Thane residential realty market with the launch of its first premium residential project Northern Read More ...

NHAI floats tenders for bridge & road projects

National Highway Authorities of India has floated e-tenders to build a new Moorad bridge on NH-66 and a small bridge at Palolipalam at an estimated cost of ₹51.66 crore. Besides, the four-lane bridge, a 2.1 km service Read More ...

Decks cleared for Ferozepur-Amritsar rail link

The state government of Punjab has approved ₹40 crore for construction of the Ferozepur-Amritsar direct rail link for which the land acquisition process in Ferozepur and Tarn Taran districts is being fast tracked. The Read More ...
NBM&CW

New Building Material & Construction World

New Building Material & Construction World
MGS Architecture

Modern Green Structures & Architecture

Modern Green Structures & Architecture
L&ST

Lifting & Specialized Transport

Lifting & Specialized Transport
II&TW

Indian Infrastructure & Tenders Week

Indian Infrastructure & Tenders Week