Why Infra Projects Suffer Time & Cost Overruns

An inside story of Inadequate Geotechnical Investigations by Amol Shingarey

An inside story of Inadequate Geotechnical Investigations by Amol Shingarey, MD, Geotech Services, Nagpur

In 1991, the Ground Board of the Institution of Civil Engineers, London, published a report on inadequate site investigation leading to construction delays and additional costs. The findings were based on a study of 5000 Industrial buildings, 8000 commercial projects, and 200 roads & bridges; of which 37%, 50%, and 35%, respectively, suffered time & cost overruns due to inadequate site investigations. The report concludes with recommendations of awareness programs for clients, planners, architects, engineers, builders, and quantity surveyors, and also insurance and property development companies, with the aim of highlighting the significance of site and ground investigation on civil engineering and building projects.

In India, many news articles are published in newspapers on project delays, cost overruns etc, without studying the root cause. Recently it was reported that:
  • Out of 1,673 projects, 445 projects reported cost overruns, totalling to more than Rs 4.4 lakh cr.
  • 557 projects were delayed by an average of 45.69 months.
  • It has also been observed that project agencies are not reporting revised cost estimates and commissioning schedules for many projects, which suggests that time/cost overrun figures are under-reported.
  • Delay & cost overrun is attributed to:
  1. Tie up for financing
  2. Detail engineering report
  3. Tendering process
  4. Law & order problems
According to a study by KPMG, only 31% of all projects came within 10% of the budget in the past 3 years. However, the real cause for time & cost overrun (TCO) are either not known to the top management or is covered up. In many situations it has been experienced that even after realizing the real cause for TCO, the government agencies and even public & private sector organizations are not willing to make any attempt for improvement.

Two case studies cited below reveal the truth:

Case Study 1 – Railway Bridge Project
A 13 span railway bridge was constructed by designing foundations with “safe bearing capacity (SBC) of 25 tons per sq.m.” Investigation was done by a civil contractor having no experience in Geotechnical investigation, was quoted the “lowest”. In the first monsoon itself, majority of the foundations were exposed due to scouring. But no distress was observed due to total or differential settlement. The only problem was of scouring; hence it was recommended that ‘Rock Apron’ on the up & down stream and a cut off up to 3 meters, to the foundation by joining them to a bed level with a nominal raft, would be sufficient to prevent scouring.

But this simple solution could not be digested by the authorities. A national level academic institution was appointed as consultant. It conduced ‘Plate load tests’ (PLT) on 50% locations at the foundation level. Actually, PLT is not an appropriate test for this type of soils. Water table was very high at the test level, though cautioned not to dewater during the test. The ‘expert’ from the Institute did not agree. Ultimately, SBC’s determined by him varied in the range of 5 tons to 26 tons per sq.m. Then they recommended for total rehabilitation of all the foundations by providing 6 piles around each of the old open foundations, with heavy cap and shear connections. The original cost of bridge was Rs. 2 cr., whereas rehabilitation cost was Rs. 8 cr., with 3 years of time delay for a project costing Rs. 650 cr.

An inside story of Inadequate Geotechnical Investigations by Amol Shingarey

Case Study 2 – Irrigation Project
An Irrigation project in Maharashtra was planned at Rs.384 cr. in 1984. Detail investigation was done only for the main dam, and no proper investigation for either Geotechnical or Material was done for the canals. A 70 km main canal flows mostly below the natural ground. The depth below ground varies from approx. 8 to 14 meters. The canal itself is only 6 meter deep, with 1 meter free board and 18 meters width at the bottom. The canal was designed with a slope of 1:1.5 without any consideration to the soil properties and surrounding field conditions. Slopes of canal were lined with only 100 mm plain concrete to prevent water seepage. A blanket of local soil was provided as a layer of “Cohesive Non Swelling Soil” (CNS), under concrete lining to prevent it from ‘swell pressure’ of the soils in cuts. The concrete lining failed at many locations, as the soil used in the blanket was not at all CNS.

An inside story of Inadequate Geotechnical Investigations by Amol Shingarey

CNS was a granular soil with least ‘Cohesion’, and could not resist swell Pressure, consequently concrete lining started failing in the first monsoon itself.

An inside story of Inadequate Geotechnical Investigations by Amol Shingarey

To prevent slope failure, retaining wall of size 9 meters in the bottom and 0.5m on the top & 6 m high was constructed to prevent further failures. Thankfully it was constructed only in 400m trial length. This also failed in the next season. The failure was so severe that the entire retaining wall moved nearly 9 meters, breaking bottom concrete slab of canal up to the centre of the canal.

An inside story of Inadequate Geotechnical Investigations by Amol Shingarey

After analysis it was found that Factor of Safety was only 0.89 against 1.4, which is unsafe!

The total project cost was Rs 372.22 cr. in March 1983 when estimated and escalated (repeated- consider risen) to Rs 13,739 cr. up to 2012, to nearly Rs 16,000 cr. in 2020.

An inside story of Inadequate Geotechnical Investigations by Amol Shingarey

The canal has also a divided forest and restricted movement of wild animals. The environmental impact of this project is beyond calculations. (Photo of tiger crossing district road during the daytime on 7th July 2022).

Similarly, when a Detail Project Report (DPR) is prepared, before any tendering process, it should be done very systematically, as all the designs & quantities are derived from this. But these DPRs are made in haste and in a casual manner, which become a source of all deviations in the future. The following example will explains how.

DPR Example: A metro rail tender for a DPR published in June 2019, gave a time limit of 6 weeks (Inception report - 10 days, Field work - 4 weeks, final report submission - 6 weeks) - all from the date of award of work; with total drilling: 360rmt. and 979 no. of laboratory tests. No laboratory, with ongoing work in-hand, can complete such a job in the stipulated timeline. In such works, drilling is done in haste. Many boreholes are not even drilled to the reported depth; and many of the lab tests are not performed at all, by filling up the data. The drillers working at field are neither trained nor are they supervised. Moreover, the rates of tests mentioned were extremely low and not at all workable. The following comparison will give a clear picture:

Comparison of rates of few laboratory tests

S.N. Test Delhi Metro in Rs./no Indian Railway in Rs./no
1 Sieve analysis 55.60 735.87
2 Atterberg‟ s Limits 161.65 535.18
3 Tri- axial 336.73 2006.91
Naturally, DPR based on such investigations are always inaccurate and lead to escalation in cost & extra time. But this is very much in favour of construction agencies, because, “new rates” are applicable to all alterations/additions and change in items. Supervising consulting agencies also get benefitted with this. Hence it is only public money which is at stake.

The example and case studies mentioned above are just a tip of an iceberg, as there are countless cases in all fields of civil engineering. But surprisingly, very few are aware, many are not “affected” and the issue remains unsolved, incurring huge loss to the nation.

DFII- Deep Foundation Institute (India), has taken over this issue for the improvement and formed a committee for “Geotechnical Characterisation for Foundations” (DCGCF) to work on it. The committee has identified following four activities for improvement:
  1. Creating awareness amongst the top management and decision makers about cost & time overrun due to inadequate geotechnical Investigations.
  2. Assistance & advice to stakeholders for enhancement in “Tendering Process” for defining scope of work, time schedule and selection of appropriate agency.
  3. Training of Laboratory & Field personnel from geotechnical Investigation agencies.
  4. Training to fresh civil Engineers for early insight in the subject.
The committee has already conducted two training programs to train the trainers and laboratory personnel as well. DFII has also signed a MoU with the National Institute of Construction, Hyderabad, for conducting training programs. The Committee has also envisaged the geographical limitations of the participants for attending such programs and is in the process to initiate these at various Govt. educational Institutions and engineering colleges, in various parts of India. The Committee is also planning its first one-day “Awareness Workshop” at Hyderabad by the end of this year. The goal to achieve is definitely challenging, but not impossible!
NBM&CW September 2022

No comments yet, Be the first one to comment on this.

×

Terms & Condition

By checking this, you agree with the following:
  1. To accept full responsibility for the comment that you submit.
  2. To use this function only for lawful purposes.
  3. Not to post defamatory, abusive, offensive, racist, sexist, threatening, vulgar, obscene, hateful or otherwise inappropriate comments, or to post comments which will constitute a criminal offense or give rise to civil liability.
  4. Not to post or make available any material which is protected by copyright, trade mark or other proprietary right without the express permission of the owner of the copyright, trade mark or any other proprietary right.
  5. To evaluate for yourself the accuracy of any opinion, advice or other content.
Foundation Equipment in Greater Demand: Sany, Schwing Stetter & Casagrande

Foundation Equipment in Greater Demand: Sany, Schwing Stetter & Casagrande

Contractors undertaking complex urban infra projects are looking for foundation and piling equipment with faster drilling speeds, product reliability, flexibility in operations, lower operating costs, higher productivity, and a long lifespan.

Read more ...

Liebherr’s First Unplugged Piling Rig LRH 100.1 on Jobsite in Sweden

Liebherr’s First Unplugged Piling Rig LRH 100.1 on Jobsite in Sweden

A building complex with flats, offices and shops on the ground floor is being built in Karlstad, Sweden. In order to transfer the load of the building into load-bearing soil layers, the company, Hercules Grundläggning AB, is driving piles

Read more ...

Suretech Infrastructure: Pile Driving Equipment & Sheet Pile Solutions

Suretech Infrastructure: Pile Driving Equipment & Sheet Pile Solutions

Suretech Infrastructure, specialist in pile driving equipment for over 30 years, is installing all types of temporary and permanent sheet piles and casings. The company has a wealth of experience in helping clients select the equipment

Read more ...

Eimco Elecon's Made in India Fuel Efficient Rotary Piling Rig

Eimco Elecon's Made in India Fuel Efficient Rotary Piling Rig

Eimco Elecon, has been offering a wide range of products such as side discharged loaders, load haul dumpers, chairlift man riding system, continuous miner, roof bolter, shuttle car etc, for use in Underground Mining. “EC216 is an indigenized machine

Read more ...

Casagrande's Piling Rig, Diaphragm Wall, Hydromill & Tunneling Machine

Casagrande's Piling Rig, Diaphragm Wall, Hydromill & Tunneling Machine

Casagrande is marking 60 years in the field of deep foundation, and geotechnical investigation. “We are mainly meeting the requirements of projects that require the latest technology for high productivity and speedy completion of jobs. Our focus

Read more ...

Kennametal's Foundation Drilling Tools And Powerful Cutting Systems

Kennametal's Foundation Drilling Tools And Powerful Cutting Systems

The key to a successful foundation drilling operation lies in the selection of the right equipment, tooling and the cutting system depending on the geological conditions. Rohit Reddy, Deputy General Manager, Earth Cutting Business, Kennametal

Read more ...

Epiroc's Drill Rig, Pulverizer, Cutter, Rock Drills & Intelligence

Epiroc's Drill Rig, Pulverizer, Cutter, Rock Drills & Intelligence

Epiroc is helping customers maximize use of the latest technologies, and developing new ways of raising efficiency and improving sustainability. Its aim is to ensure that customers benefit fully from the ongoing digital evolution. It offers

Read more ...

Deep Foundation Construction

Deep Foundation Construction

Proper site characterisation can eliminate significant risks involved in the design and construction of pile foundation both in liquefiable and non-liquefiable soils, emphasizes Dr Parthasarathy, CMD, Sarathy Geotech & Engineering Services

Read more ...

Helical Screw Piles and Opportunities in India

Helical Screw Piles and Opportunities in India

Mohan Ramanathan, Managing Director, Advanced Construction Technologies, Chennai, gives insights into the current scenario of deep foundations in India and the need for improved adoption of Helical Screw Piles Methodology for efficient foundation construction

Read more ...

For Speedier & Quality Construction

For Speedier & Quality Construction

G. Venkat Prasad, Director Operations, DFII, emphasizes the need for implementing global best practices and technologies in geotechnical and foundation construction for effective project implementation. India is in a fast-forward mode: the country is implementing

Read more ...

Blast Hole Rig From PRD For Aggregates And Granite Quarrying

Blast Hole Rig From PRD For Aggregates And Granite Quarrying

PRD is the first drilling rig manufacturer in India with ISO 9001:2015 certification; it has a wide range of superior quality products that include core drilling, reverse circulation drilling, pole drilling, blast hole drilling, and roof bolt drilling

Read more ...

Epirock's Drilling Rigs, Rock Drilling Tools, Truck, Loader & Cutters

Epirock's Drilling Rigs, Rock Drilling Tools, Truck, Loader & Cutters

Mandy Che, Managing Director of Epiroc Mining India Limited speaks about the growing business opportunities in India. Epirock offers drilling rigs, rock drilling tools, dump trucks, loaders, haggloaders, hydraulic breakers, bucket crushers

Read more ...

Piling Rigs: Casagrande, Sany, Liebherr & Schwing Stetter Insights

Piling Rigs: Casagrande, Sany, Liebherr & Schwing Stetter Insights

Manufacturers of piling rigs are looking to introduce newer, more digitized products, while keeping prices competitive, as large-scale development of transportation infra projects in India drives demand. Casagrande, Sany Heavy Industries, Liebherr

Read more ...

PRD Geotechnical Drills Rigs: Compact Yet Powerful

PRD Geotechnical Drills Rigs: Compact Yet Powerful

Complete your geotechnical investigations and expand opportunities for handling multiple types of jobs to increase your profit potential by using compact, yet powerful PRD Geotechnical Drills.

Read more ...

Piling Rigs: Casagrande, Sany Heavy Industries & ACE

Piling Rigs: Casagrande, Sany Heavy Industries & ACE

Buoyed by projects in roads, metro rails and other infrastructure developments, there is renewed activity in the foundation and piling equipment industry with manufacturers and distributors like Casagrande, Sany Heavy Industries & ACE offering

Read more ...

Basement Construction by Casagrande Diaphragm Wall Machines in Gujarat

Basement Construction by Casagrande Diaphragm Wall Machines in Gujarat

Casagrande leads in basement construction in Gujarat, offering superior diaphragm wall machines for quality excavation and meeting strict specifications.

Read more ...

IMT S.p.A. unveils 'Made in India' AF 125 Piling Rig at partner GMMCO's facility

IMT S.p.A. unveils 'Made in India' AF 125 Piling Rig at partner GMMCO's facility

IMT, one of the global leaders in piling rigs, has launched its AF 125 piling rig. Made in India for the Indian market, this 125 KN torque capacity rig was unveiled to customers on 27 Nov 2018 in an event organized at IMT's partner, GMMCO's

Read more ...

Indus displays new hydraulic rock breakers and surface drills

Indus displays new hydraulic rock breakers and surface drills

Pune-based Indus Rock Tools showcased series of new products are designed to meet the primary and secondary surface rock breaking requirements. At bauma CONEXPO India, the company showed its

Read more ...

To get latest updates on whatsapp, Save +91 93545 87773 and send us a 'Saved' message
Click Here to Subscribe to Our eNewsletter.