It is high time that the off-highway market looked again at the materials it uses in machines and identifies ways to reduce the amount it uses, beat price increases, material shortages, and emission targets, observes Alastair Hayfield, Senior Research Director, Interact Analysis.

How Off-Highway OEMs Can Improve Efficiencies by Reducing Machine Weight

Heavy Equipment needs to go on a Diet
The use of light-weight materials is very common in automotive, helping OEMs and suppliers meet emission and performance goals. Aluminium, carbon fibre, plastics, structural adhesives and more are all a part of the manufacturers’ tool kit when it comes to shedding pounds.

But is the use of lightweight and alternative materials a practical choice for off-highway machine builders? It comes with a higher cost, performance challenges, and, given the extreme operating conditions for most machines, potentially shortened life expectancy.

All this might change. As the industry slowly awakens to the potential of electrification and is hammered by rising material and fuel costs, will we see off-highway OEMs look at ways to improve efficiency and reduce the use of certain materials?

Does my Bill-of-Materials (BOM) look big in this?
For the most part, there has been almost zero focus on machine weight in the off-highway industry. Whilst soil compaction might be an issue in agriculture, heavy and robust construction machines are typically required from a longevity and balance perspective (large excavators have removable counterweights precisely because they might topple over if they didn’t have them when moving heavy loads). Machinery is also often operated when it is static, meaning that there is no efficiency penalty from having a very heavy machine. However, not all machines stay still and not all parts of machines are static: there are opportunities a plenty for the off-highway industry to tighten its belt and reduce the bill-of-materials (BOM).

A Weigh to Go
Off-highway is, predictably, a long way behind automotive when it comes to light-weighting, material substitution, and novel manufacturing techniques. To give a few examples from automotive:

The 2013 Range Rover became somewhat of a “celebrity dieter” when it was launched, being nearly half a ton lighter than its predecessor thanks to an all-aluminium chassis. Aluminium is now commonly used in cars for light-weighting.

BMW used carbon fibre reinforced plastic (CFRP) for its mass produced i3. Although it is more expensive than steel, it made the chassis lighter (a substantial boon for the electric i3) and the production process versus steel or aluminium is quicker and less energy intensive.

Living in a Material World
When it comes to material choice, steel has typically been used for structural, powertrain and body parts in off-highway. It’s cheap, hard-wearing, easy to form and can be repaired easily. However, there are a range of different materials that are starting to gain traction as they support either better fuel efficiency or improved operational performance.

How Off-Highway OEMs Can Improve Efficiencies by Reducing Machine Weight(Source: https://www.globalagtechinitiative.com/market-watch/john-deere-to-acquire-carbon-fiber-boom-manufacturer-in-spain/)

John Deere uses carbon fibre for its sprayer booms as opposed to steel. In some instances, it is nearly 1 tonne lighter than its steel equivalent. This helps to reduce weight and fuel usage. It also means a sprayer can be larger, reducing the number of passes a tractor must make to cover a field, further reducing the amount of fuel used.

How Off-Highway OEMs Can Improve Efficiencies by Reducing Machine Weight(Source: https://www.tatasteeleurope.com/sites/default/files/tata-steel-engineering-ympress-s700mc-excavator-arm-high-strength-lightweight-datasheet-en-eu.pdf)

Tata Steel has simulated the use of its high-strength steel as a replacement material in excavator arms. A 23% weight reduction was achieved, saving both material costs and also meaning that either fuel is saved, or an excavator can move more material per cycle. This then boosts the operational performance of machine, positively impacting the bottom line of the mine or building contractor.

How Off-Highway OEMs Can Improve Efficiencies by Reducing Machine Weight

Hardox – a steel product developed by SSAB AB – is wear resistant. It has been used in haul truck beds and in excavator buckets. Because of its hardness, less material is needed, making the parts lighter. In the case of the excavator bucket, a 30% reduction in weight is acheivable with a corresponding 20% increase in the amount of material that can be carried.

Simulation
Generative design is a software tool that allows components or parts to be designed that minimize material use whilst maximizing structural performance. Often looking “organic”, these new parts are iterated over thousands of generations from a starting design that is constrained by certain design parameters. This technique is becoming more common place in automotive, but it has the potential to revolutionize the design of off-highway machinery.

How Off-Highway OEMs Can Improve Efficiencies by Reducing Machine Weight(Source: https://www.korall.io/projects-jhondeere.html)

Korall Engineering used generative design to reduce the weight of a John Deere excavator boom. The final topology optimised design shows a 13.3% reduction in mass by comparison with the original arm design: this product is about 90Kg lighter. The generative design shows a 56.2% reduction in mass by comparison with the original arm design: this product is about 380Kg lighter.

Weighing Up
Ukraine- and Covid-related supply chain issues won’t abate soon. It’s also entirely likely that there will be other flash points in coming years that impact global supply chains, particularly with the substantial transitions away from fossil fuels to energy technologies that require multiple, rare-earth materials.

To protect against material shortages, (and energy price fluctuations) OEMs would be well advised to investigate how they can use less material and how they can integrate materials that are less likely to be in short-term demand. The benefit to this approach is that it means that OEMs can protect against future price increases (which usually get passed on to customers) and also guarantee product availability, which is likely to be a competitive advantage for some time.

Use of simulation and different materials could significantly reduce the weight of certain components. In the case of excavator arms, this could be deployed on both new and existing machines. This is a fundamental game changer as the fuel/operational efficiency of machines currently in the market is not something that can easily be changed.

Perhaps the biggest reason to look at materials, particularly lightweight materials, is the shift to electric machinery. Reducing the weight of electric machines will help to extend the operational performance of the battery or help reduce the size of battery needed. This either improves customer performance or brings the price of the machine down.

Alastair Hayfield
About Author
Alastair Hayfield has over 15 years’ experience leading research activities in scaled, high-growth industrial and technology markets. As Senior Research Director of our Commercial Vehicles Division, he’s responsible for cutting-edge research on electric trucks and buses, autonomous trucks and off-highway electrification
Backhoe Loader An All-Time Performer
The demand for Backhoe Loader is here to stay, which is clearly visible in the 2nd half of FY23 sales numbers and in the 1st quarter of FY24 sales figures. This is despite many stumbling blocks in the past few years like GST, the Covid pandemic, the hike in

Read more ...

Deepak Shetty - CEO & Managing Director, JCB India
“We are continuously tapping opportunities to reduce costs for our customers; over the past three years, we have introduced more fuel-efficient and low-maintenance products which has led to a significant improvement in the Total Cost of Ownership

Read more ...

BKR Prasad - Tata Hitachi
“We are working on several marketing strategies: we are expanding our backhoe loader product line, diversifying our product portfolio by introducing new types of equipment and entering related markets, and are also increasing our presence in export

Read more ...

Puneet Vidyarthi - CASE Construction Equipment
“By investing in research and development, we aim to enhance the features, performance, and efficiency of our backhoe loaders so that the improved products align with the evolving industry requirements.” Puneet Vidyarthi, Head – Marketing

Read more ...

Hafeez Khan - MD, Manitou South Asia
“We are committed to offer our world class backhoe loader with the most reliable components, lowest cost of ownership, best fuel efficiency, and technical support, through our vast dealership network and own SSPs.” Hafeez Khan, Managing Director

Read more ...

Manish Handa - Action Construction Equipments India
“We constantly review market trends so that we can realign our business to meet customer demands, make improvisations in our machines to enhance their performance, and expand our dealer network to better service the end-users of our

Read more ...

Suraj Prakash Verma - Escorts Kubota India
“In the competitive market landscape, Escorts Kubota India introduces the Digmax Super – a symbol of innovation and efficiency. This advanced backhoe loader not only enhances power and fuel efficiency, but also offers versatility across terrains and

Read more ...

Excavator - Manufacturers Developing Technologically Sophisticated Equipment for Higher Fuel Efficiency & Productivity
Envisaging high demand this fiscal, excavator manufacturers are designing and developing more advanced equipment that meets end-users’ expectations for higher fuel efficiency and productivity. Improvements are being made in the motors and hydraulic

Read more ...

Kobelco: A Strong Contender in the Excavator Market
E. Moses, Vice President & National Head - Excavator Division, at Kobelco India, informs that the company plans to be active in the mining industry with its higher capacity, robust Excavators, and aims to further strengthen its brand value by setting up

Read more ...

Tata Hitachi - Delivering Higher Productivity
Tata Hitachi is harnessing its strong, localized manufacturing and design competence to enhance productivity, while lowering the life cycle costs of its customers, avers BKR Prasad, General Manager, Marketing, Tata Hitachi. Tata Hitachi India is banking

Read more ...

Volvo CE: Building Value
Dimitrov Krishnan, MD, Volvo CE India, informs that foreseeing demand for excavators to remain buoyant during FY 23-24, the company is gearing up to promote its products across various industrial projects. Excavators are highly versatile

Read more ...

JCB India - Driving Innovative New Solutions
With the launch of several new excavator models, JCB India is widening its market presence in the 21-ton and above class of excavators for use in infrastructure construction, mining, and quarrying, informs Deepak Shetty, CEO & MD, JCB India

Read more ...

CASE India’s Unstoppable Innovations & Developments
According to Puneet Vidyarthi, Head of Marketing and Business Development, India & SAARC, CASE Construction India, the company’s two newly launched Crawler Excavators - CX220C and CX220C LC - have already proved their reliability, efficiency, and

Read more ...

Schwing Stetter India Widening Presence
V. G. Sakthikumar, Managing Director, Schwing Stetter India, outlines the company’s strategies to drive sales and expand the brand’s presence across industries. We have a three-pronged strategy to drive sales of our 7-10-20 ton class of excavators. One is

Read more ...

Liugong India: Staying Competitive
Nischal Mehrotra, Vice President,Liugong India, informs that the company is making design and technological advancements in its products to stay ahead in a highly competitive market. In India, demand for excavators will continue to be driven by the

Read more ...

Five Equipment Dealership Trends that will Shape 2023-24
If you have been working around construction equipment you have probably heard of the “Equipment Triangle,” a philosophy that is one of the fundamental tenets of the Association of Equipment Management Professionals (AEMP). The theory

Read more ...

Tata Hitachi Construction Machinery - Aao Kartavya Nibhaye, Chalo Desh Banaye
Tata Hitachi Construction Machinery - a joint venture between Tata Motors Limited (40 percent) and Hitachi Construction Machinery Limited (60 percent), has been an integral part of India’s growth story for more than six decades. The organization’s

Read more ...

Caterpillar organizes customer meeting; showcases latest range of large hydraulic excavators
Caterpillar Inc., world’s leading manufacturer of construction and mining equipment, off-highway diesel and natural gas engines, industrial gas turbines and diesel-electric locomotives, along with long-standing Cat® dealer Gmmco, organized a one-day

Read more ...

Construction Equipment sales cross 1 lakh mark in FY 2022-23 To grow 15-20% this Fiscal
The Indian Construction Equipment industry recorded an excellent 26% growth YoY with sales crossing the one lakh unit mark in FY2022-23. CE sales in Q4 of FY23 (Jan-Mar 2023) increased by 23% over Q4-FY22 and by 22% over Q3-FY23. On a month-on

Read more ...

Case India: Building Competence
Case Construction India is banking on its recently launched 770 NXe Loader Backhoe, the 770EX Tractor Backhoe Loader, and CX 220LC Tracked Excavator, to mark a stronger presence in the highly competitive Indian Construction Equipment market. P.P. Basistha

Read more ...