Cut & Cover Metro Stations & Other Underground Structures

Vinay Gupta, Director & CEO, Tandon Consultants, discusses the intricacies and issues in the construction of underground metro stations including strata survey during structural design, selection of methods and techniques of construction, traffic management, handling of utilities, installation of diaphragm walls, launching and retrieving of TBM, manufacturing of precast segments and more.

Underground construction poses several new challenges such as execution of Diaphragm Walls for Top-down or Bottom-up construction, Secant Piles for Bottom-up construction, Soldiers Pile-Wooden Lagging for Bottom up construction, etc. Installation of Diaphragm Walls is easy in soil sub strata, but extremely difficult in rock substrata. In such cases, use of Trench Cutter becomes necessary.

A new technique called Cube method involves construction of a shaft at each of the two ends of the Diaphragm Walls, and driving a tool horizontally between the two, keeping the upper strata undisturbed. Installation of Ground Anchors to control floatation and Rock Bolts to control lateral forces/sway of soil retaining system are intricate processes. Soft Eye comprising of Glass/Carbon Fiber Reinforcement is constructed within the retaining wall for the TBM to cut through the wall easily while entering the station structure. Tunnel Lining, Cross Passages, TBM Advancement, Tunnel Ventilation are some of the specific issues related to Tunnel Boring. Handling the traffic and utilities during construction require special careful planning to prevent any disruption to public life. Instrumentation and Monitoring are other important aspects of underground construction.

Underground Metro Station
A typical underground metro station has a main station body of about 20m width and 250m length with two levels below the ground, lower level for track and platform, and upper level for concourse (paid & unpaid areas). The main station body is flanked by four or more entry-exit structures connecting ground level to the concourse. Figure 1 depicts a typical station footprint. Figure 2 shows an inside view of the concourse and platform levels (with a large opening at the concourse level).

Cut & Cover Metro Stations & Other Underground Structures

Top-down Method of Construction
Top-down method of construction is more common as the ground above is usually required for traffic or other uses during construction. This method requires the use of RCC Diaphragm Walls (Figure 3) followed in sequence by the roof slab, the concourse slab, and the base slab, wherein connection between the Diaphragm Wall and these slabs are achieved through reinforcement couplers (Figure 4). Use of Secant Pile wall or Contiguous Bored Piles as permanent wall for Top-down Construction is not in vogue yet.

Cut & Cover Metro Stations & Other Underground Structures

Bottom-up Method of Construction
In locations where the ground is not required to be used during construction, or where there is hard rock at small depths, making a Diaphragm Wall difficult, the conventional bottom-up construction is used. In such cases, either we go for sloped excavation (not desirable for deep excavations) or the use of Secant Pile Wall, Contiguous Bored RCC Piles or Soldier Pile-Wooden Lagging system (depending upon the suitability). Figures 5 & 6 show soldier pile-wooden lagging and contiguous bored pile, respectively. Similarly, figures 7 & 8 may be referred to for Secant pile and lateral bracing system, respectively.

Cut & Cover Metro Stations & Other Underground StructuresCut & Cover Metro Stations & Other Underground Structures

Analysis
The main aspects of the analysis are soil and water pressure at every stage of construction. The sub-surface profile requires utmost care in deciding the corresponding design parameters. Complex 3-D analysis models associated with such structures is shown in Figures 9 & 10, which are generated with various loading combinations. Some of the useful tools to analyse correctly the structure for its interaction with the adjoining soil are Wallup and PLAXIS. General purpose software like STAAD and MIDAS are used for service stage analysis for its superimposition with the construction stage analysis.

Cut & Cover Metro Stations & Other Underground Structures

Launching of Tunnel Boring Machine (TBM)
The other important area of concern is the location of launching and retrieval of Tunnel Boring Machine (TBM) used for tunneling. Usually, this area is maintained at the end part of the station body as depicted in Figure 11 - sometimes a separate structure, depending on the construction sequence. Once the end wall of the station launching retrieval area is constructed the TBM is required to penetrate through it to move (Figure 12). A Soft Eye comprising Glass Fiber reinforcement or Carbon Fiber reinforcement is incorporated in the Diaphragm Wall that can be cut by the cutters of TBM for it to advance through.

Cut & Cover Metro Stations & Other Underground Structures

Drive Through & Drag Through
One of the common methods of launching and retrieval is to make launching shaft (LS) and retrieval shaft (RS), respectively (usually at the last 15m part of the station structure) and later used as an area for housing various services. This entails launching, retrieving, and again launching the TBM, which consumes time, but is cheaper.

However, in cases where construction timing and sequence demand earlier movement of the TBM, other methods of TBM movement such as Drive Through (Bore Through) and Drag Through are used. When the station body is ready fairly early, we can go for Drag Through type wherein the TBM is moved over the already cast base slab of the station using bottom-up construction (Figure 13).

On the other hand, when the station is expected to be delayed somewhat, we drive the tunnel through (Bored Through method) with sacrificial tunnel segments to be removed after constructing the station structure (Figure 14). This is more expensive due to the sacrificial segments but needed in certain circumstances. On the whole, there are many issues involved in UG Metro Stations that require careful planning and conceptualisation.

Planning of Tunnel Movement
The entire construction scheme depends on the planning of TBM movement. As explained above, the station may have LS and RS for launching and retrieving the TBM, respectively. Or drag through or bored through method may be used. Sometimes, the non-availability of TBM in the initial phase may affect the construction planning. The designer has to design the structure suited to the construction type and sequence. Figure 15 below depicts TBM movement for a stretch.

Cut & Cover Metro Stations & Other Underground Structures

Sometimes, a separate LS or RS is constructed to launch or retrieve the TBM when none of the above techniques are found difficult. The LS / RS is used as Vent Shafts which are necessary for the Tunnel Ventilation System (TVS).

Manufacturing of Tunnel Precast Segments
Figures 16 & 17 depict the method of casting in a steel mould and of stacking them.

Cut & Cover Metro Stations & Other Underground Structures

While the segment (a shell element) is cast in one orientation, it needs to be rotated to upside down orientation. It is done by a different mechanism wherein a vacuum lifter is used (Figure 18) and a special rotating bed is used for the rotation (Figure 19).

Conclusions
There are many intricacies in the construction of underground structures. The method to be adopted needs a careful consideration of the available site, construction equipment, and the timeline of each element. The structural design needs to cater to every construction scheme. Geotechnical aspects and ground water table play a vital role in the design and economics. Some of the smart software tools have made it possible to analyse and design complex underground structures.

Taking a cue from Paris and London – cities that appear neat and clean with their metro rails running underground - India is moving in the same direction and constructing a large number of metro projects all over the country.

About the author
Vinay Gupta civil Engineer from BITS, Pilani
Vinay Gupta is a civil Engineer from BITS, Pilani (1983). He is currently Director & CEO at Tandon Consultants that specializes in bridges, flyovers, underground & metro structures, precast buildings, chimneys, etc. He is an active member of various Code Committees of BIS and IRC. His contributions include preparation of IRC:SP:65 (Segmental Bridges), IRC:SP:71 (Precast Pretensioned Girders Bridges), etc. He is a recipient of several awards from IEI, IBC, UKEIRI, etc and has authored about 100 technical papers. He is a Guest Faculty at IAHE, CRRI, CIDC, ISDA, DPC, etc. and is also the President of IIBE and of ICI.
Sela Tunnel Project - Overcoming The Impossible
The responsibility for construction and maintenance of Balipara-Charduar-Tawang (BCT) Road has been entrusted to Border Roads Organisation (BRO). The 317.520 km long road connects West Kameng and Tawang districts of Arunachal Pradesh to the rest

Read more ...

Slurry TBM ‘Channel Express’ launched by CRCHI for working in Water Supply Tunnels in Singapore
On February 1, 2023, CRCHI attended the launching ceremony of its Slurry TBM ‘Channel Express’. It will be used in the construction of key water supply tunnel project TWRP Pipeline Contract 1 in Singapore where it will bore 1.6km with the inner diameter

Read more ...

China’s Largest TBM - With Panda Face Emerges From Tunnel
On 12 December 2022 ‘Jinxiu’ - China’s largest EPB TBM developed by CRCHI - marked the first smooth breakthrough of the Jinxiu Tunnel, a key control project of the Chengdu-Zigong high-speed railway. Jinxiu is China’s largest diameter EPB TBM with

Read more ...

STRUCINSPECT Technology Transforms Inspection of Los Angeles Metro Tunnel Network
With drones, multispectral optics, and AI, Austrian joint venture transforms tunnel inspection in the US. The world’s first infrastructure lifecycle hub taps the rapidly growing global market for infrastructure inspections. The remarkable thing about

Read more ...

CRCHI showcases total solutions of Underground Engineering Equipment
China Railway Construction Heavy Industry Corporation Limited (CRCHI) brought the whole industry chain products and solutions to bauma CONEXPO INDIA 2023. CRCHI exhibited TBMs, drilling and blasting method equipment, cotton pickers, and other

Read more ...

Sandvik sets up new factory; hands over first ‘made in India’ tunnelling jumbo to KSR Group, Hyderabad
In a historic event held on 30th January, 2023 Sandvik proudly presented the key of the first ‘made in India’ DT820 Tunnelling Jumbo to Mrs. and Mr. Koneru of KSR Group, Hyderabad. The machine was rolled out from Sandvik’s newly set-up state-of-the-art

Read more ...

CRCHI Slurry TBM ‘Avni’ Helps Make a Breakthrough in Bangalore Metro Project
The 6.6m Slurry TBM developed by CRCHI exited the tunnel at Vellara Station, Phase II of Bangalore Metro in India, becoming the first TBM to complete the breakthrough for the whole line of the project. Avni is one of the four slurry TBMs provided by CRCHI

Read more ...

The Bolter Miner - A Technology Revolution for Roadway Development in Underground Coal Mining
In India, coal is still the primary source of energy; over the past few years, there has been quantum jump in coal production level, but it was mostly due to the high percentage share from the opencast sector. The country is witnessing a fast

Read more ...

CRCHI emerges as provider of total underground engineering equipment and solutions
China Railway Construction Heavy Industry Corporation Limited (CRCHI) showcased its comprehensive range of equipment and products at bauma that included solutions for the whole industry chain in the field of

Read more ...

Herrenknecht AG wins bauma Innovation Award 2022 for development of continuous tunnelling
Herrenknecht AG won the highly coveted award bauma Innovation Award 2022 in the category “Machine Technology” for the new development of continuous tunnelling. The award was given for the next innovation boost in the mechanized

Read more ...

The Genesis of Underground Engineering
Regardless of the tunnelling technology used, tunnel designers decide the future success or failure at an early project stage. In fact, designers are the real managers of tunnel construction. The choice of design together with selected contract model is

Read more ...

Managing Geological Complexity in BVC and PAC of Tehri PSP, India - A case study
Tehri hydroelectric project is located on the left bank of River Bhagirathi in the state of Uttarakhand. Tehri Pumped Storage Project (PSP) comprising 4 Nos of reversible pump-turbine units of 250 MW each, involves construction of an underground Machine Hall

Read more ...

TBM driving under low overburden by adopting innovative methodology
TBM mining in urban areas particularly under low overburden (less than 0.5D, D = tunnel Dia) is a big challenge to design team as well as execution team. While working in a Lucknow metro project, the metro authorities encountered a stretch where TBM had to cross

Read more ...

Tunnel Ventilation System Basic Concepts and Designing Principles
The term ventilation combines several functions such as smoke extraction, pollution ventilation, and ventilation for environmental purpose. The design of a ventilation system is usually based on three scenarios: During construction: to provide external

Read more ...

CRCHI Mega Slurry TBM ‘Jinghua’ Assists the First Tunnel Section Breakthrough of Beijing East Sixth Ring Road Reconstruction Project
In September 2022, the Beijing East Sixth Ring Road Reconstruction Project reported another good news: the CRCHI mega slurry TBM ‘Jinghua’ smoothly reached the intermediate air shaft, marking the project’s achievement. The maximum excavation diameter

Read more ...

TERRATEC EPBMs ready to tackle Kanpur Metro’s 1st Underground Section in India
TERRATEC celebrated the successful site acceptance testing of two 6.52m diameter Earth Pressure Balance Tunnel Boring Machines (EPBMs) for Uttar Pradesh Metro Rail Corporation (UPMRC) for Corridor-1 of Kanpur MRTS Project (KNPCC-05) in India. The two 6.52m

Read more ...

Tunnelling Asia 2022 - International Conference on Underground Space
Tunnelling Asia 2022, organized by TAI, which took place in Mumbai during 27th and 28th June, saw a huge gathering of delegates/engineers from all around the world. The theme of the conference: ‘Underground Space: Need of the Day’ focused on

Read more ...

Hydraulic Heave Failure Mitigation Approach for the construction of the Deepest Metro Ventilation and Egress Shaft in India
Dr. Lakshmana Rao Mantri, Assistant General Manager (Designs), and Satya Narayan Kunwar, Project Manager, AFCONS Infrastructure Ltd. , discuss the design and construction challenges of constructing India’s deepest underground metro ventilation

Read more ...

Creating Zero-Carbon Tunnels
Despite a daunting timeline set by the Paris Accord, zero-carbon tunnels are within reach, provided the right solutions are implemented. Er. Vasileios (Bill) Paoulos, CMT, CMRL, L&T Construction Heavy Civil Infrastructure

Read more ...

Readily Biodegradable Soil Conditioning Foaming Agents - A New Technology
Mike A. Sposetti, Global Technical Manager TBM, Underground Construction, Master Builders Solution, Malta, and Manish Gautam, Product Segment Manager - UGC TBM Tunneling Projects, Master Builders Solution, Mumbai, discuss how readily biodegradable

Read more ...