Transit Oriented

By Vishnu P. Sudarsan & Tanvi Trivedi

Transit Oriented Development (TOD) complements the concept of new urbanism. Compact, mixed-use communities are the answer to suburban problems. Due to the dynamic nature and multiplicity of underlying features and definitions of TOD, no umbrella strategy works for all cities. Every city is different in nature and has a unique fingerprint, therefore, to make a successful strategy for TOD it is important to list out specific indicators or key components for measuring the TOD scope of a city.

TOD categorisation helps answer questions such as ‘‘what mixed uses of public transit will optimize effective mixed-use development and support efficiency under specific conditions (for example, in areas with different levels of density/population)’’ or ‘‘what densities and level of transit service are necessary”. These questions not only help design better TOD policies but also help in evaluating them against success or failure on set parameters. For example, while increased density has the potential to increase ridership, it may result in negative implications on the fronts of social equity and quality of living. As a result, a fine balance needs to be achieved between various factors for a successful TOD environment.

Indian cities are plagued with issues such as rising population and underdeveloped public transport systems, which have led to a rapid rise of personal vehicles, traffic congestion, and increasing pollution. The majority of the population does not use public transport because of the lack of it and inaccessibility to the transit. Hence, planning for accessibility is the need of the hour. The most important reasons for implementing TOD in Indian cities is the emphasis on public transport by all levels of government.

One of the fundamental challenges is that the regulatory framework of most municipalities is not supportive of TOD. Cities have zoning ordinances and land development codes designed for automobile-oriented development. The conditions regarding physical requirements under the zoning ordinances often prohibit the development necessary for TOD. Provisions such as maximum floor area ratio, height limitations, landscaping requirements and minimum parking requirements often cause an impediment to develop and incorporate TOD seamlessly into the existing regulatory framework of the cities.

The Ministry of Urban Development has come out with a multi-pronged policy viz., the ‘National Transit Oriented Development Policy’ (the TOD policy), which seeks to provide a viable solution to challenges like haphazard urban growth and sprawl, mobility, rapidly rising private vehicles on roads, pollution, housing choices etc. The policy seeks to shift current practices to encourage denser, healthier, more productive cities. It recommends transit and land use strategies for compact, mixed-use development, that gives citizens access both to open space and transport services. Additionally, the policy envisages ‘value capture financing’ by means of enhanced or additional land value tax, betterment levies, development charges or impact fees, transfer of development rights, etc. The resources generated, thereby, would be credited into a fund for urban transport (development, upgradation, maintenance, enhancement, etc.)

TOD is already being implemented at the ground level in various cities such as Delhi, Naya Raipur, Ahmedabad, and Haryana. The Delhi Master Plan 2021 has TOD policy included; it provides for mobility options for all, better quality of life, housing for all, cheaper public transport and mixed-use development. The Haryana Government, Town and Country Planning Department has issued TOD Policy 2016, which strives to incorporate TOD principles like allowing mixed-use development and high-density development within TOD Zones. It also highlights that additional fees collected under this policy shall be kept in a separate infrastructure development fund and utilised for MRTS projects.

To move towards a sustainable and successful TOD environment, the regulatory framework should be reflective of the following principles:

Amendment of local laws and reduction in time gap between notification and successful implementation of the TOD policy at state level: There should be suitable provisions in place for creation/designation of an agency with single-point responsibility for successful implementation in a timely manner, including notification incorporation of TOD policy into local building bye-laws. Establishment of enforcement mechanisms with penalties/ sanctions for non-compliance and delays.

Availability of Land and Land Acquisition: As TOD was not a part of city development from its inception stage, suitable parcels of land will need to be acquired to undertake TOD. Land aggregation is a major concern for the TOD policy as undertaking necessary pedestrian-friendly development would require acquisition of land along the right of way of the public transportation system. A possible solution to this challenge is land-pooling which allows land to be aggregated to enable mixed-use development. Formulation of a detailed project report that clearly identifies land parcels that need to be acquired from early stages of project development with specified time line which will aid in the success of TOD.

Increased flexibility in existing contracts and contractual commitments: The contractual framework for a TOD project needs to tie in seamlessly with the existing contractual framework for transit development projects. In case the existing contractual framework does not permit ‘expansion’ or ‘change in the original scope of work’ of the transit-oriented development, it may lead to delay in implementation of the TOD project. Existing contractual limitations in transit development project will adversely impact the implementation of the TOD project. Suitable provisions should be incorporated to allow flexibility and amendments to existing contracts.

Price and Quality Regulations in PPPs: Parking needs to be controlled through effective parking management. Amendments must be made to the local parking policies of the cities so as to deter use of private vehicles and encourage public transport as a preferred choice.

Gentrification: There is an increasing demand for housing in neighbourhoods around public transit projects. Average prices for homes near TOD areas may be costlier than in areas far from such developments. This may deter Affordable Housing. In this context, those with poor purchasing power may get replaced by the richer households through the process of Gentrification. The TOD in the influence zone maybe planned in a manner so as to facilitate Affordable Housing. The allocated minimum percentage for allowed FAR for Affordable Housing as per the present TOD policy maybe revised.

Giving teeth to the guidelines: Cities have guidelines or advisory documents instead of regulations and policies in many cases. Guidelines are simply recommendations which should be implemented, but they are not mandatory. One of the simplest examples here is the case of street guidelines, which have been developed in many cities across the country (including Delhi and Chennai), yet they carry little weight due to their advisory nature. Area Based Development within a Smart City Proposal or a city’s Transit Oriented Development Policy, present an opportunity to turn such advisory documents into regulations and policies. Bhubaneswar has proposed this in its Area Based Development, where it is implementing a complete streets policy to diversify its mode share.

Transit Oriented

To conclude, it is necessary to adopt the following:
  • provision of affordable housing
  • provision for variety of housing choices to meet the needs of all sections of society
  • progressive and flexible parking policies which deter use of privately owned vehicles and incentivise people to use mass transport
  • charging higher market rates for parking
  • encouraging walking and cycling through creation of infrastructure that’s safe
  • mainstreaming TOD as part of statutory/building/city plans and making use of innovative tools and incentives to finance TOD initiatives and projects into the existing policy framework.
There is a need for a robust policy framework governing TOD in India which is applied across national and state levels.

Vishnu P. Sudarsan is a Partner and Tanvi Trivedi is an Associate at J Sagar Associates. Views expressed are personal.
Click Here
To Know More or to Contact the Manufacturer
Please let us know your name.
Invalid Input
Please let us know your Designation.
Please let us know your Contact Number.
Please let us know your email address.
Please brief your query.
Our other Value-Added Services:

To receive updates through e-mail on Products, New Technologies & Equipment, please select the Product Category(s) you are interested in and click 'Submit'. This will help you save time plus you will get the best price quotations from many manufacturers, which you can then evaluate and negotiate.

Invalid Input
Invalid Input
Invalid Input
Equipment with cutting edge technologies is making tunneling smoother at RVNL’s mega railway project and helping contractors overcome geological complexities. Sandvik’s DT 821 C and DT 922i advanced automatic

Read more ...

The Metro-Rail segment in India is growing at a frantic pace with positive long-term prospects, supported by the impetus provided by the government by way of business-friendly policies and financial support. Use of advanced

Read more ...

Lucknow Metro has achieved the distinction of becoming the fastest built metro rail project in the country - both in terms of completion of construction work and execution. On 25th November 2013, LMRCL

Read more ...

India received its first mode of modern transportation in 1853 when the first railway line was laid from Bombay to Thane to boost industrial activities and ensure easy accessibility to heavy raw materials. In the following

Read more ...

The growth of the tunnel construction in the country has been driven by a robust pipeline of projects and investments in setting up hydropower projects, developing urban mass rapid transit systems, improving road

Read more ...

Stoked by their debut success with the timely completion of Kajang Line’s underground section, Gamuda Engineering found themselves pitted once more against the unique challenges of tunnelling in Kuala Lumpur

Read more ...

A tunnelling project is a race against time and costs. Getting it right from the very beginning requires knowledge, skill and experience, as well as a proper range of equipment that fulfils the customer’s tunnelling

Read more ...

The Mumbai-Nagpur Expressway is delayed until 2022. In the meantime, a machine ‘GHH IS26’ with remarkable reliability has been specially flown in from the supplier and is in operation to help complete the project

Read more ...

The project, located at the riverside of the Moscow River, passes under heavy traffic and crowded buildings. It includes two sections of a total length of 2947m. One is from Maple Avenue Station to No.2 Working Shaft

Read more ...

Pull Force is the force that a truck or prime mover can exert onto a transporter or any type of trailer. It has been a subject of much controversy and misunderstandings as truck manufacturers and end-users often do not talk

Read more ...

The first Sandvik DT922i, a computer controlled fully automatic tunneling jumbo, has been introduced by Sandvik Mining and Rock Technology in India with a vision to achieve high levels of safety, productivity and

Read more ...

Horizontal Directional Drilling is a technology in pipe and utility installation that allows greater accuracy and flexibility in placement and ends the need for costly digging, large crews, road closures and other

Read more ...

Special knowledge is required for building tunnels and wind energy plants in order to implement demanding projects. The facilities and manufacturing processes required for such projects can be adjusted well in advance for

Read more ...

The Large Hadron Collider (LHC) at CERN is the biggest particle accelerator in the world – and growing. To equip the LHC for new, more ambitious experiments in the next decade, the accelerator is currently

Read more ...

The river has its source at over 3000 meters high in the snow-covered Andes. It reaches the Pacific Ocean after 250 km. On its way, it overcomes a considerable gradient and is, therefore, ideally suited to generate electricity

Read more ...

Tan Shunhui, Chairman, CREG, discusses the competitive advantages of the company’s tunneling equipment and solutions, emerging opportunities in developing countries, factors driving its growth and success across

Read more ...

15-meter mega Slurry TBM rolled off the assembly line at CRCHI. The excavation diameter of the equipment is 15.01 m, its total length is about 130 m, total weight is about 4300 t, installed power is about 9755 kW, rated

Read more ...

Being the longest water delivery line in the history of Jilin province, transferring water from Songhua River into Central Jilin Province will transfer the largest capacity of water and cover the largest areas. The water diversion

Read more ...

Amit Kaul, BASF India Limited (Construction Chemicals Division), India, tells about the innovative tunnel lining system and related design aspects, and also describes the main advantages of this lining system in comparison

Read more ...

Underground infrastructures are an integral part of modern cities as they serve to counter problems of surface congestion and environmental degradation. The problems of ground vibrations, vibration induced noise and ground

Read more ...

×
Sign-up for Free Subscription
'India Construction Week'
Weekly e-Newsletter on Construction Industry
Get the latest news, product launches, projects announced / awarded, government policies, investments, and expert views.