Vivek Singh, Founder, BuildStreet

Economization of Road Subgrade Material by Mechanical Stabilization

Subgrade makes the formation level of the road crust. The material specifications of subgrade material are therefore more demanding than the soil used in general fill or embankment. In some construction projects, it becomes difficult to get the required subgrade material at an economical lead. In such cases, the properties of locally available materials are required to be improved by stabilising them, either chemically or mechanically, in order to use them as subgrade material. One such case study where the available soil was stabilised mechanically and utilised as subgrade material is presented hereunder.

The Problem
In a city infrastructure project, the CBR value of locally available soil was not meeting the design requirement of 8%. Availability of required quality of subgrade soil was at a lead of 50 km from the project site.

Impact
  • Increase in the cost of subgrade construction due to haulage cost
  • Number of haulage trucks needed to be increased to keep pace with the project schedule
Visible Options
  • Lime Stabilisation
  • Cement Stabilisation
  • Using some stabilising agent
Limitations
Lime or Cement Stabilisation was not helping in reducing the cost. Getting approval for any stabilising agent was a lengthy process and would have taken a lot of time.

Opportunity
There were some stone quarries in the nearby areas whose overburden was a highly weathered rock. In its present stage, it was like gravely soil with nil PI value. The material was available at an attractive landed price since the supply was higher than the demand. An initial study was conducted in which this material was mixed with the soil available in the embankment Borrow Area and an improvement in CBR was observed.

Detailed Study and Lab Tests
Following tests were conducted for this study on Borrow Area Soil, Granular Material (Quarry Overburden Material) and their blends (80:20 & 90:10):
  • Index properties
  • Grain size analysis
  • CBR tests on blended material
The test results are tabulated below.

S. No. Material Gravel Content Sand Content Fines Content Plasticity/ Classification CBR
1 Granular (Quarry Overburden) Material 85% 13% 2% NP >100%
2 Borrow Area Soil 0% 5% 95% MI-ML around 5%
3 80% Soil+20% Granular 17% 9% 74% NP 27% (average)
4 90% Soil+10% Granular 8% 9% 83% NP 20% (average)
Methodology of Work
  1. Soil and Granular Material were dumped on the bed in three layers in the following sequence:
    1. Soil in loose thickness so as to attain a compacted thickness of 75mm
    2. Granular material in a loose thickness so as to attain a compacted thickness of 50mm
  2. All three layers were uniformly mixed with the help of a rotovator
  3. Required water added followed by grading to attain required level and camber
  4. Rolling pattern of “1 plain pass+1 pass with High Vibration+1 pass with Low Vibration+ 1 pass with High Vibration” was found good to attain greater than 97% compaction during the mock-up trial.
Cost Analysis
Cost analysis was done considering the following attributes:
  • Landed cost of overburden material to the stockyard
  • Landed cost of soil (from maximum 27 km average lead)
  • Cost of inter-carting of granular material from stock to the roadbed
  • Cost of in-situ mixing of soil and overburden material
The above cost was then compared with the cost of conventional subgrade construction from the borrow area at a 50-52 km average lead.

SL No. Description UOM Quantity Rate
(Rs Per Cum)
 Amount (Cr.)
1 Use of Borrow earth in Subgrade incl. (without granular material & 50 To 52 Km as average lead) L.cu.m. 10 523 52.3
2 Use of Soil (80%- With 27 Km as average Lead) and Granular Material (20%) Mix in Subgrade incl. (without granular material) L.cu.m. 10 494 49.4
Saving In Option 2 Over Option 1  Rs. (Cr) 2.9  
  % 5.9
Discussions
Over and above the lab tests, a close observation was done during the rainy season. Due to the very nature of the project the construction traffic was bound to ply over the prepared beds during the monsoon. The mechanically stabilised layer had clearly shown a very good improvement in performance when traffic was plying directly over it. This soil, when not stabilised, used to become weak when exposed to rainfall even after compaction and could not bear the load of even light vehicles.

The reason for the soil (un-stabilised) to behave (as mentioned above) was probably because it was uniformly graded silt (95-100% fines). As is evident from the test results, the blended material has got all three major grades of soil (Gravel, Sand, and Fines) which makes it a well-graded material that is more stable and easily compactable. The shear strength of well-graded soil is always better than uniformly graded soil and hence also the CBR.

The improvement in the most desired subgrade soil property, CBR, was clearly evident when the granular material is mixed with the fine-grained soil. A few points to be noted:
  • Less than 10% of granular material was not considered blending because of the mixing method chosen. Lesser proportion can be considered if:
    1. the mixing is done at the plant using a pug mill
    2. if it can be proved that uniform mixing can be done by site mixing method (s).
  • In spite of getting the desired CBR value at 10% quarry overburden, it was proposed to mix 20% so as to eliminate all possible errors and ensure the required CBR of subgrade in the absence of any data on process performance.
  • The CBR was conducted on the site mixed material on a regular basis i.e., samples were collected from the bed after mixing and grading and before compaction. This was done to measure the performance of the site process as well as for quality control. The CBR values of such samples were generally between 20 - 27% and the minimum CBR which was ever found was 15%.
The statistical analysis of the CBR values of field samples was conducted and the mix was re-designed to the proportion of 85:15:Soil:Granular. This enhanced the cost saving to 10.5%. The costing may change from situation to situation; hence, detailed working must be done before taking a decision.

Conclusion
The following were the enhancement in value for different stakeholders:
  • 80% of the locally available soil got utilised
  • Reduction of costlier material, the soil, by 20% and 15% has resulted in cost savings of 5.9% and 10.5%, respectively
  • A good process control not only ensures good quality but also ensures savings in cost
  • Resources saving in terms of reduction in the number of haulage trucks achieved
  • Faster construction because of lesser transportation and stacking of overburden
  • Lesser carbon footprints than using cement or lime
  • Ensured quality subgrade constructed by ensuring 15% min. CBR against the design requirement of 8%.
Atasi Das, Assistant Vice President, G R Infraprojects, explains the concept of the Perpetual Pavement in India’s expressway constructions and its practical implementation with due consideration of layers, materials, and thicknesses

Read more ...

Dr. Rakesh Kumar, Senior Principal Scientist & Pankaj Goel, Senior Technical Officer, Rigid Pavements Division,CSIR-Central Road Research Institute (CRRI), New Delhi, give information on the Performance of Curing Compounds in Strengthening

Read more ...

The construction and maintenance of roads with flexible pavements in very cold regions where annual temperatures range between +30oC to -35oC has got its own challenges. The bitumen in the asphalt layer becomes hard at such low temperatures

Read more ...

The Bundelkhand site team achieved yet another feat on 15 Jan 2022 by completing 13 deck slabs of varying types in just 46 days. Therefore, it is a demonstration of exemplary display of overall project executing capabilities

Read more ...

Er. Devjyoti Paul, Project Manager & Er. Harpreet Singh, Chief Project Manager, B&SEC, share the technical and construction features of three bowstring girder ROBs, recently constructed under Package I & III of Purvanchal Expressway in the state of Uttar Pradesh

Read more ...

Use of Extruded Polystyrene Sheets (XPS) in the construction of the Zojila Approach Road has been especially effective as XPS is the most suitable, convenient, and cheaper solution for mitigating frost action on pavements, increasing the life of pavements

Read more ...

The Indian road network is the second largest globally, with a length of around 63.86 lakh km. The outbreak of the virus towards end-FY20 had created panic globally, leading to the temporary suspension of economic activity

Read more ...

Roads and Railways boost awards; tenders up marginally Overall tendering grew 5% YoY during H1FY22 Awarding activity grew at a 2-year CAGR of 22% in H1FY22 Infrastructure credit near all-time highs

Read more ...

There are many challenges being faced by the highway sector such as ensuring availability of construction materials and machinery, timely completion of projects, availability of trained human resources

Read more ...

Practical Recommendations for Construction of Longitudinal Joints in Hot Mix Asphalt (HMA) Pavements Rajib B. Mallick, Ralph White Family Distinguished Professor, Civil and Environmental Engineering, Worcester Polytechnic Institute (WPI), Massachusetts, USA, and Veeraragavan

Read more ...

Plant and Equipment Determine Quality of Road Construction Road Infrastructure projects are time constrained; early completion of project entitles rewards while delays attract penalties. The plants and equipment being used determines the quality of the road

Read more ...

Designing roads and highways efficiently with the right materials will help achieve optimum construction cost, lower maintenance, and reduce life cycle costs. Ash from coal-fired thermal power

Read more ...

Rodic Consultants has emerged as a leader in the infrastructure consulting space with state-of-the-art engineering solutions, and a proven track record of timely completion of projects across sectors

Read more ...

Readymade Kandhal Pothole Patching Mix was adopted as Indian Roads Congress (IRC) Standard Specification IRC: 116-2014 for Readymade Bituminous Pothole Patching Mix Using Cut-Back Bitumen. All concerned

Read more ...

The Bundelkhand Expressway is a 296-km long, 4-lane wide (expandable to 6 lanes) access-controlled expressway in the state of Uttar Pradesh. It will connect Gonda village in Chitrakoot district with Agra–Lucknow

Read more ...

This case study briefly discusses the planning, design and construction of Package 3 of the Purvanchal Expressway. Package-3 of the Purvanchal Expressway is a 41.7km long section of the 340.82km long

Read more ...

Since the 1980’s billions of dollars have been invested in developing methods to make pavement design and construction more sustainable through the re-use of existing resources. This includes insitu recycling and

Read more ...

India has the second largest road network in the world, spanning a total of 5.89 million km, transporting 64.5% of all goods in the country. Nearly 90% of India's total passenger traffic uses the road network to commute

Read more ...

India generates nearly 26,000 tonnes of plastic waste every day, making it the 15th biggest plastic polluter globally. Discarded plastic waste litter the country’s roads, rivers and also form huge mounds in garbage

Read more ...

×
Sign-up for Free Subscription
'India Construction Week'
Weekly e-Newsletter on Construction Industry
Get the latest news, product launches, projects announced / awarded, government policies, investments, and expert views.
Click here to subscribe.