RERA: Law of the Land?

Samantak Das
Dr. Samantak Das, Chief Economist & National Director- Research- Knight Frank India

It is nearly a year since the Indian realty entered a new paradigm with the on-set of nationwide implementation of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (RERA). As the first anniversary of RERA draws closer, so does the knowledge that the implementation across states is nowhere close to its goal. While the state-level dilution of the Act on aspects like definition of ongoing projects and punishment for violations is well observed, in this white paper we have delved into the establishment of the RERA machinery across the country. Taking stock of the current scenario, some issues have come to light that are vital for the implementation of RERA in the true letter and spirit of the Act.

A LOT of ground to be covered!

Real estate is a state subject and the central government formulated Act is a model Act, which is then re-drawn and adopted by the states. Since 1st May 2016, when the central law came into effect with 60 out of 92 sections, a complete one year time until implementation was available at the disposal of states for establishment of the RERA machinery. Subsequently, the remaining 32 sections came into force on May 1, 2017.

Further, 3 months (1st May 2017 to 31st July 2017) were provided to promoters for registration of on-going projects. In the past one year, RERA compliance in some markets has been a prominent factor for price rationalisation in the residential segment as it has put a break on pre-sales activities and fund mobilisation by developers at the once popular “soft launch” stage. There have been instances where developers have resorted to selling inventory at a marked discount in a bid to raise finances as no sales at pre-launch stage are allowed now. New supply in the residential segment has also taken a massive hit as RERA compliance and mounting unsold inventory pressures have forced developers to curtail launches. In 2017, new residential supply across the top eight Indian cities (Ahmedabad, Bengaluru, Chennai, Hyderabad, Kolkata, Mumbai, NCR, and Pune) plunged by 41% over 2016. NCR was the worst hit market where a 56% annual drop was noted. However, the progress on RERA compliance across the country still presents a gloomy picture.

RERA Rules not yet notified in... West Bengal, Arunachal Pradesh, Manipur, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Nagaland, Sikkim and Tripura.

Facts at a glance
  • Total States in India: 29
  • Total Union Territories in India: 7
  • RERA is applicable across 28 States (except Jammu and Kashmir) and 7 UTs
Table 1: RERA Implementation Summary
  STAGE I STAGE II STAGE III STAGE IV
Number of States 20 20 14 10
Number of Union Territories (UTs) 7 7 5 5
Source: Knight Frank Research
Note: The table above includes states and UTs with both Permanent and Interim Real Estate Regulators and Appellate Tribunals As per information on April 23rd, 2018.

Most states and Union Territories (UTs) have followed a quasi-implementation route which does not amount to creation of an effective regulator that has started delivering on its intent. Maharashtra is the only exception where the regulator's proactive functioning has set new precedents every second day. Currently, more than 25,000 projects have been registered under RERA across India, out of which 62% are in Maharashtra alone.

Most states and Union Territories (UTs) have followed a quasi-implementation route which does not amount to creation of an effective regulator that has started delivering on its intent. Maharashtra is the only exception where the regulator's proactive functioning has set new precedents every second day.

Currently, more than 25,000 projects have been registered under RERA across India, out of which 62% are in Maharashtra alone. But in some states, extension of deadlines for project registration is still underway. For instance, in Goa, the deadline was extended till February 2018. The delay caused in registering projects also restricts the information that can be supplied to consumers via functional portals. At present, only 19 states and UTs have a functional portal in place, that too with a lot of information dissymmetry across data points. In Andhra Pradesh, only two projects are registered under RERA. Haryana still does not have a portal, and the status of projects registered manually remains unknown.

Similarly, while the number of live projects in Bengaluru alone stands at around 1,300, the total number of projects registered for the entire state of Karnataka is only 1,500. The progress on establishment of a Real Estate Appellate Tribunal is far more disappointing with only 15 out of the 35 (states and UTs) having made progress on this parameter.

Permanent Regulator in 25 states yet to see light of the day!
While the Central act permitted states to designate any regulatory authority as the Real Estate Regulatory Authority, it did not define any timeline when such an “Interim” Regulator should cease to exist. In addition, since the interim regulators are only “designated” as a Real Estate Authority, it is only an additional responsibility for them to implement the rules and regulations as per RERA. Hence, their efforts fall short of the intended goal of a dedicated real estate regulator.

RERA: Law of the Land?
Sections 20 to 39 of the Central RERA outlining the process for setting up a Real Estate Regulatory Authority came in force two years ago, but only 3 states (Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, and Punjab) have established a permanent one so far. The devil, as we know, is in the detail. Firstly, while the Central act permitted states to designate any regulatory authority as the Real Estate Regulatory Authority, it did not define any timeline when such an “Interim” Regulator should cease to exist. Secondly, since the interim regulators are only “designated” as a Real Estate Authority, it is only an additional responsibility for them to implement the rules and regulations as per RERA. Hence, their efforts fall short of the intended goal of a dedicated real estate regulator. From the consumers' perspective, RERA implementation and compliance needs undivided attention and focus from regulators for smooth operations.

Sadly, most states have been playing the waiting game about getting a Permanent Regulator after handing over the reins to such “Interim” authorities. What was strictly supposed to be a stopgap arrangement has turned into a standard. Such authorities are making half-hearted attempts as evident by progress on even basic parameters like getting the portals up and running, registering projects and agents. Since the Central RERA also stipulates transfer of all applications, complaints or pending cases to Permanent Regulators, the “Interim” regulators seem to let the grass grow under its feet.

At present, 25 Indian states are yet to establish Permanent Real Estate Regulators.

The actual functions of a permanent real estate regulator are to facilitate the growth and promotion of a healthy, transparent and competitive real estate market. These include making recommendations to the government on measures to (i) encourage investments in real estate (ii) creation of a single window approval system (iii) encourage grading of projects on various development parameters as well as grading of promoters and (iv) measures to facilitate digitisation of land records.

Dispute conciliation between promoters and buyers is only one of the functions. But most states are far away from the whole nine yards. Until the permanent regulators are off the ground, the shift to an organised real estate market would be difficult. If the regulators don't evolve into institutions with the necessary experience in understanding the ground level challenges faced by participants, they cannot be their eyes and ears to represent their interests.

Table 2: What are the disadvantages if the Interim Real Estate Regulators continue to operate?
  • Focus of regulators, whether permanent or interim, is to maintain RERA compliance visibility. However, with interim regulators, creation of an information rich portal and supporting infrastructure still remains work in progress. Hence buyers are left with no other choice but to resort to third party information for real estate due diligence.
  • The administrative nonchalance puts a big question mark on the efficacy with which consumer disputes are addressed, ruled and made available to public at large.
  • Several officers in interim regulators are heads of state level development departments, development authorities and housing boards. This raises a very pertinent question – will there be no conflict of interest when these officers have to evaluate cases pertaining to projects where the said bodies are promoters/developers? In all likelihood, justice in real estate rulings would be tainted by bias.
RERA judgments reinstating consumer confidence

Recent judgments by MahaRERA have been successful in restoring buyer sentiment in under construction projects and addressing intricacies of the construction development process. Some judgments have been delivered within 30 days of complaint filing. Since its constitution, MahaRERA has ruled in over 1000 cases with the first ruling coming in September 2017.
  • Nature of complaints pertained to delay in possession of the flats where buyers had issues with the revised completion timeline of the projects indicated on the RERA website, ambiguity in regulatory approvals and slow construction pace.
  • Our previous studies indicate 78% of these complaints were settled in favor of consumers between August and Dec 2017.
  • Prompt rulings such as imposing fines on erring developers who are advertising projects without RERA numbers, returning advance to buyers with interest in case of non-delivery of flats, helping allottees and promoters reach amicable grounds were unprecedented when real estate was not governed by any law in India.
  • In case of an aggrieved developer's complaint to MahaRERA regarding part payment by a buyer citing extension of delivery timeline as a reason for non- payment, MahaRERA asked the developer to advance the completion date as well as instructed the buyer to pay the remaining amount in proportion to completion of the project within 45 days to the developer.
  • In a recent case, the Real Estate Appellate Tribunal held MahaRERA accountable for an oversight in reviewing an architect undertaking. A good example of the type of scrutiny a Real Estate Appellate Tribunal can provide, if in place.
By resolving cases on merit basis, MahaRERA is able to meet consumers' expectations of a fast-tracked redressal mechanism and bring about a change in the attitude of real estate developers towards consumers. Karnataka has also started moving in a similar direction with prompt rulings in 63 cases. In Haryana, a private builder was recently fined with INR 3 million for wrongfully advertising an unregistered residential project. However, consumers still continue shopping around at multiple forums to file grievances until the issue gets resolved as an effective regulator does not exist in all states.
The scope of functions of the newly created Central Advisory Council (CAC) should be broadened to include advisory to state bodies on issues related to RERA compliance. It should hand hold state governments to create support infrastructure.

Table 3: What MahaRERA got right?
  • Registering projects, agents and getting the portal up and running.
  • Fast-tracking consumer complaints; speedy rulings.
  • Setting up Conciliation Forum to reduce number of formal complaints and provide cheaper litigation option to consumers to resolve issues amicably.
  • Real Estate Appellate Tribunal evolving into a reliable watchdog.
  • Planning to implement a GIS based mapping for registered projects in future.
Way forward

Dilution of the Central RERA presents a report card which is a picture of despair. Despite positive economic sentiment, the confidence of buyers is still not back. In our view, the following recommendations might salvage the Centre's vision and help RERA meet its desired objectives:
  1. It is time for Centre to step in and bring out stringent penalties for non-complaint states. The state governments had ample time to put regulatory machinery in line with the ground realities and their liability should not end with setting up interim authorities.
  2. The scope of functions of the newly created Central Advisory Council (CAC) should be broadened to include advisory to state bodies on issues related to RERA compliance. It should hand hold state governments to create support infrastructure.
  3. CAC's role should be widened to encompass feedback from industry stakeholders that can be channeled into actionable insights regionally.
  4. A digital platform or portal for Central RERA should also be in place where regular updates on RERA implementation by states should be made available to consumers at large to remove ambiguity about the extent of RERA compliance in each state.
  5. Creating a common RERA portal for remaining states where either manual registration is in place or hasn't started should be the priority. By employing a common vendor for developing the digital interface, the development costs of such a portal can be shared by states. This will save a lot of time and also make real estate information accessible to consumers faster.
  6. Efforts should be made to reach interiors of the state so as to ensure that the coverage is not limited to just a handful of top cities of that state.
Land being a state subject, “One Nation, One RERA” is only wishful thinking. However, given the impactful stature of MahaRERA after an eventful first year, the new eco- system hence created has made the process transparent for buyers.

Other states struggling to implement RERA can learn from Maharashtra's strategy and replicate its success to bring the buyers back to under construction projects.

© Knigh t Frank Indi a Pvt . Ltd.
This report is published for general information only and not to be relied upon in anyway. Although high standards have been used in the preparation of the information analysis, views and projections presented in the report, no responsibility or liability whatsoever can be accepted by Knight Frank for any loss or damage resultant from any use of, reliance on or reference to the contents of this document.

As a general report this material does not necessarily represent the view of Knight Frank in relation to particular properties or projects. Reproduction of this report in whole or in part is not allowed without prior written approval of Knight Frank to the form and content within which it appears.
NBM&CW May 2018
Women At Work : Breaking Barriers

Women At Work : Breaking Barriers

This feature highlights the important role women employees are playing in male dominated industries like civil engineering, and the contributions they are making towards their company’s progress with their professional approach and skill

Read more ...

Minimol Korulla - Head - Strategic Projects and Initiatives, Maccaferri ISEAP

Minimol Korulla - Head - Strategic Projects and Initiatives, Maccaferri ISEAP

I was born in a village in Kerala which was surrounded by a river and every monsoon the roads would become flooded. Better bridges began to be built from the 1970s, connecting us to the outside world. My encounter with the subject

Read more ...

Dola Roychowdhury - Founding Director, G-Cube Consulting Engineers

Dola Roychowdhury - Founding Director, G-Cube Consulting Engineers

The Construction Industry is one of the most male-dominated amongst all the STEM fields, though women have contributed significantly to it by continuing to crash barriers, break ceilings, and sometimes shifting their goal

Read more ...

Rubee Kongbrailatpam - Superintending Engineer, PWD, Manipur

Rubee Kongbrailatpam - Superintending Engineer, PWD, Manipur

After completing my B.Tech, I joined as a lecturer in an Engineering College, but after a year into it, I joined the State Engineering Services as an Assistant Engineer. After subsequent promotions, I’m currently serving as a Superintending

Read more ...

Sujatha Manoj - Technical Director & Geotechnical Services Leader, Australia, Beca

Sujatha Manoj - Technical Director & Geotechnical Services Leader, Australia, Beca

After graduating as a Civil Engineer from TKM Engineering College, my first challenge was to find a good job. In a city like Mumbai this was tough especially considering the fact that I had no previous work experience and had no one

Read more ...

Annapoorni Iyer - Chartered Engineer, Founder of Engosym Consultants for Infrastructure development projects

Annapoorni Iyer - Chartered Engineer, Founder of Engosym Consultants for Infrastructure development projects

I have done my B.E.(Civil) from DMCOE (2001 batch) and MBA (Infra and Contracts) from MIT, Pune. DMCOE gave me a clear vision about my career choice and I began to study each subject of civil engineering in depth. I found that my

Read more ...

Dr Barnali Ghosh - FICE, Mott MacDonald, London, UK

Dr Barnali Ghosh - FICE, Mott MacDonald, London, UK

I was first introduced to Geotechnical Engineering during my undergraduate days. What fascinated me most about this field of engineering was that soil was so unpredictable! Unlike concrete, you could not assign a set strength to it, and

Read more ...

Dr. Yogini Deshpande - Renuka Consultants

Dr. Yogini Deshpande - Renuka Consultants

I hold a PhD in Civil Engineering from Purdue University, USA (2006), a Bachelor’s Degree in Civil Engineering, and a Master’s in Geotechnical Engineering from Mumbai University. Prior to pursuing a PhD, I worked as a Senior

Read more ...

Dr. Ambika Behl - Senior Principal Scientist at CSIR-CRRI, New Delhi

Dr. Ambika Behl - Senior Principal Scientist at CSIR-CRRI, New Delhi

My journey in the construction sector started in 2005 as a technical executive in a private construction chemical company and then as a scientist in the Central Road Research Institute in the year 2007. It has been an experiential journey

Read more ...

Dr. Naveet Kaur - Senior Scientist, Indian Structural Health Monitoring Society (ISHMS)

Dr. Naveet Kaur - Senior Scientist, Indian Structural Health Monitoring Society (ISHMS)

I completed B.Tech. in Civil Engineering from Thapar University, Punjab in 2007 and M.Tech. in Structural Engineering from IIT Delhi in 2011, where I topped the 2011 batch and was awarded the NBCC Award of Excellence. I later completed

Read more ...

Atasi Das - GR Infraprojects Limited

Atasi Das - GR Infraprojects Limited

After completing my post-graduate studies in the US, I went on to have a successful career in the country, where my child was born as well. I resumed my duties at the private consultancy in the US within 6 weeks leaving my child under

Read more ...

Dr. Madhavi Latha Gali - Geotechnical Engineer, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore

Dr. Madhavi Latha Gali - Geotechnical Engineer, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore

My major interest lies in developing resilient geotechnical systems through various innovative reinforcing techniques. I did my Ph.D. at IIT Madras and joined IISc after working for a year at IIT Guwahati. My 20-year tenure at IISc

Read more ...

Natalia Rucinska - Environmental Director, Menard Group

Natalia Rucinska - Environmental Director, Menard Group

At the age of 24, as a young graduate with the title of MSc in Geotechnical Engineering, I dreamt big. I wanted to see what the world had to offer, and I was open to exploring the adventures that came my way. I had the itch to live a full

Read more ...

Ishita Manjrekar - Director, Sunanda Global and Board of American Concrete Institute

Ishita Manjrekar - Director, Sunanda Global and Board of American Concrete Institute

I am a Chemical Engineer with a bachelor’s degree from Institute of Chemical Technology, Mumbai (erstwhile UDCT) and I hold a post-graduate degree from RPI, New York. My professional career began in the USA where I worked as Vertical

Read more ...

Sangeen Desai - Keller Ground Engineering India

Sangeen Desai - Keller Ground Engineering India

My initial years of learning were very crucial, and though challenging, they provided me with opportunities to learn and develop new skills. With strong determination and a positive attitude, I learned to work through all the challenges

Read more ...

Saranya Subramanian - Merlin Automation Solutions

Saranya Subramanian - Merlin Automation Solutions

Hailing from a humble village background, I pursued my B.E. in Mechanical Engineering at Trichy, Tamil Nadu. Driven by my career aspirations, I enrolled in an Advanced Manufacturing course at PSG College. This course, conducted on

Read more ...

Building a New India - By Fortifying the Construction Industry

Building a New India - By Fortifying the Construction Industry

In the backdrop of India's current dynamism and ambitious goals in infrastructure development, the book sheds light on the nation's journey. The construction industry's share, constituting 13% of the global GDP, is a crucial aspect

Read more ...

Robust Realty & Infra Growth to Boost Construction Sector

Robust Realty & Infra Growth to Boost Construction Sector

Spurred by the supporting economy and favourable policy initiatives by the current government, the rejuvenated real estate and infrastructure sector bodes well for the construction business, especially as the government will provide an extra

Read more ...

Realty Year-Ender: A Year of Residential & Retail Resurgence

Realty Year-Ender: A Year of Residential & Retail Resurgence

Riding high on the positive policies, and notwithstanding global headwinds, India’s resilient real estate made a mark with its impressive performance. While the residential segment saw robust demand, supply, and sales, and was on

Read more ...

Colliers leads AI revolution in construction with remote monitoring tool CoGence

Colliers leads AI revolution in construction with remote monitoring tool CoGence

Real estate advisor, Colliers, has been carving a niche in the tech space with its AI-enabled platform CoGence. Designed to detect anomalies at construction sites and generate a high precision quality report, the tool is widely being applied at several of the

Read more ...

To get latest updates on whatsapp, Save +91 93545 87773 and send us a 'Saved' message
Click Here to Subscribe to Our eNewsletter.